7 Best Pizza Bars In City Island

7 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Michaelangelo’s Restaurant of Arthur Ave restaurant

1. Michaelangelo’s Restaurant of Arthur Ave

4.4

Awesome(47)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Belmont

Booked 4 times today

We came for Family Weekend at Fordham. The food was absolutely delicious. Entrees included shrimp parm, lobster ravioli, eggplant parm, shrimp fra diavolo, and the heart healthy pasta. We also started with Caesar salads. Everything was excellent. We will definitely be back!

2. Fumo Upper West

4.6

Exceptional(270)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Upper West Side

Booked 37 times today

Service is always top tier and everything I’ve had on the menu is truly delicious.

3. The Onion Tree

4.7

Exceptional(58)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Sea Cliff

Booked 11 times today

Another fabulous experience at The Onion Tree. Every time I eat there, I wonder why I don’t go more often. The service is exceptional and the food is delicious, fresh and unique. My husband and I shared the onion rings, which were simply out of this world, and the chicken wings for appetizers. The chicken wings were crisp on the outside, juicy inside and had a spice mix unlike any wings you’ll get anywhere else. We then had the chicken tikka masala pizza which we devoured. Last, he had carrot cake and I had the Forbidden Rice Pudding, which were both fantastic. All in, The Onion Tree is not to be missed!

A photo of Pizza Gourmet Restaurant | Mamaroneck restaurant

4. Pizza Gourmet Restaurant | Mamaroneck

4.8

Exceptional(5)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Mamaroneck

Our new neighborhood gem - food is delicious and service is friendly. Causal and relaxing.

5. Capri 246

new

5.0

Exceptional(2)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Glen Cove

Booked 2 times today

We will be back again. The food was amazing and huge portions. Everything tasted great and our waiter Javier was a good time.

A photo of Lombardo's Scarsdale restaurant

6. Lombardo's Scarsdale

4.6

Exceptional(10)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Scarsdale

Booked 11 times today

We had gone to Lombardos to celebrate my grandsons 7th birthday and were beyond pleased with our choice. The food was delicious and the service was outstanding.

A photo of Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant restaurant

7. Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant

(0)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Upper East Side

Of course, there’s a story behind our menu. It starts with our chef’s grandparents, Maman and Mimi, who were passionate cooks based in France. In the early 1900s, they closed their Paris-based bistro and moved to Algeria. They raised a family, and their grandson, Jacques, was born – who shared their love for fantastically flavorful food. The mix of French cuisine with Algerian influences introduced them to a new variety of spices and flavors that added a hearty warmth and depth to the meals that go unmatched. Picture the French’s love for fine bread, pastries, and high-quality ingredients mixed with the sun-soaked flavors of Algeria along the Mediterranean. The result is heavenly pasta, pizzas, gelatos, and sides that absolutely burst with flavor. There’s always an interesting interplay of spices and ingredients and a subtle touch of something just a little different.

Best Pizza Bars in City Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

7 restaurants available nearby

1. Michaelangelo’s Restaurant of Arthur Ave

2. Fumo Upper West

3. The Onion Tree

4. Pizza Gourmet Restaurant | Mamaroneck

5. Capri 246

6. Lombardo's Scarsdale

7. Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable