Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Scarborough
Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility
31 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- TTaylorGoldToronto / Ontario •7 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoWent here for the first time and it was so great. The drinks, food, service everything was incredible. Will definitely be coming back!More infoBar Romy$$$$• Italian• Entertainment District•4.3
- JJermaineToronto / Ontario •2 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoDon Alfonso was an exquisite experience from start to finish. The interior is gorgeous and the atmosphere was lively for a Friday night. It was my first time and I was blown away by the service and the presentation of the courses. Olivia was an incredible server who made my experience 10/10 once she realized I was celebrating a new milestone in my career. She went above and beyond in every aspect, while being knowledgeable about each dish and charming with her delivery. I enjoyed the L’Anatra, the Linguine and the Bisonte with a dark chocolate almond cake with vanilla ice cream as my meal. My night was ended with a lovely tour of the restaurant to celebrate the history and identity of Don Alfonso provided by Olivia herself. It was an unforgettable night and I will always recommend Don Alfonso 1890 for a night of elegance and celebration.More infoDon Alfonso 1890$$$$• Contemporary Italian• Harbourfront•4.8
- MMichaelToronto / Ontario •1 review4.0Dined 3 days agoThe covered back patio appears to be in operation year round. Heated and cozy. Service was prompt and helpful. Cocktails imaginative and fun. Food was great. The salad awesome. The meatballs (3 served with an intensely flavoured red sauce) were remarkable- the best anywhere. The nduja and shrimp pasta was terrific. My companion had the Cacio e pepe. Instead of the expected toothsome al dente bucatini, the pasta was like wide lasagna noodles wrapped in the shape of a crown. It was ok but didn’t quite provide the same effect. All in though - great. We shall return.More infoBar Vendetta$$$$• Contemporary Canadian• Little Portugal / Dundas West•4.6
- WWendyGoldToronto / Ontario •7 reviews5.0Dined on 1 Nov 2026This was 3rd visit to DaNico, outstanding as ever. From service to food- exceptional, the tasting menu was just perfect, they even made a couple exceptions that were just delicious. Our server was friendly and very knowledgeable with all the courses and took the time to chat with us, he was awesome. Cannot recommend DaNico enough for a celebration dinner, just perfect.More infoDaNico$$$$• Italian• Little Italy / College St.•4.8
- HHarmanToronto / Ontario •2 reviews5.0Dined on 12 Oct 2026I enjoyed the drinks, food and service. I also appreciate the location.More infoScaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar - Scarborough$$$$• Italian• Scarborough•4.6
Discover best Contemporary Italian restaurants in Scarborough
Explore the vibrant dining scene of Scarborough, Toronto, where contemporary Italian cuisine takes center stage. Nestled in this culturally rich area, a selection of restaurants offers a modern twist on traditional Italian dishes, appealing to both the adventurous and the classic palate. Each establishment is known for its commitment to quality, featuring fresh ingredients and creative menus that showcase the best of Italian culinary traditions with a contemporary flair. Patrons can expect a warm and inviting atmosphere, where the focus is on exceptional service and an enjoyable dining experience. These restaurants not only cater to food enthusiasts but also provide a perfect setting for both casual and special occasions. As you search for the ideal place to savor Italian cuisine in Scarborough, you'll find that these eateries stand out for their culinary excellence and welcoming ambiance, making them must-visit destinations for locals and visitors alike.