This includes info about cleaning, sanitising, social distancing, and usage of personal protective equipment. Learn More.
I•T•A Kitchen is a new modern chic dining space located in the heart of downtown Bay Shore. This open concept space has a beautiful mosaic tiled bar, modern brass lighting, with a black and white theme throughout the restaurant. The atmosphere is inviting and caters to everyone. Salvatore Sorrentino formerly of Matteo’s Family Style Restaurants & Andrea’s 25 is bringing the first Italian Fare to Bay Shore Village.
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
This was our first time eating at ITAKitchen...and it was fabulous. There were four of us, there was a Salmon, Veal dish, Saltimbocca requested and my dish Andrew's Chicken oh my goodness amazing...everything just perfect, cannot wait to visit again...
The food was absolutely amazing. Staff was nice and knowledgeable. Everyone was following the guidelines with masks. I can’t stress enough how amazing the chicken cutlet bowl was. Can’t wait to go back.
Food was delicious, service lacked a little bit being that it was so empty. Overall prices were on the higher side but worth it for the quality of food. Slightly disappointed there was no hot bread on the table before the entrees came out. Perhaps it’s Covid related, either way I would go back again.
If you like Italian food with great ambience and great service, come here. Very ideal for a date, small business meeting, or even a casual outing with friends.
Highly recommend the Artichoke Hearts Oreganata & Chicken Andrew!
It was perfect.
Had a group of 4 for dinner to try out this new local restaurant. We are all foodies and love good food so I was nervous because ITA was my pick. The food was absolutely amazing! I literally never eat meatballs ANYWHERE except my own at home and my friend ordered them. I have to say they were delicious. Service was very good and attentive. Drinks were very tasty as well as interesting. We were all very happily impressed with the experience overall and will 100% be returning for another fabulous dinner.
Amazing food and service!! The new outside area is gorgeous !!
We really enjoyed out date night here. I would recommend it to anyone. Will definitely come back
Amazing food. every item was delicious, good value. the Shrimp luciano was incredible. large fresh shrimp and the luciano sauce you want to take a quart home with you. the ITA fries are insanely good, must try them. the Zinguini was delicious, get the luciano chicken on top of it
FABULOUS dinner! Food is AMAZING!!! Service is OUTSTANDING! Thank you!!!
Everything was great, especially our server griselda.
Went for dinner and sat outside, very quiet and beautiful atmosphere. Our waitress Gina was wonderful!! The food was AMAZING! Hands down our new favorite Italian food restaurant!! Highly recommend the penne alla vodka, Mac and cheese, truffle fries, calamari, chicken vodka parm - everything was great.
The outdoor seating area is comfortable and cute. The wait service was a little slow, took about 15 - 20 minutes to get drinks. They were out of several items on the menu also. The food that we did order however was excellent. Everything tastes fresh and is full of flavor. They have an interesting modernized take on Italian cuisine. Will definitely eat here again.
First time visiting ITA Kitchen & the food was excellent! Had the lamb special and it surpassed my expectations. Will definitely be returning
Tonight was our first time back since reopening. The food and service was as great as ever. They really made us feel comfortable in this new dining environment. Welcome back!
Amazing food and cocktails with perfect service!
Great food and service!
Great service and great food.
First time there and we were so impressed. Food was delicious. Stumbled upon it looking for outside dining. Delicious- everything about it.
Food was amazing and staff was beyond accommodating :)) cannot wait to go back!
Got the chicken parm I was hungry it was great
Always great here
Outstanding meal. One of the best restaurants around. Tremendous value.
I read reviews on your restaurant and it was exactly what I expected Excellent
Peter, Thank you so much for this! We truly do have so much passion for Italian Food & really try to convey that. We hope to see you again soon! The ITA Family
Overall I wasn't impressed the seating was too close together. The table was not set properly and the food was just so so. For the prices I expected a little more.
Michele, We apologize you did not have a positive experience by us. We know the weekends can get a little hectic. We hope you give us another try again. The ITA Family
The goat cheese salad and buratta avocado toast was delicious. My truffle source gnocchi was amazing. Service was great and they even comped the dessert since the fritters were a little over fried. Great experience. Would go back again.
