Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

View all

Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

View all

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(801)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2673)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(387)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Shelter Island restaurants

  • Restaurant List

Shelter Island Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Shelter Island restaurants

Shelter Island Restaurants

Vine Street Cafe
Vine Street Cafe
(943)
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Always a great experience. Good food, service and ambiance. More

OpenTable Diner -
Pridwin Hotel
Pridwin Hotel
(97)
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Beautiful setting over looking the water. The waitresses were lovely and the food excellent. Great value not something one can often say about the Hamptons area. Especially so given the setting. Highly recommend More

OpenTable Diner -
Red Maple at The Chequit
Red Maple at The Chequit
(107)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

We loved the oysters and steamed littlenecks, especially the littleneck broth. Fish tacos, veggie burger and fluke were also all outstanding. Service was attentive and friendly. More

OpenTable Diner -
18 Bay
18 Bay
(399)
$$$$
Italian | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

What a pleasure to visit 18 Bay. The entire experience was first rate. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and efficient, the wine list is expansive and the food was delightful. The menu was seasonal, fresh and creative with gorgeous flavors and textures. For a high end tasting menu, I think the restaurant is quite affordable as well. I just generally liked the entire vibe in this restaurant. You can tell in every aspect that the owner/chefs take pride in their business and put the customer experience first.... More

OpenTable Diner -
SALT Shelter Island
SALT Shelter Island
(194)
$$$$
Seafood | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Great water front restaurant in a beautiful waterfront location. Good food, good service and great location. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
(151)
$$$$
Mediterranean | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

It just wouldn't be summer if I didn't pay at least one visit to this Shelter Island staple. Each year the chef reinvents some basic item into a melt in your mouth affair. This year it's the straciatella with asparagus. While burrata is on everyone else's menu everywhere, this is a scrumptious variation on the trend finished with a lemon zest that makes it sing. The mussels are always flavorful as is pretty much everything on the menu. We always share at least 3 or 4 items like the cevice that was so amazing fresh we tried to take our time and savor every bite. Make a reservation in advance soon. They roll up and out on Labor Day. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sweet Tomato's
Sweet Tomato's
(9)
$$$$
Italian | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Were seated promptly. Wait staff was very attentive. Food recommendations were perfect! Enjoyed our meals. Will definitely return. More

OpenTable Diner -
Fresh, The Restaurant
Fresh, The Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Osprey Bar & Lounge
Osprey Bar & Lounge
(47)
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Nice room, nice server, pricy. Eating on Island’s is always pricey. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Shelter Island Tavern
The Shelter Island Tavern
(72)
$$$$
Contemporary Italian | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

The tavern offers wonderful food and service! We have eaten there nearly a dozen times with a variety of delicious options. We are always impressed. More

OpenTable Diner -
Port Waterfront Bar and Grill
Port Waterfront Bar and Grill
Reviews coming soon
Contemporary American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

PORT Waterfront Bar and Grill provides fun and friendly waterfront dining in Greenport, NY. Enjoy lobster rolls, duck tacos, burgers and wings while dining outside on our patio or at one of our two bars. Enjoy a margarita or painkiller and live music daily. Come by boat, land or air - Just come are you are! Brought to you by the team behind SALT Shelter Island.More