Food was excellent but service was lacking. The bus man was terrific and one of the waiters but the other waiter was not good. Took forever to bring drinks and unapologetic when I questioned if our drinks were coming. Food was really good and fresh
Christmas eve dinner for 4 was really delicious. Huge portions, authentic Italian food, excellent seafood (zuppa di pesce, red snapper & flounder francaise) & service with style & experience.(our waiter has been in service business for 40 yrs +). Only drawback is size, but the name says it all!
Great food great service.
Authentic & delicious Italian food with outstanding service. A real treat & highly recommend!
Sat outside which was very relaxing.
Wonderful eating in their lovely patio. Food was good, too.
Was very excited to see that Carlos is back!
There a tons of Italian places in Mamaroneck. This is my favorite. It is the Goldilocks option for quality, value, and ambiance. Their caprese is a must. We get it every time we go.
I wish I could have given 3 1/2 stars. It was pretty good but I also realize that you can't judge a place on one experience. Our waiter was nice. There isn't much atmosphere, tiny place with a backyard seating area. I thought the food was good but but not great. I'm not running back there.
I was with a friend, very early for lunch. We sat outside, brought our own wine and shared salads. The waiter could not have been more accommodating or more gracious. Arugula Portobello salad and the caprese salad which included roasted peppers and procuitto was so fresh, so full of taste and so big we didn't get to entrees. We sat outside, which was very pleasant, despite the hot day. Felt like I was in Italy. We will definitely go back and highly recommend Piccolo Mulino for a very enjoyable and satisfying dining experience.
Third time to this restaurant and the quality of food has been amazing each time. It was nice to sit in the back patio this time.
We had reservations at 6:3o for the Emelin show at 8 pm and we were 15 min late for the show
This was after speaking to the waiters at least 5 times
We had no appetizer,no dessert
The service and food turnaround was terrible
We ate on the patio early in the evening and so had a lovely quiet dinner in a pleasant atmosphere. Really appreciate the flowers and plants.
Piccolo Mulino is a neighborhood Italian restaurant. It is convenient to the Emelin Theater. We dine there several times a year. The food this time was good, but not the best we've had. The bread seemed like it was stale bread that had been reheated. We had the hot appetizer for two, which was fine but not exceptional. It turned out we hadn't ordered carefully, because both the appetizer and my husband's red snapper were very heavy with mussels. My veal special was good but the veal could have been more tender. Tiramisu was very good.
There was a large, very noise group at the restaurant while we were there. Everyone else had no choice but to listen to their conversation. Rude diners seem to becoming more of a problem everywhere!
Waited one hour for bread and another 40 minutes for food. This was not the case on a prior visit. Waiter said they were overbooked ..people left after their food was finally served. They had it wrapped and left!!! The entire restaurant was composing... no excuse for staff not checking in with the dinners! Not even a drink on the house.
We always enjoy a great meal at Picolo Mulino- it's one of our favorites. And, it it ever stops raining, the patio is lovely.
We went on Saturday at 6:15pm and the servers seemed overwhelmed. Had to wait 15 minutes for menus.
Waited a while for food but it was worth the wait. Salads and eggplant rolatini apps were good. Chicken francaise and marsala were very good. Also there bread and complementry bruschetta was very good. Will go again on a weekday.
While small and seemingly not on everybody's radar, this restaurant is surely worth a visit. There are nightly specials i addition to the regular menu; the kitchen is consistent and the food is very good. The service is also good. I am especially fond of the very tasty stuffed artichoke appetizer.
Excellent food by the standards of the best Westchester Italian restaurants (Trust me, I’ve been to them.) at bargain prices.
While the waitstaff was very attentive, the food was not good. We regretted trying a new place.
Excellent food, service and atmosphere. A gem of a neighborhood restaurant!
Wonderful small restaurant with delicious food!
Always a great place for a romantic dinner for two. Great food and excellent attentive service. The Veal Sinatra was out of this world.
Piccolo Mulino is our favorite restaurant in Mamaroneck. The food is wonderful, the staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. Make a reservation as the place is quite small and the word has spread how wonderful it is!
Been coming here for a number of years and I have never been disappointed. My favorite restaurant in the area.
GREAT Food. Wonderful ambiance and service. Love eating here.
This is my 2nd time at Piccolo. Again, didn't disappoint. Our waiter (2nd time) was Jesse -- so pleasant, very attentive. Everyone at Piccolo's is amazing. The food, ambiance and service is impeccable. Taking my partner in a few weeks and we are looking forward to it. Thank you to Piccolo and staff!
I am looking forward to returning. Food was amazing! The service was exceptional. Very attentive. We were 15mins late for our original dining time due to bad weather and traffic, they graciously changed our time and were very accommodating. We certainly appreciated it! The ambience was perfect. Great for intimate dining as well as large crowds. Happy New Year!
Great meal an wonderful service. We had a group of 6 people, 2 vegetarian, 1 vegan and 4 meat eaters-everyone loved their meal.
We loved the food, we loved the owner, we loved the atmosphere. We will definitely go back. Carbonara was amazing.
Food was amazing
Pleasant dinner. Attentive service. Old world Italian food. Unfortunately this small restaurant was quite cold on a Sunday evening.
This is my go to restaurant whenever I have tickets at the Emelin. Food is always great as well as service. Noise level is low and prices are moderate. We have always had a wonderful meal with great service at a reasonable price.
We're lucky to have such a great restaurant in Mamaroneck, and particularly lucky to have access to the Emelin Theater from the restaurant.
Excellent food and service. Great size portions - high quality.
Restaurant is very small. As long as there are no big noisy groups you are AOK.
Truly enjoyed our dinner and will return.
We are always pleased when we leave the restaurant with full bellies and full hearts.
Had a most delicious meal of flounder almonds, wine and my friend had pasta with shellfish. Nice, quiet room where we could actually talk. What a pleasure. Can’t wait to return.
Great family dinner
This is the second time we have dined here and loved it both times. The waiters are pleasant and the atmosphere is charming. Next time we'll bring friends so they can enjoy it too! Delicious.
Great food and service. Small, somewhat quaint setting. Quiet enough to easily carry on a conversation. Highly recommend for a dinner out with friends or family.