Sushi of Gari 46
Please note: Sushi Bar reservation is not available online. Please contact the restaurant directly.
Amazing tasting menu!
Front Staff is unfriendly
Awesome service and food
Was a lovely delicious and exciting menu. Enjoyed everything we got and ca not wait to return. Very attentive and helpful waiters just enhanced the experience.
What a disappointment — loved the one on the UWS but this is not that. I can handle small dark rooms if the food is right but this was so average it was sad. Nothing special, no real flavors but a cost that reflected a Michelin star restaurant. Over priced, weak food, ok service, nothing special ambiance. Sad. Would never have thought this was a Gari restaurant.
Service was very rushed and a staff person took garbage from the kitchen though the restaurant out the front door and it made a very foul odor. Food was fine but very expensive.
do the omekase, it was incredible and we asked for another round!
Sushi of Gari is not what it used to be! This was one of our go-to spots for Japanese and sushi, but not anymore. Limited menu, high prices, a boring wine list, and a very expensive sake list. Bottles of sake should be offered at every price level!
Sake options are limited. I like organic w/out added sulphites due to allergy. You should offer this. Also, my son ordered a sushi special and it came w/ eggplant sushi which he didn't like. The roll was crab which was also an inferior roll for the prices you charge. We love your food but it isn't close to good value. I ordered 4 special pieces of sushi and was happy to pay for that. It was delicious as was the Hijiki salad.
Food at its best ever bere, service efficient and helpful, improve premise and you will be come almost... perfect
Sushi of Gari chefs make some of the most unique dishes I have eaten. Very creative and very delicious.
Food is consistently excellent. Service too!
The omakase was great! But maybe not as worth as the deluxe sushi.
Came back because the sushi was worth it. A must have experience in NYC.
Loved every minute. Best sushi I have ever had in my life (and I’ve eaten a lot of sushi!)
I've eaten at both the upper west and theater district locations. Both are great - the fish is definitely at notch above the average sushi place. I look forward to it every time. Service is always very good and speedy (without feeling rushed). Huge fan of Gari!
Food, service and atmosphere was excellent. The fish was so fresh! We went for a birthday party and werent disappointed!
Must love the element of surprise. Menu is designed to leave choices up to the chefs. Very popular spot, so expect close proximity where table conversation appears shared with neighboring tables. Unique experience but very enjoyable.
Not worth it. Basic sushi, expensive price. Not even good.
This was quite possibly the worst sushi I’ve ever had, and I don’t say that casually. My daughter and I also got sick from the meal. And it was pricey for what it was. It was rated highly and I was very disappointed. The waitstaff was attentive but I truly couldn’t understand a word out server said.
The quality of food and sushi was really average at best.
Also ordered a chicken teriyaki which was soaked in their sauce. Underwhelming overall experience but admittedly I am spoiled by sushi in Asia.
Disappointed as it was great in its day. Just so so sushi now.
Totally some of the best sushi in NYC in a simple and welcoming environment, with a welcoming family like vibe. And one that does not break the pocketbook. The 8pm Broadway show crowd does make it a bit hectic during rush hour, but then it is always good to know that a later in the evening reservation should be easier to come by. Delicious.
The sushi is still amazing. The restaurant looks old and dated.
Been there many times for upscale sushi fix. Expensive but delicious and would always suggest sitting at the counter for omikase.
Could not understand what the waitress was saying. Food was good, ambience was disappointing. Too many other places to choose from to return.
The fish didn’t seem as fresh as usual and the atmosphere was noisy and closed in. Not up to usual Sushi of Gari experience and not consistent with high price point.
Poor. Server kept pushing us to finish and leave even though it was under 1 hour total and we ordered more than $150. Would put unfinished items onto our plates for us to clear the table. Sushi was mediocre - seaweed lacked any texture and the shrimp tempura made my lips swell upon eating. The ac had also broken this night and the fish was lukewarm, which I hope was because of the rice and not because of fridge issues. Overall negative experience - I was shocked to hear this had any sort of Michelin recommendation/affiliation.
Just made it in before they closed. Tuna Gari was amazing
The staff is targeting Bridge horrible experience for the price,had over $500 check...
Sushi was phenomenal. Waitstaff was very attentive. Excellent service. Highly recommend.
Food was incredible and delicious. I ordered tuna of Gari and it was outstanding
Had a great sushi dinner after a show. Service was very good and the fish was fresh and delicious. Thank you - it's about time a restaurant in the theatre district served up an excellent meal!
Our favorite place to go for sushi as a family
Way too expensive for the quality and quantity of food served.
The food was good - almost very good. But not great. I'll admit I'm a bit spoiled - I live in the Bay Area and only eat sushi at a handful of places that make truly exceptional sushi. I had the Omakase and it was close to what I get on the west coast. But for the cost and the hype I'd read online, I expected it to match or even exceed what I'd experienced.
Gari’s Choice (Omakase) is the way to go! Delicious!
Service was awesome.
Excellent sushi and a unique set of flavors which created just an wonderful experience.
The waitress was able to provide for all our needs, dinner arrived in short order and was delicious. My husband got the "chef's choice" which was the best (and the most creative) sushi he had ever eaten.