Scotty's on Sheridan
Our American Grill menu offers something delicious for everyone, from timeless comfort food to new American classics.
Relax with one of Scotty's signature house cocktails in a cozy club chair in our bar lounge. Enjoy a candle-lit dinner and a bottle of wine in our intimate white tablecloth dining room.
Discover Scotty's — a hidden gem tucked away on Sheridan Road, across from Fort Sheridan in Highwood, IL
Came early and they seated us immediately very friendly wait staff food entrees were excellent both Filet and whitefish Polly
Great as always. Had an excellent filet — grilled perfect! They are always flexible in giving you what you want as sides. North Shore jewel— don’t tell too many— don’t want the masses to come.
We had a nice meal with good people. Our staff was friendly and attentive. Overall, the food was good. My daughter had the mussels which she loved, but I thought were too salty. My wife and I split a Greek Salad, which was perfect size and good flavors. I had a burger and I’d have it again. My wife had a gluten-free pasta and really enjoyed it.
Great food, yummy cocktails, excellent service! Also conversation friendly, that is, it’s not too noisy!
Excellent fish. Nice wines by the glass. Attentive service. Given it. A try.
Salad & Veal Parmigiana was delicious! I expect nothing less! I’m never disappointed at Scotty’s.
Great food as usual. Never disappoints
Love the atmosphere! Scotty and his staff are always welcoming. Never have had a bad meal .
Always enjoy our dinners at Scotty's...the goat cheese pizza was especially good that evening1
The food and service at Scotty’s are all consistently good; highly recommend.
We had a quiet table where we could talk. Service was excellent. Not intrusive but very attentive. Food was great.
Whitefish was done completely differently from any other restaurant I have visited. Very ample portion, too.
First time at Scotty’s and I enjoyed the food and the service. The menu had enough variety and I liked that their were some less expensive options at dinner if you were not real hungry. I will be back
Scotty’s is our favorite neighborhood joint. Just classy enough to make it special, but not a snob or fussbudget attitude anywhere among the staff. Scotty takes great care to make all of the guests feel welcome and catered to. The kitchen holds up their end of the bargain too. We love this place and highly recommend it. You will not be disappointed. TIP: try to be seated in the bar. It has more room between tables and being there makes sure that Scotty keeps his eye on you.
Enjoyed a nice quiet dinner after a holiday weekend. All the food was fantastic. Servings were plentiful. Service was good.
We had a wonderful meal there and the waiter was very friendly. My wife said she wanted to compliment the chef and the waiter actually asked the chef to come out to our table. We had some wonderful shrimp cocktail pre-dinner and we loved the cocktail sauce and the waiter actually gave us a small carton of the sauce to take home. We will definitely come back again
Great food, excellent service and outstanding food
I clicked anniversary on open table and nothing was done for it. Food was just okay. Nothing special. Don’t get all the good reviews. Our first time and we won’t return. Too many better restaurants.
Food and service were excellent
Server Polly was outstanding her recommendation was right on
Love Scotty's. Great restaurant, food was fantastic
Everyone at the table thought their meals were outstanding....From white fish to pork chops Great neighborhood spot for simply comfortable dining
Great as Always 💚😇
Will go there whenever I have the chance as live 30 minutes south. Worth the drive every time. Service is stellar. Food...am close to going thru entire menu. Have yet to find anything they do not do well. North Shore resident for 73 years. This is a gem!
We had never been to Scotty’s before. We all had delicious entrees and could not have been happier.
After reading all the good reviews we decided to try Scottys. The waitress was not knowledgeable about the menu at all. I asked what the place is known for and she couldn't give me an item that she would recommend . I went ahead and ordered the veal piccata. It came swimming in a pool of oil with raw spinach leafs on top. Tasteless at best. Only the capers had flavor. My husbands pork chops were not glazed with a brandy sauce but very watery and they were overcooked and chewy. We will not be visiting this place again.
We love getting together with friends at Scotty's......a friendly place with good food. However, a new policy of double checking reservations is irritating...the day before our reservation, I received an e-mail asking if our party was coming to the restaurant. I confirmed that we still were. Then about an hour and a half before our reservation, I received a phone call asking me to confirm that we were still coming...totally unnecessary. What if i had missed that phone call? Would Scotty's have cancelled the reservation?
Lived up to star rating do not be put off by location in strip mall
Food is outstanding. I hope no one reads this review, because i'm afraid that the place will become too crowded.
Excellent food and service!
Our party of 4 all enjoyed the meal and ambience. How nice to get good food at reasonable cost.
Love the food, ambiance and service. The salmon sandwich was delicious!
Always consistent and very good. Quality food and quality service. Great spot — don’t tell everyone.
great food. Quite place. Greeted very warmly. Good menu variet...something for everyone. Our service was meh...but not terrible...just not super speedy when we wanted the check...and wanted to order.
Great! The food is wonderful!
We dine several times per year at Scott’s. Never disappointed
Great menu offering, with welcome changes occasionally
Highly professional service
And be certain to make a reservation!
Amazing meal and over the top friendly service. We will be going back regularly. All of our meals were wonderful.
From a food perspective, this was a very uneven meal. The fried calamari were barely decent, though the meatball appetizer was fantastic. The ribs totally fell right off the bone, but the fries and broccoli that we got on the side left a lot to be desired. The corn soup had no taste, but the bacon wrapped scallops were exquisite. Overall, it was OK, just very inconsistent.