What a find! The food was awesome. We ordered some of the specials. One was better than the next. The waiter was the best one I’ve had ever. The ambiance was gorgeous I’ve already told everyone I know. I cannot wait to go back.
When we arrived, we were told that our reservation in the solarium room could not be honored because a group increased its attendees. Also, the main dining room was not available to us because it was totally booked by another group. They put us at a nice outside table; however, since it was cool out I requested an indoor table. They placed us in a small dining room with a nice round table to accommodate the 6 of us--it was very nice!
The appetizers (meat and cheese, scallops, and shrimp) , the entrees (pork loin and salmon) and the desserts (sundaes and brownie) were all very good.
The service was slow because the restaurant was very crowded; however, our waiter, John, nevertheless did a great job!
Limited menu choices that are uninspired, didn’t even have specials except for hamburgers, much too nice of place for such pedestrian fare.
It was very nice. The menu needs to be updated on their website
We went for brunch and it was delicious! The restaurant itself is beautiful, the staff were very kind, and the food was fantastic. We will be going back.
This restaurant is really hit or miss. The service leaves a lot to be desired - we had to wait 15 minutes to get acknowledged for drinks at our table, I had to ask for both a spoon and a knife. I find a $16 shrimp appetizer comprised of three miniscule shrimp to be ridiculous. Since their menu rarely changes and they don't seem to do specials very often, I was really underwhelmed. There are not lots of fine dining places to choose from in Goshen at this point but they really need to get their act together.
Overpriced. Long lines for buffet. No omelette station and food was cold by the time you could sit and eat it. Service was awful, but that's because we were outside. They had no record of our reservation. Good thing I saved my confirmation from open table. Also, I had called to confirm 3 days prior and asked not to be outside.
Thank you ! Nothing short of fabulous. The food was delicious! Our server was wonderful, and the ambiance..spectacular.
Place has lots of charm. Had been there one other time and food was ok. But friends rave about the place. So we have another chance. This time it was spot on. The were friendly accommodating and food was great. Plus there’s a huge outdoor space for the summer. I will definitely go back!!
Not only was the food amazing so was the staff. A friend and I went for Brunch and the staff was just so nice and accommodating....we were there for a while and we felt no rush at all.
This was our first visit to the Stagecoach and we were very impressed. The food was excellent! Our server Elizabeth was the GREATEST! She was knowledgeable and had the greatest personality. We highly recommend the Stagecoach.
Welcome addition to the local restaurant scene. Excellent Valentine's Day Dinner and Sunday Brunch.
Super ambiance as well.
Our meal was excellent and the staff was great we enjoyed everything.
Lovely atmosphere, nice presentation, food served hot and everything was delicious.
Love this place. Food is always lovingly prepared. Each and every meal is truly a dining experience. Staff is friendly and attentive. Well done. Best food in Orange County.
My salmon dish was delicious - the couple with us ordered spareribs & scallops and thought the
spareribs to spicy & scallops not up to par as the last time ordered - also the bread pudding was
not good. Service was pretty bad & the room we were seated at was cold and noisy. I would
come back and request another room as my food was delicious.
First time there. Had brunch with my wife. Gorgeous place. Best Eggs Benedict ever. Looking forward to go there for dinner.
I have had many a meal there and never had a bad experience. Staff is friendly. Food is tasty and made by an expert. The only criticism I can offer is that the coffee is never really hot. Other than that it’s a great experience.
All in all a very good rating in all parameters. We sat in the closed in huge porch on Valentine's day. Next time, we will ask for one of the numerous dining rooms since the heater was a blower that went on and off.
Friendly staff, excellent food.
I love Riesling wine and prefer St Michelle rather than Brotherhood but since the owner grew up near the Brotherhood winery, I can understand.
The prices seemed moderate given the food and ambiance .
No hesitation to recommend the Stage Coach Inn after one visit. We shall be back.
Beautiful fire going and the food was delicious. Staff friendly. Our first time there. Perfect valentine evening!
The Stagecoach is a wonderful place. It is elegant and the staff is extremely welcoming. A new server, Andrew was great and Kayla was absolutely terrific. I found the food to be excellent and the value well worth it. If you are in the area; it is a must place to dine and stay overnight. The rooms are magnificent.
Stunning and intimate dining experience. Food was delicious and gorgeously presented, the service personal and professional. Truly 5+ stars.
What happened? The menu changed and it’s searching for an identity. From empanadas to pasta to filet mignon (none great) it’s a mess. Ambiance is lovely, unfortunately the food isn’t.
Once again Stagecoach did not disappoint. The atmosphere was cozy with fires burning in rooms. The service was excellent. The food was tastefully presented and very well prepared. I again recommend the Inn for any number of occasions from a get together with friends to celebrating special events.
While the food was ok, I thought the portions were small for the price paid. In addition, the service was lacking. Our server had to be reminded to bring the drink menu for us and we had finished our apps before we had to remind him again we hadn't received our drinks.
Amazing atmosphere in a welcoming and charming setting. Highly recommended for Sunday Brunch. Great staff and remarkable food choices.
Great dinner .. beautiful decor especially at Christmas time .
Food bland and overcooked.
Always a great experience at the Stagecoach!
Everything we ate was superb & the ambiance was wonderful! It was a lengthy dining experience & some of the members of my party were a bit tired, so didn't have much patience for the 'dining experience'. We didn't find the server to be too attentive or efficient, but overall it was a good experience & I would return as well as recommend it to others.
THe portions were very small for the price. would like to see more food on the plates. They should actually put the fresh bread on the tables instead of walking around with it. Overall the experience was very nice.
This was our first time here and we love the food and the. Ambience..
Excellent meal in a great atmosphere. Glad the Stagecoach Inn participated I HV Restaurant week.
My sister and I went there for restaurant week and we were so surprised on how terrible the food was. I will most likely never go there again, nor would I recommend it to people I know
We live in the area and if not for Hudson Valley Restaurant Week we may never have tried the Stagecoach Inn. What an incredible place! From our first step in the door we were welcomed and very well treated. The Inn is beautiful with many nooks to see and the food was excellent. We will definitely be back.
Dined during Resteraunt week, would enjoy returning but menu is a bit pricy.
Food was mediocre. Short ribs was actually roast beef. And wayyyyy too expensive. Not worth it.
It was our first time there. The food was delicious and the service was good. We will definitely make the Stagecoach Inn one of our “go to” restaurants!
It was our first time there- the food was wonderful and excellent service. We will return!