The Oar Steak and Seafood Grill
Warmly welcomed by the hostesses, immediately greeted by busgal and waitress. Bread, drinks and appetizer order taken swiftly. Holiday drink list is a good variety. Coffee is piping hot with fresh cream. Burgers, steak and soups are brought out to perfect temperature. Desserts were phenomenal. Would visit again.
Thanks for the great review! We hope to see you back again in the future!
Excellent food with a very nice atmosphere
Wait staff on their A game
We love to hear that! Thank you!
Great service, food good, restaurant week value good
Thank you so much!
Food was delicious!! Great service!
Thank you so much! We love to hear that!
The Oar House has been given a face lift and it is quite beautiful. I was there on a Friday evening and all of the rooms were lit and decorated beautifully. There was vocal music which added to the ambiance. The menu has been changed for the better also. I had a delicious salad and our waiter was beyond helpful and courteous. I will be back again soon.
We're so glad you had a great time with us! We'll see you back again soon!
Went for a Book Club lunch. Food, service and most important ambience were outstanding!
We're so glad you had a great time with us! Thank you!
Great service. The atmosphere was very nice and the food was delicious. They do need new menus however. The ones we had were so faded we could hardly read them. Also wish they would add more seafood options.
Food, service all great. The place was dirty. Food on the floor all around us. Flies all around. Clean the place and the rating will improve. Im not writing this to hurt the place. Im a 20 year restauranteur with both fine and casual dining management experience. The management needs to know these things.
Always good. Been there many times
Thank you! We love to hear that!
The Hostess and our waitress were extremely helpful friendly attentive and professional. Food is always tasty and the band was fantastic....what a fun night!
Thank you! We're glad you had a great time with us!
The atmosphere this night was fantastic. It was a beautiful night , we sat outside the band began around 7pm . great music , good food and a wonderful waitress. She had a smile all night. It was as if she didn't want to be any where else. She was accommodating , personable , and had a great raspy voice that my fellow patrons didn't let her forget. Thank you for a wonderful evening.
The seasoned olive oil was very watery and bland.
The clams on the half shell were fine, but should have come with more than one small piece of lemon. The Chilean sea bass ordered was only seared on the top, rest had no flavor; the paella was served in a deep bowl so it was more like a soup..definitely the wrong plating; the seared tuna was good but way too much rice and hardly any wasabi. Overall, very disappointing and I would not recommend going there!
i enjoyed our dining experience at The Oar. loved the bright indoor dining area and when bifold doors were opened it was even nicer. The lobster sliders were excellent and we received complimentary salads which was a very nice touch. Only thing i was disappointed in was my duck entree. The maple glaze was delish but i felt the duck was overcooked and dry. The veggies and potatoes that accompanied the duck were excellent though. Overall a very nice dining experience and I would come back and try some of the other entrees. The other guests in my party were happy with their choices.
We're glad to hear you enjoyed your experience with us. We hope you'll come back again in the future so we can improve upon your last visit even more! Thank you!
Bring back Sunday brunch. disappointed to find that it was no longer offered
Was great! Party of 5 all enjoyed everything.
We love to hear that! Thank you!
Lobster tail fair waitress as great drink made by bartender not so good
Service a little slow, but overall a good place to eat
Staff was excellent. They sent me a gift certificate for my parent’s 45th anniversary and they loved it. Great overall staff, food and atmosphere. Looking forward to returning.
Thank you, Beth! We're looking forward to your next visit!
We had returned an undercooked steak that was just full of fat. They cooked it properly but it was too fatty to eat, so they took it off our bill. It was a bad piece of meat.
My family and I recently were here to eat dinner before the kids dance recital at the Patchogue Theater. Great Ambiance, Food and Service. Thank you
Thank you so much! We're glad you had a great time!
This restaurant is on the water but not much of a view due to all the boats. We ate outside under an umbrella. The staff was very pleasant. My friend ordered a turkey club with fries and I had the fish and chips. Both meals were ok. For dessert I had tarfuto and my friend had the carrot cake which she liked. The tarfuto was delicious.
Good food good time
We love to hear that!
Excellent meal as usual.
Thank you so much, Danielle!
The food was excellent and we were seated very close to the time we had a reservation for that’s always appreciated. I was not happy with the table location and lot of people walking by seemed a little busy to me for location for a table .Our table was on the other side of the wall to the entranceway and it just didn’t feel right the table next to us three different couples had refused to sit there because it was also in a little poor location those two tables should be eliminated or wall for privacy should be put up something needs to be done
Food was good and the waitress was very attentive. A 6:45 Reservation is just that. Seated at 7:20 not cool. In the future if it's a split decision on where to dine, this will be the deal breaker.
Good food and service. Nice and comfortable environment.
We had a reservation for 5. And unfortunately my grandmother couldn’t make it. So I said we dropped down to 4, when I said that the woman behind the podium was extremely rude about it. Saying that now she needs to accommodate her restaurant the right way considering we booked for 5. The hoity toity attitude and that stick up her butt need to chill. You don’t have to be rude about it. Needless to say it went downhill after that. We waited 15-20 mins before being acknowledged. We were shoved in a corner in the cross way of the kitchen and staff. The food was half par. I was expecting so much more from all the reviews I read.
So needless to say. Will not be going back. Which is a shame considering it’s local.
the restaurant is beautiful, the food delicious, the service grand!
Thank you so much! We love to hear that!
Great time as always . They even accommodated extra people in our party that showed up . Staff was great food awesome love the place !
We're so happy you had a great time with us! Thank you!
We had a wonderful lunch to celebrate our anniversary.
We love to hear that! Thank you for celebrating with us!
Very friendly and professional service. Food was hot and delicious.
We love to hear that, Theresa. Thank you!
Great meal. Great band
Great place, food is amazing and the service is great. the only think that is not so good is the drinks. either too much alcohol or no alcohol. other than that best place i ever been in a long time.
While we were seated, greeted, etc. The waitress took exceptional care of us even though we had to leave quickly. We had a family medical emergency. I do wish my drinks were comped bc we left suddenly.. and paid to wrap our dinner
Beautiful setting; wonderful menu selections prepared to perfection and well presented. The room was lively - a little noisy to my taste but not enough so that I would not return. Definitely
not a good choice for those with hearing aids.
Favorite restaurant on Long Island
We love to hear that! Thank you for the kind words!
Wonderful service. Took our time, never felt rushed. Delicious, fresh fish.
We love to hear that - thank you!
Perfect birthday lunch
Thanks for celebrating your birthday with us!
The Oar is a great place to go for excellent food, service, and ambiance. We’ve been there about 10’times now.
This time we had the Oar Burgers which were delicious without ketchup. We asked for well done regular French fries and well done sweet potato French fries. Both came out well done and hot. The regular French fries were better because they were a little thicker, best regular fries I’ve ever had.
In the past we’ve had steaks and seafood, both were great although I recall one time the fried calamari was ok but not great.
Overall, you cannot go wrong eating and/or having drinks at this great place!
Thank you, Jim! We can't wait to have you back again soon!
Food was very good, Open Tables menu was different from menu at The Oar, and prices were considerably higher on the house menu. Service was excellent. Always enjoy the ambiance, can't wait till the weather gets nicer to sit outside. Was a little noisy around the bar, but that's to be expected on a rainy Friday night.