Best Italian Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Price: Moderate (451)Price: Expensive (393)Price: Very Expensive (156)

394 restaurants available nearby

1. Verde on Smith

4.7

Exceptional(657)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Cobble Hill

Booked 12 times today

Verde on Smith is an exceptional Italian cuisine restaurant that has managed to make it to the top three restaurants on the popular Brooklyn Restaurant Row, Smith Street. The excellent feedback from multiple satisfied guests confirms its outstanding menu featuring Italian and American dishes, excellent service and a good atmosphere for conversation and dining. Seafood dishes like the stuffed shrimp appetizer and brazzini are highly recommended, as are their Italian specialities. Verde has been described as offering great value and always delivering on food quality and service. The ambiance is characterized as lively and electric, attracting an attractive crowd. Its success has also been attributed to the owner's quiet and watchful oversight.

A photo of Mama Capri - Brooklyn restaurant

2. Mama Capri - Brooklyn

4.2

Awesome(96)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Carroll Gardens

Booked 5 times today

Mama Capri located in Brooklyn is a celebrated gem among Italian cuisine lovers. Reviewers consistently praise the restaurant's authentic Italian food, pinpointing its seafood as some of the freshest and most delicious in the city. The eatery delights diners with delicacies such as the "frito misto" appetizer and the "limoncello ravioli" which are reportedly cheesy, rich, and wonderfully lemony. Not only does Mama Capri deliver an outstanding menu, but the friendly and attentive staff, beautiful decor, and clean ambiance add to the overall dining experience. Reviewers have further mentioned that the staff is very knowledgeable about the Southern Italian origins of the food served. Moreover, if you're a fan of pasta, this restaurant is a must-visit as their pasta has been described as "like in Italy". Whether you're seeking a great date spot or a comfortable family setting, Mama Capri comes highly recommended.

A photo of Savelli Restaurant and Bar restaurant

3. Savelli Restaurant and Bar

4.7

Exceptional(247)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cobble Hill

Booked 7 times today

Savelli Restaurant and Bar is lauded for its exceptional Italian cuisine by countless satisfied customers. One patron praised it as the "best Italian spot in the neighborhood," while another highlighted its "delicious southern Italian cuisine." Many reviews commend the authenticity of the dishes, with one customer delightfully surprised that the food exceeded his expectation of "authentic Italian." Apart from its culinary excellence, Savelli Restaurant and Bar also impresses diners with its warm ambiance and hospitable service. As one customer put it, "This place left me and my wife speechless, great service, great food... felt like I was back home at grandma's house." Located in the heart of Brooklyn, this highly recommended Italian restaurant promises a memorable dining experience that transports you to Italy.

4. Cecconi's Dumbo

4.5

Awesome(5051)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • DUMBO

Booked 228 times today

Cecconi's Dumbo, famous for its Contemporary Italian cuisine, has been lauded by many for its exceptional dining experience. The restaurant, nestled under the Brooklyn Bridge, offers stunning views of the waterfront and the Manhattan skyline, creating an unmatched ambiance that guests find irresistible. Patrons have consistently praised the authenticity of the dishes, with one even singling out the vegan sausage pizza for its convincing flavor. The service has been deemed 'outstanding' and 'impeccable' by numerous reviews, with waiters like Mario and Sam earning special mentions for their kindness and attentiveness. Whether for the vegan dessert that is 'decadent and rich', or for the 'amazing' salami pizza, Cecconi's Dumbo has something for everyone, expertly blending traditional Italian cuisine with a touch of modern creativity, promising an experience that 'never disappoints'.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Casa restaurant

5. Piccola Cucina Casa

4.8

Exceptional(48)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Boerum Hill

Booked 23 times today

Chef Philip Guardione is bringing all the Italian flavors to Brooklyn.

6. Café Mars

4.8

Exceptional(57)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Park Slope

Booked 18 times today

Café Mars is an unusual Italian restaurant. Come see what we mean!For parties larger than 6 please email info@cafemarsbk.com to help craft your hassle free dining experience!

