Best Cosy Restaurants in Duck Key

We had a great time.Lexi was our waitress she was awesome she was able to answer a couple questions so I could order something I would like and she suggested the shrimp tacos and they were really good so was my wife’s bacon burger,the portions were very generous we will definitely go back

Our waiter, Scott, was superb. We had the lobster bisque, the mahi mahi, and the crab stuffed yellow tail. All were excellent. Wonderful dinner in a very nice setting.

Always an awesome Islamorada dinner. We had the Tuscan Steak and Carbonara. Better than in Florence!

More phenomenal food ! Yum sandwich (eggplant) and pasta for the wife ! Plus their rum cake dessert- truly outstanding ! Andrea outdid herself ! And Ivan did us great !

Plaza Grill was recommended by our hotel and it was great. Many places on the Keys are touristy and don't need to try very hard since they have a great location but Plaza Grill was awesome. We went there for an anniversary dinner and the food and service were outstanding. We had the clams but since my wife cannot have wine the chef made it with extra chicken broth and garlic. This was outstanding. The service was also great. If I had to say something negative it is that the interior was a little dated and dark but that did not keep us from enjoying a great dinner.