During This Difficult Time, PF Market is offering Take Outs & Free Deliveries to the areas close to the restaurant. Call us at 973-227-1007 to get your favorite fish or Old York Wine Delivered at your Door.
Delivery also supported by UberEats & GrubHub.
served with a lemon-herb dressing
First night reopened after COVID-19and as usual very good! Glad they are back and they should keep the outside dining permanently. Thank you!
Honestly food was OK. I probably wouldn't go back as I was rushed out the door. From valet parking my car to departure-30 minutes. That a soup for one and 3 entrees-30 minutes. No check in's from management or waiter.
They are the Jose Tejas of "Fish.
Unfortunately had a bad food experience here, first time ever. Staff is always terrific. Been here many times. Ambiance, decor, unimportant.
Unique IPad type menu listing excellent food choices. The seafood was prepared deliciously. It was fresh and tasty. Veggies were crisp and fresh also. I had a fillet that I never heard of
( barmundi) that the waiter described perfectly.
We will return soon. All four of us were pleased!
Outstanding! The fish was so fresh. I had pistachio crusted swordfish, cherrystone clams and amarone gelato and each course was excellent.
The server was very nice, and we were not rushed.
The only reason I did not give 5 stars was the decor was not very nice with plastic fish on the wall and the dining room was so cramped that the waiter smashed into my table multiple times. I found out later that the upstairs dining room is much nicer.
I will definitely be going back to P.F. Market.
It was a birthday celebration and no acknowledgment was given when the reservation indicated birthday.
We went early. It was nice and quiet and the food was delicious
The fish was delicious and fresh. The Chef was open to modifying the entrees to our needs
Food was great, service excellent! Overall Very minor, but bread was stale and cold...
Seafood is always fresh and quality very consistent. Being a BYO is always a plus.
Definitely in our rotation of local favorites!
From the moment we walked in it felt like we were going to dinner with family/friends. It was so romantic and quaint. Every single employee I encountered was so friendly! One of the best Valentine’s Dinners I’ve had!
Great service, and excellent seafood place
Everyone enjoyed the meal and the service was great. Consistently good food.
Fresh and delicious. Generous portions and the cheese cake is yummy.
Very Happy with my dining experience and my wife enjoyed it thoroughly.
Excellent fresh fish, service always excellent; our fav spot
Fish was fresh as always and prepared as requested. Restaurant goes out of its way to accommodate any and all requests. Steve staff is especially professional and nice especially Leslie and Nadia. Free valet parking is a nice touch especially when compared to the nightmare in Montclair that everyone experiences as they look for a parking space.
This restaurant had the freshest seafood and excellent service. We had the seafood salad appetizer, lobster bisque, Chilean sea bass (which was fresh and melted in your mouth. The seafood fra diavolo was full of fresh seafood. To cap off a fantastic meal the chocolate lava cake, strawberry cheesecake and pistachio tartufo were perfect. Will definitely return!
We've eaten here before and have always been pleased with the food. It is fresh and well prepared. I especially like the lobster.
Excellent seafood prepared perfectly. A real treat and our favorite.
I had the Sea Bass special which was coated with macadamia nuts. It was moist & delicious. It came over Pea & Mushroom Risotto. My boyfriend had the whole grilled Bronzino. It was expertly prepared. His came with a nice dish of escarole & beans. .
Great food and great service! What more could you ask for? We brought two friends who had never eaten there, and they LOVED it!! Highly recommend the octopus appetizer, as well as the tuna tartare.
Never again! Who knows how need to looks seafood will never it here
Casual environment with a warm, knowledgeable, friendly staff. Food is always well prepared and simple. Excellent pastas and fish dishes.
Food and service were very good, but it is a bit pricy.
Brought friends back this time and both couples loved it. Never a bad meal at PF. Highly recommend it.
I was just expecting more based on reviews. No lobster in my paella, although the flavor was good.
We’ve eaten there many times and the food was good. This time it was bad.
Great spot for really fresh seafood. Also nice and quiet so you can have a group and hear everyone at the table.
Outstanding service and food, will be back!
The food and service are always excellent
Did not realize when we booked that restaurant had new owners
Second time back and the food was better than the first time. Not as noisy as last time and the food came out much faster.
Not like before.. New Owners. Food was just Okay. Not Bad but didn't stand out either. A bit tasteless and dry. They came same Chef but I kind of doubt it. Do a fan of the new menu either as I miss our favorite. Calamari Chino was boring. Stuffed flounder with Lobster and Crab Meat was lacking the Lobster and very dry and bland. How sad.. we used to love it there.
Same as always... We love this place! Food is fresh, hot and tasty.
Very disappointed in the value of each meal. A salad is not even included as many competitors do with meals starting in the mid $30s.
Went on a Thursday evening; relatively empty at 7:15 pm. Service was very good and food was good, although the grilled octopus was not up to the usual standard. Menu is less extensive than it used to be, but still plenty of options so long as you're looking for seafood
First time at P.F. Market, only reason I gave it 4 starts instead of 5 was the kitchen was backed up. Our salad even took a lot longer than normal. The entree and salads were excellent and would definitely be back. Other knock on the place that it is very loud so just be prepared for that. Overall, good experience!
Seated immediately for a 7:45 dinner, hostess handed us menus and was poured water, waited 15 min before waiter came over to open wine ( byob) . Ordered appetizers took 30 min before they came out, our main course came out at 9:20 after, the staff never checking to see if we needed anything, at one point they took water pitcher to refill it and never brought it back, had to ask for water again,.
Food , presentation excellen!
Staff horrible service!
P.F. Market offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 227-1007.
P.F. Market is rated 4.4 stars by 793 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.