Kelly's Steak and Seafood
If you want something a bit more casual, Kelly's Steak and Seafood has you covered. Choose from the bison burger, Thai chicken sandwich or grilled fish tacos.
Kelly's does not offer anything from our menu "To-Go".
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
Crab and Artichoke Dip*
Blue crab, artichoke hearts, parmesan cheese and sweet onion. Served with sliced baguette bread
Parmesan Crusted Halibut Cheeks*
Flash seared, topped with creamy chive butter. Served with yukon gold mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables
Excellent food and Service
This was my second time visiting the restaurant. Their dishes are amazing and we had great service the first time we went. This time, the waitress was extremely rude to our party of four, two couples. We needed time to look at the menu and get settled; the first time she came to the table after giving us menus and drinks, we ordered appetizers. The second time she stood at our table and did not leave until we ordered our entrees after rudely telling us that the kitchen closed soon, which we were unaware of have just got there less than 15 minutes ago. I felt like a child being scolded by my mother - and to me that is unacceptable at a nice restaurant. We also are not college students, we are local to the area!!! I have never had someone be rude in that manner, especially at such a nice place as Kelly's. I cannot imagine what my grandmother would have said if she got the service we had!! While we were eating dessert she gave us the check and after finishing, not in the exact words, she told us to leave. We were not even close to being the last ones there and only stayed an hour (you must make reservations at $25 per person cancelation fee and you get an hour and a half for dinner for parties of 4). Due to the rude service, I am not sure if our friends - being their first time there, would go back. Luckily it did not spoil the evening and once again, their food is great. It is a give and take, but I will probably not eat here again for a while - hopefully when we do return, we will get great service like the first time.
Delicious meal, great service, outdoor seating was perfect
We had a delicious meal on the patio. Very good waitstaff.
Very nice experience. Will be sure to come again.
Our reservation included a request to be seated in lounge at 6 pm. We arrived 10 minutes early and were told that we could not be seated until 5:45 reservations were seated. We were required to wait in the lobby for 10 minutes until we could take our seat in the lounge. Made no sense.
Great food, Great service, safe clean environment.
The food was excellent but the service was slow. There was a great wine list but limited quantities available. There was only one bottle of each wine we chose so it was a little disruptive selecting wine when you are in the middle of a meeting.
So delicious! Food came quickly. And really great service!
Excellent food and service. My wife had the flatiron stake and she loved it. I did the Create Your Own Crab Pot - it was wonderful. Highly recommended and we will be back.
After a long, busy day moving in to PSU, we were starving. Everything was fantastic!
For a college town the middle of nowhere, it is good. But expensive for what you get.
Jordan was an awesome service. Very attentive with a playful "sass".
Food and service were great, but we were seated outside where flies and other insects disgusting.
We were there to celebrate my partners birthday. It was a lovely meal and experience.
Not many good spots left in the area, but this was a recommendation by some locals. We were not disappointed in the food. However, service was slow, particularly the long wait for dessert.
We love Kelly’s and go regularly. Food is always great and the kids love it too. Staff are great and they accommodate my dietary needs excellently.
Crab and Artichoke Dip was Amazing! Steaks also! Crab cakes had too much breading for my taste!
The lighting was poor had a hard time reading the menu
It was well worth the 40 minute drive to eat there. Food Great! Our server was outstanding and all in all a top notch experience!
We always have a great meal there. The service is outstanding. My favorite place in town to eat.
Seafood chowder is the best. Booths are very roomy for four people. Not cramped. Food and service great.
Wonderful Cocktails, Appetizers, and great Seafood dinner. Salted caramel cake recommendation from our server for dessert was spot on to split between us for a bite of sweet to end our meal. Another great dining experience!
Met some friends from St Louis and they said it was the best meal that they had since leaving Missouri! I made a great choice. Our waiter Miguel was excellent too!
Our meals, drinks, and appetizers were excellent. Server was exceptional. Perfect evening.
We enjoyed our dinner, but were seated at a table between the door to the outside tables and bathrooms so there was lots of foot traffic. The table must have been old as our menus and plates literally stuck to the surface (it was sticky to touch). The server said there was a problem with the varnish. Kind of a bummer when celebrating an anniversary and two birthdays - something I noted when making the reservation.
Kelly's is a State College area institution, and the seafood and beef dishes are outstanding. Nice atmosphere, excellent service. Last week while we were there the electricity went out shortly after we were served, and after about 20 minutes without lights, they comp'ed our whole meal. Last night the lights stayed on, but still a wonderful meal.
Great variety and quality of food, try something new every time
Always a home run at Kelly’s
Excellent Copper River salmon and actually like their vegetables, too. Always a pleasant dining experience.
Excellent front of the house staff. Food quality was great and correct temps.
Varied menu, excellent service, tasty food. A neighborhood gem.
Always great food and service @ Kelly’s. The Ahi tuna was outstanding. Interesting wrinkle with this reservation…they charge a non-refundable reservation fee of $25 per person.
We opted to sit on the patio and were seated promptly at a table outside, with a nearby heat lamp (turned on at our request).
Our waitress informed us that a number of dishes were unavailable, including the ones that a few of us had been eyeing. So, a number of us got our our second choice meals.
Cocktails priced to be the most disappointing part of the dinner experience. The cosmopolitan and mojito ordered by two of our party were not drinkable. Apparently, they did not have mint for the mojito and used a mint-lemon(?) syrup instead. While this was explained prior to ordering, the impact on the drink itself wasn’t obvious until the cocktail was actually being consumed. Not good! Oddly, the cosmo looked nothing like our collective experience with that cocktail, and it didn’t taste right either.
The halibut cheeks, served with mashed potatoes and mixed vegetables were delicious. The portion was on the smaller size, especially notable when compared to the portion size of the salmon. Two in our party ordered the salmon and thought is was very good. One person ordered the pot with shrimp, clams and mussels; sausage was also included. He finished the entire meal and thought it was very good. Only one person. Ordered a steak. He also thought it was tasty and well-prepared.
Had to send steak back as it was rare and chewy and we had asked for medium doneness. Smoked salmon did not taste fresh and the ravioli was salty and greasy.
We arrived on time and got a table right away, which was a good start. Then the food was very good, and the service too.
Nice place, good selection of quality food, superb service.
Halibut cheeks are a rare and delicious treat, that must be tried. Accompanying potatoes and vegetables prepared well. Suggest they make it known a house salad may be substituted for veggies...or offer a small house salad with dinners at no charge. Lemon sorbet was a lovely follow-up....but tiramisu, which companions had, got very good reviews.
We love Kelly’s. Consistent food great people.
Kelly's provides a very good over-all dining experience. The service especially when there on June 9th was fabulous and the food was very good.
You can order delivery directly from Kelly's Steak and Seafood using the Order Online button. Kelly's Steak and Seafood also offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (814) 466-6251.
Kelly's Steak and Seafood is rated 4.6 stars by 359 OpenTable diners.
Kelly's Steak and Seafood does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.toasttab.com/kellyssteak/giftcards.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.