The Pie

4.6 (24)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

216 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

Make a booking

The Pie

4.6

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Port Jefferson

Make a booking

2 people

24 Sept 2026

7:00 pm

Booked 2 times today

About this restaurant

Kid-friendly
Great for craft beers
Neighbourhood gem

We are one of the few locations on Long Island that serves true authentic coal fired Neapolitan pizza and the only place to get pizza this unique. When the summer months hit, Port Jefferson Village is jumping and the hottest spot in town is The Pie. In the Winter, The Pie is the perfect cozy spot to get together with your loved ones. Whether you are part of the community or just visiting, our family friendly atmosphere is the place to be. Our pizza is hand-crafted thin, crispy, and well done. Each pie is made with only the freshest ingredients served by our courteous staff. A great selection of appetizers, fresh salads, homemade pastas, and desserts there is something here for everybody. We are located in the heart of Main Street, just a short walk from the marina.

Dining areas

Additional information

Dining style
Casual Dining
Price
$30 and under
Cuisines
Pizzeria, Italian, Contemporary Italian
Hours of Operation
Mon–Thu 12:00–20:30 Fri 12:00–22:00 Sat 11:30–22:00 Sun 11:30–20:30
Phone number
(631) 331-4646
Website
https://www.thepieofportjeff.com/
Payment Options
AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
Dress code
Business Casual

Location
216 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Area
Port Jefferson
Parking Details
None
Additional
Beer, Cocktails, Full Bar, Wine

Concierge
AI Beta

Our AI assistant, Concierge, is here to answer your questions about this restaurant.

Reviews

OpenTable reviews from verified diners

Reviews from people who have dined at The Pie.

4.6

(24)

4.6Food
4.5Service
4.2Ambience
4.4Value

Noise • Moderate

Loved For

Suffolk
Kid-friendly

Review summary

AI-generated from verified diner reviews

The Pie Coal-Fired Pizza offers "wonderful food and service" with standout items like hot honey pepperoni pizza. Guests praise its "excellent service," especially from servers like Kerri. While some note noise levels and occasional service lapses, the "top quality food" and local charm make it a beloved spot for family gatherings and theater-goers.

24 Reviews

T
Tamra
Washington, D.C. Area5 reviews
5.0
Dined on 22 August 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 4
Great pizzas- highly recommend the hot honey pepperoni! The music was very loud even for the 20-30 yo in our group.
Is this helpful?
C
Casey
New York City2 reviews
5.0
Dined on 22 August 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
Excellent service and the food is amazing. Can’t wait to go back.
Is this helpful?
A
Audrey
New York City1 review
5.0
Dined on 22 August 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
Food and service is always wonderful . Great staff and value
Is this helpful?
c
christopher
New York City9 reviews
5.0
Dined on 8 August 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
Great experience from start to finish! We had a nice large booth for my family of 4 adults. Drinks and food were delicious. Service was excellent . Very attentive
Is this helpful?
p
paul
Miami - Dade33 reviews
5.0
Dined on 8 August 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
Been to The Pie a number of times. And always return when in the area to see a show at the theater down the street. Why? Because it's excellent. No matter what you order, you're gonna love it. And yesterday we were treated to perfect service by a real professional waitress. Couldn't have been any better. We loved it.
Is this helpful?
n
nicole
New York City9 reviews
2.0
Dined on 4 August 2026
1. Overall 2
2. Food 2
3. Service 2
4. Ambience 3
Ordered 2 pizzas. One came out and the second don't come out for another 15 minutes. Was very strange we were 7 people so we sat around waiting for the second pizza. Tables that came in after us has their food ( pizzas) before us. Think they forgot our second pizza or it was given to another table. The crust on our first pizza was burnt as well. Very expensive for 2 pizzas and some sodas.
Is this helpful?
P
Peter
New York City44 reviews
5.0
Dined on 25 July 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 5
Top quality food and service. Kerri, our server remembers us from visit to visit and is fantastic!
Is this helpful?
N
Nadene
Key West / Florida Keys5 reviews
5.0
Dined on 24 July 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 4
We love The Pie! We Enjoy a visit each time we come home to see family
Is this helpful?
D
Donna
Unspecified1 review
3.0
Dined on 23 July 2026
1. Overall 3
2. Food 3
3. Service 1
4. Ambience 1
Server was extremely inattentive. Some dishes were good. Others were not. Specifically the baked clams were all breading no clams. The chicken franchese had 3 SMALL chicken FINGERS over a lot of spaghetti. The clams oreganato were prepared very differently but they were tasty. The rigatoni rustica was delicious.
Is this helpful?
D
Derek
Columbus3 reviews
5.0
Dined on 13 July 2026
1. Overall 5
2. Food 5
3. Service 5
4. Ambience 4
Food was excellent. Loved the meatballs and pizza. Server was friendly and helpful.
Is this helpful?

Dining areas

Additional information

Dining style
Casual Dining
Price
$30 and under
Cuisines
Pizzeria, Italian, Contemporary Italian
Hours of Operation
Mon–Thu 12:00–20:30 Fri 12:00–22:00 Sat 11:30–22:00 Sun 11:30–20:30
Phone number
(631) 331-4646
Website
https://www.thepieofportjeff.com/
Payment Options
AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
Dress code
Business Casual

Location
216 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Area
Port Jefferson
Parking Details
None
Additional
Beer, Cocktails, Full Bar, Wine

Make a booking

The Pie

4.6

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Port Jefferson

Make a booking

2 people

24 Sept 2026

7:00 pm

Booked 2 times today