7. Olio e Più

4.6

Exceptional(3902)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • West Village

Booked 186 times today

Olio e Più is a highly recommended Italian restaurant known for its delicious food and exceptional service. One reviewer refers to the Tagliatelle Verdi al Ragù Bolognese as "a symphony of taste," and praises the attention to detail in preparation. Others express appreciation for the outdoor dining environment, highlighting the lobster ravioli and bruschetta as "to die for." Many have made it their favorite Italian spot in the city, praising the outstanding food, atmosphere, and "friendly" staff. Regardless of their location, all visitors to New York City seem to crave Olio e Più and promise to return. As another reviewer put it, this restaurant is definitely "a go-to Italian restaurant when visiting Manhattan."

A photo of Terre Pasta Natural Wine restaurant

8. Terre Pasta Natural Wine

4.8

Exceptional(764)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Park Slope

Booked 33 times today

Terre Pasta Natural Wine is a cherishable Italian restaurant located in Brooklyn, recognized for its authentic cuisine and exceptional service. The restaurant stands out with its tantalizing house-made pasta, sharp cheeses, and a vast selection of natural wines - all contributing to the vibrant Italian culinary experience. Patrons commend the knowledgeable staff for their excellent service and wine recommendations, who add to the charm of the restaurant with their delightful Italian accents. Reviewers continually appreciate the fine preparation, attention to detail, and the use of high-quality ingredients. Terre Pasta Natural Wine is highly recommended for providing a delightful 'rustic epicurean experience', making it a noteworthy Italian gem in Brooklyn.

9. Serra by Birreria

4.3

Awesome(6836)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Gramercy Park

Booked 102 times today

Serra by Birreria, a renowned Italian restaurant in New York, receives a lot of praise from patrons for its authentic cuisine, ambiance, and excellent service. The restaurant has been described as a wonderful Italian garden, filled with greenery, flowers, and fruit, creating a pretty and relaxing atmosphere. Visitors rave about the food, one patron stated, "From the ambiance to the server, to the food, I'd recommend it highly," while others commend the Pomodori side dish and pasta bolognese, among other meals. Despite being located inside Eataly, it carries its own unique charm, and many customers were eager to revisit.

A photo of La Pizza & La Pasta - Eataly NYC Downtown restaurant

10. La Pizza & La Pasta - Eataly NYC Downtown

4.5

Awesome(1600)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Financial District

Booked 79 times today

La Pizza & La Pasta - Eataly NYC Downtown, situated in the bustling heart of Manhattan's WTC/Financial District, is heralded by patrons as one of the best destinations for authentic and high-quality Pizzeria cuisine. The restaurant has garnered praise for its spectacular food and impressive service, with customers noting the satisfying portion sizes despite appearances. Both locals and tourists enjoy the authenticity of the dishes, from the pizza Napolitana to the homemade pasta dishes like Caccio e Pepe, all echoing the essence of Italy. Paired with an exceptional Tiramisu dessert and amiable staff, the restaurant consistently exceeds expectations. As one reviewer puts it, "This is so good. Like so so good."

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Discover the charm of authentic Italian dining in the heart of New York City's Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn. This neighborhood is renowned for its vibrant culinary scene, offering a variety of Italian restaurants that cater to all tastes, from traditional recipes passed down through generations to contemporary twists on classic dishes. Each establishment boasts a unique ambiance, ensuring an immersive dining experience whether you're seeking a romantic dinner or a casual outing with friends. The focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients is evident, with menus featuring everything from artisanal pizzas to exquisite pasta dishes, all crafted with genuine Italian flair. Patrons consistently praise the attentive service and the overall dining atmosphere, which combines to create a memorable gastronomic journey. As Carroll Gardens continues to thrive as a culinary hotspot, its Italian restaurants remain a cornerstone, drawing both locals and tourists alike to experience the essence of Italy in Brooklyn.

Explore OpenTable

Carroll Gardens

Italian