We're so glad you enjoyed your experience! Thank You for dining with us and we hope to see you again soon! The ITA Family
Great meal but this happened. My friend & I both noticed on the website that it was ladies night so we were even happier that we had chosen ITA..We both ordered wine, not by any particular name brand, and it was fine. When we received the bill we noticed we had been charged full price, thinking it was an error, we called over the waitress to ask her. She told us she didn’t give us the wine that applies to the ladies night so she charged us full price. We thought she might have been confused because we hadn’t asked for any particular wine, we assumed she knew because she didn’t ask us either. She said in a huff she would talk to the manager but came back with some website that we didn’t see and went on to exclusions...what? Also saying we have to be 8 or more to get ladies night pricing. That makes no sense. I pulled up
the website that shows it was ladies night And it said bar or table. Included beer, wine or Well drinks. In the amend it wasn’t worth arguing with her and we paid the extra $2 per glass of wine. It just ruined the evening to see her roll her eyes at us, when clearly it should have been the other way around. I’m so disappointed that this happened because I have been there before and have also referred others to go there. My girlfriend will not be doing the same, unfortunately. Meal was great but not sure it’s worth the aggravation after a long day. Must be why there weren’t many more ladies there for “Ladies Night”. If you go and there is and they claim to have a special that night, I advise you to ask first or make sure to go over your bill. At the end, if she would have just acknowledged the mistake, she would have gotten that much more in a tip. We certainly didn’t tip her badly but just saying...not how we would have normally tipped. We tend to slide up in tip because we’re not bad people or cheap. Just the point. That was all. (If there was a manager there & he/she advised the waitress to act that way, then shame on them & not her fault.
We apologize you didn't have a good experience with us. We now offer a Price Fixe Menu for 4 or More ladies on Wednesdays for $34.95 pp plus tax which includes Martini's, Bellini's, Mimosa's, & House Wine. We do not have any packages that offer any other Wine other then House Wine except on Sundays we offer 1/2 price select bottles. I can assure you our manager would not condone the staff treating any customer poorly and we will discuss it. We hope you give us another try in the future.
We enjoy ITA, and were looking fwd to the new menu. The Veal Rolitini was amazing and a great portion. The Gnocchi is my go to dish, it tasted great, except it was missing the shaved truffle, I feel like that's what makes the dish. I'm not sure if that is a change with the new menu or an oversite. We shared the fried rainbow cookies for dessert.
We're so happy you enjoyed the Veal Rollatini! The Gnocchi hasn't had the Truffle on it for a bit now, but it does have Truffle Oil in the dish. Unfortunately getting them out of season can be difficult. We appreciate your patience and we hope to see you again soon! The ITA Family
Excellent food. Great atmosphere! Drinks were good. Only issue ran out of proper glassware for drinks but didn’t bother us. Complimentary dessert was thoughtful!!!
Thank You for such kind words on your overall experience. We appreciate your patience and we hope to see you again soon! The ITA Family
Excellent four star food service and ambiance. Love this place.
Get the pounded veal cutlet and the broccoli rabe and sausage egg rolls
Five * experienced
Thank you staff your great !!!
This is absolutely wonderful to hear! Thank You so much!! SJ's Veal Chop is a Fan Favorite! And the Rabe & Sausage Egg Rolls as well! We're very happy you enjoyed your entire experience. We hope to see you again soon! The ITA Family
An absolute must go!!!! The gnocchi will melt in your mouth. The fried rainbow cookies are outstanding.
Thank You so much for your kind words! The gnocchi is made in house fresh daily so we're very happy it shows :) We hope to serve you again soon! The ITA Family
Food was delicious and atmosphere was great! Highly recommend checking it out!
Meagan, Thank You!!! We're glad you enjoyed everything and hope to see you again soon!
Great as always
Angelo, Thank you to you and your family for being such wonderful customers. We look forward to serving you all each and every time. Sal & Christina
Great food and service
Outstanding. One of the best in Bay Shore. Never had a bad dish and the service and prices are great.
Food was great, service was attentive. We will definitely be back!
Fantastic place! Excellent food! Great service! Perfect ambience for date night!
First time visit. Will definitely go back. Food was so good and really nice atmosphere.
ITA Kitchen does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. ITA Kitchen also offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 267-5916.
ITA Kitchen is rated 4.5 stars by 109 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.