Cutler & Co

Only issue was that serving staff with a bit slow with bringing us the wine menue when asked, and then forget part of the order (i.e additional potatoes and salad to the set menue which they in fact suggested) which we never received.....Food and wine was fantastic, and venue lovely

We finally managed to get a reservation at Cutler and Co!!
From the moment we stepped in the door we were greeted by impeccably groomed and polite staff who were very kind and welcoming. The ambience, decor and lighting were perfect. The restaurant was quiet, elegant but also unprententious. Fine dining at its best. We chose the Chef’s menu which was outstanding for every course. Beautifully presented and impeccable quality of ingredients. Each course was smallish but very adequate for us. 5 stars for Romy our lovely waitress!!

Great night as always. Great sommelier, a fantastic menu and a calm and stylish room.

Impeccable service with a stand out Sommelier and wine list.
Perfect Sunday afternoon to celebrate a promotion!

Was an absolutely fantastic experience. Simply outstanding food and wine, outstanding service and a fantastic dining space. Cannot wait to return.

Unbelievable

Fabulous service, food, welcome, wine list. Coping well with the post CV world. Great space too. Good value with set menu given all the above. One of the gems of Melbourne, with a diverse and loyal following.

The service was outstanding - Hannah was a terrific host and the 2 waitresses that looked after us were friendly, professional and on top of everything. All-round it was a wonderful experience!

Cutler and Co maintains a very high standard across the board. One my favourite dining experiences for special occasions.

Really great atmosphere. Service was excellent, food amazing.

Great but very limited menu with no red meat except for an $80 extra charge.

The food is exquisite, very refined flavours, hearty at the same time. Friendly staff looking after our table was new and did not fully comprehend nut allergy can mean all nuts and not just peanuts. Overall a really lovely evening, we will return.

Sunday menu is good value. Service is endearing. Melbourne institution

Wonderful venue to celebrate our 46th wedding anniversary. Also a big plus just to get out with this COVIDSafe shutdown. Cutler& Co are certainly a professional act in all aspects.

Overall the experience was great. I was a bit disappointed about two dishes. The tomato salad which was good but meh and the peppers where far to spicy. However, the other dishes were absolutely amazing. The service outstanding and polite.

Just seemed overpriced and no food was a standout considering the high price paid for dishes; these prices give you an expectation and it wasn't met.

Superb restaurant serving delicious food with first rate service. Highly recommended.

We had an amazing dinner at Cutler & Co. We were greeted upon arrival and the service and food for the evening was incredible. I would recommend this experience to all my friends and family. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable about the food and wine. It was a night to remember.

Was in my top 3 in Melb, but now in main restaurant only set menu. Yet if you sit in the bar you can order what you want. Chefs selection is ok for the chef. If I am paying in excess of $220 per head, I wan to eat what I want, not what the chef wants.
No more for me

Such attentive and friendly waitstaff, the food was amazing. The setting was great too. Would definitely recommend.

Perfect. Food, pace, recommended wines, beautiful service. Love it.

Just had one mishap with one course, but other than that very good.

Very good for a special occasion or just catching up with friends.
Quality food & service at not eye watering prices!

Awesome loved it great service food and venue will come back

Had a lovely Sunday lunch, thought it was good value for the money. Variety of meals was good, entrees were excellent. Main meals were generous. Desserts were a little disappointing compared to the rest of the meal.

Amazing food that is up there with the best meals we have had.

Our food took way too long to come out. Waited a minimum of 40 minutes for our 3rd meal. Kept us hungry for awhile. However staff was very nice tho. Quite soft spoken but they are nice and helpful

Great food and place, and pretty good value for the quality. Left feeling full and satisfied. However service was oddly poor this night.

Excellent service and a thoroughly enjoyable evening from start to finish, including a very memorable list of wines by the glass.

Absolutely outstanding meal, service and atmosphere. Highly recommend!!

I was seated in the back part of the restaurant and it was at least 15 or 20:minutes before my waiters even looked in my direction. Inwas dining alone and have done this many times in restaurants all over the world, and I felt he was giving more attention to the couples than to me. This is not a feeling Iv’e experienced when dining in top restaurants before.

Food was nice, would be nice if there is a combo for 3 or 4 people to share other thn the rib eye.

We got seated in an area w poor lighting, the inner restaurant has much better ambience and setting.

Other thn that everything was excellent, staff friendly etc.

My wife and I had the best time for our anniversary dinner. Everything was perfect!

Fabulous food and service.

Atmosphere and service is reasonably good, what you would expect of a restaurant with two hats. Being Valentine's day, a 6 course set menu of $170 is mandatory for all diners, which is understandable. However, the quality of the food leaves a lot to be desired. Portions are OK but could be more generous, if not add on the number of courses. Besides one of the courses is actually a tablespoon of sorbet as palate cleanser. One of the dishes was a tomato salad, which basically consists of chopped tomatoes and some dressing, something that most can prepare at home. The dessert was also disappointing too. Given the price paid, I wonder whether I was in my local bistro or a two hatted restaurant.

Delicious food, great setting, helpful staff. The reviews of this restaurant were not overrated.

Great food and ambiance. Service spectacular. Very pricey but that is what you get for this type of service and freshness. Would highly recommend

I had a fantastic time at Cutler & Co. It had been on my list of restaurant to try for years. 5 of us celebrated my birthday and we bought the signature chocolate cake which was amazing. The staff were welcoming, attentive and friendly. All of the food was of the standard you would expect, and there were appetizers and palate cleansers between courses which were thoughtful and delicious. The wine list was well rounded and we had wonderful cocktails and even a daigingo sake. Looking forward to the next visit!

Wonderful dining experience, delicious and beautiful food, great service in an ambient atmosphere.

Will definitely be going back. Really enjoyed the ambiance and the food was excellent. The wine, although a tad expensive, was exceptional. Also I need to add the service was exceptional. Had a drink in the bar next door beforehand and really enjoyed there as well. I think they may be linked.