So glad my husband and I wandered in after a move. It’s become our favorite spot for a celebration or just a nice evening out. Great menu and everything we’ve had has been great. Love the friendly, unfussy warmth Pomodoro offers.
Always a favorite!!
There were five of us and we all ordered different entrees. We all agreed that the food was excellent, served hot and the server was very accommodating.
you can refer to the previous 12 reviews we have left for Pomodoro Rosso.
This is the last time we'll go there. Over the years, it was really lovely, but no longer. Everything has changed, even the food. Sorry Peter, but something isn't right and you're not correcting it. Having discussed this with a few friends and neighbors, they too have said the same thing. Fortunately, there are other restaurants. Having said this, it saddens us to not say it's one of our favorite places any longer. Good luck !
Met friends from out of town. We were able to sit, eat and visit and talk easily. We all had a very pleasant afternoon and I would go again A friend recommended the restaurant and I am glad she did.
Good food, nice neighborhood Italian restaurant
Food was delicious! A lot of options outside your typical "spaghetti bolognese".
I always enjoy dinner at Pomodoro. Never fails to satisfy.
Always delicious, pleasant and accommodating! Real neighborhood jewel.
Thank you Peter and Staff. Another great meal!
Excellent service. Excellent wine. Excellent food, especially the bread! A bit pricey, but probably the norm for that part of the City. Only real negatives were the crowded seating and the volume. If tested, I would get 100 on the content of the conversations of the people sitting next to us. We could hear one another okay at our own table, but it was loud. When having a nice piece of sea bass, I don't haven't to learn at what age the woman next to me lost her virginity.
Pomodoro used to be a wonderful Italian restaurant with beautiful murals and ambiance. The ambiance is the best thing about this restaurant now. The food is so mediocre and used to be wonderful. It is way over priced. We had a small kale salad with beets and goat cheese $16. I ordered lobster ravioli in cream sauce and I was handed 6 medium sized raviolis drowning in cream sauce $37. To make matters worse the ravioli tasted like I bought it in the frozen section of my grocery store. Not good at all. I sent it back and didn’t get anything else I was so disappointed. The best thing they have is their focaccia bread with garlic olive oil to dip. I won’t be going back.
We live in Westchester and our daughter and her family live near Pomodoro. We eat there as often as we can. The s time it was better than ever.
Nice neighborhood restaurant, attentive and friendly staff, excellent food. Busy but not too noisy, tight seating, but not uncomfortable. Just a wonderful experience.
Terrific food, wine and service. Easy walk to Lincoln Center
The food was simply delicious and the service outstanding even thought it was a very busy night.
very friendly, accomodating place with solid, tasty food, nice wait staff, pleasant atmosphere.
I hadn't been to this neighborhood gem in a while but glad I chose it to for a dinner celebration with my friend. The ambiance is warm and cozy. The staff was attentive throughout our dinner. We both had delicious pasta dishes and shared salad and dessert. The food was great. My advance request for a birthday candle and song was honored and executed beautifully. Highly recommend.
I always enjoy this restaurant. The food is consistently good, with good service and pleasant surroundings....and just a 10 minute walk from Lincoln Center
My favorite home cooked meal on the UWS!😋
Service is fantastic. Food is delicious. Everyone was super happy. Would go here again for sure. Went here before show at Lincoln center.
Food was delicious and service was great!! Will definitely be coming back!
Always great food and wonderful service here!
I had the best dinner. We had a party of 6 and everyone loved there food and service. I would definitely make it a point to eat here again.
Four of us enjoyed a fine meal. The salads and burrata were a promising start, and the pastas and chicken parm were so good! We will be back, for sure.
Food was exceptionally good. Service was timely as we were going to Lincoln Center. Hosts were gracious.
We have been to this restaurant many times when we come into the City. It is our first choice. Love the neighborhood as well. The atmosphere and food are excellent.
Love this place. Food is great. Service is great ! I go for regular dining and special occasions for over 20 years now.
Food was ok. We split the fettuccini with bolognese sau
We discovered Pomodoro Rosso on our last trip to NYC and it’s a safe bet to say it will be a must for all future visits! The service was exceptional, with the manager making several trips to our table to double check that we had everything we needed. The small restaurant was packed with what appeared to be a lot of locals- which is always a good sign. Chicken pesto gnocchi was excellent! Chicken parm was delicious!
It was lovely and they accommodated all 6 of us. I highly recommend it.
food was amazing and great service and the employees made you feel like you were part of the family
Fabulous neighborhood restaurant. Food is consistently delicious. Service is always prompt and friendly.
The ambiance is warm and welcoming.
God. Is delicious. Very nice atmospkeree
Never disappoints. Brought an out-of-town visitor who enjoyed it. Was even quiet at lunch enabling us to have a business discussion.
Very good Italian food. Pretty brick wall and nice ambiance. Service was friendly and excellent. Great place to spend a romantic evening.
This is a neighborhood gem. The food is always outstanding and the service excellent. They make you feel special and comfortable
The food is good but doesn’t justify the prices.
Great food, impeccable service.
Pomodoro Rosso offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 721-3009.
Pomodoro Rosso is rated 4.6 stars by 1214 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.