Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Commack
Always a good time and meal at Anthony
Excellent experience and one of my family's favorite local restaurants. They have a fully stocked bar and TV's which add to the experience. The pizza is great and they have expanded their menu to provide other options for food.
Had a great meal and a great time! Looking forward to going back soon.
Very good food. Even my picky kids were happy! Only problem was they didn’t have my reservation from open table. Thankfully they sat us quickly but not sure about using open table anymore.
We enjoyed our meal. Our server was very friendly and knowledgeable. Always a good time when we visit Anthony’s.
We stopped in for an early dinner on the weekend, before it got too crowded. Given the amount of customers, service was spotty. Very nice and friendly, but it was hard to find our server at times, and we waited a long time for various reappearances, and wound up having to ask the food runner and bartender for a couple of things. At one point, after waiting a lengthy period of time, I had to physically get up to track down salt and pepper, which inexplicably, is not among the seasonings on the table. That said, the food was good, but service could be tightened up a bit.
Great service. The drinks were great and the pizza was good as always.
Been to several Anthony’s. Always order pizza and salad. The pizza at this location is very different... not in a good way. Dough is thicker and overworked, so it was tough. I prefer the Woodbury location.
Horrible horrible service but foods good.
Great wings & meatballs
Honestly, the meatball and ricotta pizza and italian salad were good. But the service and cleanliness were not good at all. Don't think I will go there again, unless maybe to take out.
Consistent quality is what brings us back to Anthony's. Chicken wings can't be beat and we enjoy the variety of pizzas. Start with the house salad and you can't go wrong!
Best wings and meatballs in town
My go to lunch spot.
When I arrived they told me they did not have a reservation for me and do not take reservations. There was a line of people and my time was limited due to another obligation later that evening. The hostess was great and made sure she cleared a table right away and gave us priority seating. We were at a table within 5 minutes. Food and service were good.
Food is delicious, service is great.
The food was standard for Anthony’s, however the restaurant was very dirty. Tables and chairs were sticky and there was food scattered all over the floor.
Great lunch spot
The restaurant was very cold. There were multiple people sitting with coats on and telling the wait staff that they felt cold to no avail. The pizza was tasty but we wished it was much warmer inside the restaurant.
Well as good and consistent as always NY pizza is the best in the world BUT Anthony’s is pretty damn good as well !!! If you like well done thin crust go have a pie
Great for business lunches
Great place for lunch and dinner
Great lunch spot
Great spot for business lunches
Very good food. I love their brick oven pizza. Always crispy, never soggy. Tried their chicken sandwich and it was phenomenal. WOW
Overall excellent food. We had salad and wings for appetizers and both were very good. Pizza was enough for the 3 of us and we also ordered a cheese calzone, which was excellent. Good place to come to grab a drink, watch sports and eat pizza with friends and family.
The pizza was very good and the service was friendly and accommodating. The seats we were in could have used a little extra attention to the cleaning after the last guests.
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Commack offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 858-2625.
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Commack is rated 4.5 stars by 28 OpenTable diners.
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Commack does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://acfp.myguestaccount.com/guest/egift?ic=EG1.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.