14 Best Comfort Food Restaurants In Sheffield

14 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. The Red Lion Inn

4.4

Awesome(3551)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Stockbridge

Booked 68 times today

Excellent meal. Bouillabaisse was phenomenal! Nice setting in an historic inn. Piano music was a plus. Service was excellent.

2. Kips Tavern

4.8

Exceptional(355)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Rhinebeck

Booked 11 times today

Dining at Kips Tavern is a very nice experience. The staff is quite friendly and attentive and it is wonderful having this restaurant in our town. The menu is fine American tavern food, last night we had the French Onion Soup, very good, not salty which is always an issue; chopped salad was very good, fresh and with tasty dressing; a smash burger (which I doubt usually have), it was very good-not overcooked and crisp french fries. For beverages I had a bourbon manhattan, up. It was very good. My wife had the special cocktail, I can't remember the ingredients, but she enjoyed it.

A photo of The Charles - Wethersfield restaurant

3. The Charles - Wethersfield

4.5

Awesome(2051)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Wethersfield

We had the steak frites and the chicken and dumplings… Truly one of the best meals we’ve had in a long time. Oh, and don’t forget arranciata pepper and beet appetizer… Really really good.

4. La Figata

4.0

Excellent(172)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Granby

Booked 3 times today

Our experiences at LA Figata are always enjoyable. The food is excellent, the menu is creative. Service is always good. Prices are very reasonable for the quality of both food and overall experience.

5. Catamount

4.6

Exceptional(557)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Mount Tremper

Booked 10 times today

Catamount Restaurant is the perfect setting for a romantic dinner for two, a family dinner, or meeting friends for a nice meal and a drink. The hostess, wait staff and bar tenders are all great! Very pleasant and inviting experience in an absolutely gorgeous setting. And the food and drinks are wonderful, too!

6. Pond House Cafe

4.6

Exceptional(2743)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Hartford

Booked 20 times today

I gather that dinner is done as a pop up, and there was a wedding going on in the main room, so.we were in the cafe area. The food and service were excellent, with a broader menu than expected for a pop up. The only slight downside was the lack of formality of the room and tables - it was a little less fancy. Throw some tablecloths on and we wouldn't have noticed! We go back in a heartbeat though for a quirky, fun and delicious dinner.

7. Tilly's Table

4.3

Awesome(1062)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Brewster

Booked 7 times today

As usual superb food….lobster bisque was exquisite

8. Market Grille

4.7

Exceptional(929)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Manchester

Booked 24 times today

Great service and food. Loud but contained with happy customers

A photo of Gather55 - Hartford restaurant

9. Gather55 - Hartford

4.8

Exceptional(418)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Hartford

Booked 2 times today

The Meal was fabulous as was the whole dining experience

A photo of Maggie McFly's® l Glastonbury restaurant

10. Maggie McFly's® l Glastonbury

4.1

Excellent(16)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Glastonbury

Booked 3 times today

Great food, great value. Host said he could not find reservation from open table so that was only annoyance.

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Sheffield

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

14 restaurants available nearby

1. The Red Lion Inn

2. Kips Tavern

3. The Charles - Wethersfield

4. La Figata

5. Catamount

6. Pond House Cafe

7. Tilly's Table

8. Market Grille

9. Gather55 - Hartford

10. Maggie McFly's® l Glastonbury

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable