Cutler & Co

We enjoyed our Sunday lunch at Cutler & Co. The entrees were delicious, however the main pasta (garganelli) was disappointing. I was so looking forward to lovely tender homemade fare, however the actual pasta was firm and and not very tasty. My dessert of chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream was scrumptious. Attentive, friendly service. Thanks

My wife and I shared a wonderful night of great food, excellent wine and remarkable friendly service from people who enjoy their work and want the customer to feel comfortable and welcome. Would recommend this place to anyone who wants to experience fine food and a special night out.

An enjoyable evening enjoying a scrumptious meal. Our waiter was knowledgeable and attentive.

The food was great but the service was very poor for a fine dining restaurant.

It’s a good dining restaurant for catching up with friends or dates. They provide good quality service and oysters are yummy.

We went on a Sunday and had the Sunday menu, it was delicious, plenty of food for $85. Service was great everyone was very friendly and their wine recommendations were spot on. Loved it.

Celebrated a first anniversary here for Sunday lunch; the food and service were outstanding. The Sunday lunch was a great vibe, a bit more relaxed than I imagine an evening reservation. Would absolutely recommend and go back again.

Absolutely the best Sunday Lunch in Melbourne - best enjoyed with the matching wines.

The staff were so pleasant and attentive without any arrogant or snobby attitude.

The food was absolutely delicious, I cannot fault it. The chefs are clearly wonderful. However, I must say the service was very disappointing. The dishes weren’t properly explained. No extra detail was given unless we asked for and it felt like an effort to understand the menu because of this. I wish the staff had been more personal.

The food, service and atmosphere was amazing, highly recommend cutler to all my friend

This was my fourth and final visit to Cutler & Co. On arrival the greeting was brusque and unfriendly. My party, comprising of two, were sat directly in front of a doorway connecting the bar and restaurant. It was noisy and other patrons were often skirting around us which was intrusive and uncomfortable. Our waiter was pleasant and knowledgeable and the chef’s menu was satisfactory but rather pedestrian. Overall the evening was disappointing and not deserving of the $505 (before tip) tariff.

The sourdough bread was amazing. It came with two kinds of butter. Two! The food in general was great, and there was plenty of it. We struggled to finish the last courses of the chef's selection menu as we were so full at that point. Everything else was amazing too - the service was great, and the ambience was perfect for a candlelit dinner date.

Always a marvellous experience at Cutler & Co. Really can't fault it.

Had the Sunday degustation lunch. Amazing food and service. Will be back!

Excellent venue for a big night out. Great food & service.

Amazing service paired with incredible food. Definitely coming back!

Cutler and Co was fantastic! Do yourself a favour and let the team at Cutler give you an experience you won't forget! The Ox Tongue was memorable and Sommelier Liam O'Brien delivered!

We had a wonderful evening out for my husband's birthday. One of the only two night's we've had out since the birth of our baby a year ago and as my husband is an ex-chef I wanted to book somewhere that he'd find impressive but also enjoyable. Food was lovely, the wine was amazing and the service was brilliant. Our waitress was on her very first shift and she was one of the highlights of our evening, just really friendly and knowledgeable and not pretentious at all. Our sommelier was also fantastic and as a wine enthusiast, I thoroughly enjoyed every wine we tried. We don't go out often so this was a real treat for us, hence the splurge but it was a memorable evening.

Perfect Dining Experience
Highly recommended ✅
The staff were very professional and the food was exceptional

It was my first meal at Cutler very aware and friendly. The food was delicious and the courses were spaced out. Most enjoyable experience.

A very nice place. Food was superb, matched by the wonderful service. Thank you! We'll be back for sure.

Thank you Cuttler and Co, what a beautiful dining experience, just perfect in every way the drinks the food the ambiance and the lovely professional enthusiastic staff , Apart from GLO GLOs back in the 80s Cuttler and Co will never be forgotten.

Ridiculously slow service. 3.5 hours for the tasting menu is way too long.

A really special place! We had an incredible night- great food,wine,atmosphere and incredible service! A great “special occasion place”

Stand out dining experience of the last 5 years.

From the moment we arrived to the minute we left, the service was impeccable. Attentive, with out being in your face.

The food was sublime. Each dish was a delight to our taste buds. And the matching wines were delivered by a knowledgeable and charismatic sommelier.

Perfect decor

What’s not to love!

Overall for the amount we paid food was underwhelming. Fish was dry and mushroom pie was a bit too strong. The pork was beautiful. The service was wonderful and the atmosphere lovely.

Upfront poor experience of being asked to wait at front of the restaurant (we were early) and not offered a drink or anything for about 10 minutes. Then moved to a really open table which was cold and drafty. As I had been to the restaurant on several occasions before, I was feeling agitated and so asked to be moved. This was done with apology and grace. Once this occurred, we had a fabulous meal and matching wines as well as great service. Highly knowledgeable staff - sommelier was great and listened to preference to go with cheese.

Outstanding across the board. One of the best places for a decadent Sunday lunch in Melbourne

My husband and I were still talking about the meal and service the next day. It was a wonderful experience and we cannot wait until we have another special occasion to celebrate, because I know where we will be eating.

What an experience, from the moment we stepped foot into this modern and well articulated restaurant we felt relaxed and jubilant. Every staff member was so welcoming and friendly and immediately our preconceptions of antiquated formality associated with fine dining evaporated. (the chefs in the open kitchen even welcomed us in!). The food was splendid, well thought out and very balanced. We enjoyed each mouth full more than the previous. Special thanks to Simone who looked after us the entire evening and made it that extra bit special!

My husband and I shared the duck which was a little bland, and possibly a touch on the rare side as it was slightly chewy. The oysters and whiting we had for entree were excellent. Excellent service and overall a lovely evening.

The service was amazing. It was same as Michelin star restaurant level (in Japan)

I really enjoyed food as well. I really liked King george whiting dish.
But, because of everything was perfect to me, the red emporer dish seemed a bit boring to me. I would prefer more flaver and different type of sauce.

I also had Cherry blossom dessert, but personally, I didnt like this dessert. the presentation was very nice, however I didnt like the taste and texture of purple thing?

Very nice place. Food was good without being outstanding, no dish wowed us. Large bone in fish, received and apology and gave a complementary desert.
We felt overall it was overpriced by about 33%

Great produce, Profeesional and friendly staff and outstanding value for money

Very few high end experiences deliver in Melbourne. The service can be smug and the prices are extortionate.
However, Cutler and Co was tremendous. It stands out among the hype. Exceptional service, gorgeous space and simple menu. Well done team.

We had our dinner here for the first night of our honeymoon trip around Austalia. It was a fantastic experience, we received exemplary service from start to finish.

We had the zucchini flower and the mouth-watering dry aged rib eye (recommend reserving a piece when making a booking) to share. It tasted amazing and cooked to perfection. We did have a dessert each, however I forgot the name of them, but it was definitely worth a try too.

Give this place a try, will recommend it to anyone!

Simply amazing. We decided to share plates so they brought us 2 plates for each dish with divided portions. The butter is the best I have ever had! Every single dish was cooked to perefection. We had a great night

Amazing food and fantastic service! Cosy ambience and nicely spaced out tables for privacy. We were served by Simone who was so friendly and genuine. We had the chef’s selection and loved the spanner crab dish and the Blueberry vacherin dessert the most. Would definitely come back.

I will be purchasing a gift voucher soon For a 50th birthday gift.