Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

View all

Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

View all

Best Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(894)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(376)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
View all New York Area restaurants

Hungry for something new? Explore Shelter Island restaurants.

Shelter Island Restaurants

Vine Street CafeVine Street Cafe
909 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

As usual the service and ambiance were outstanding. The only reason for a four star review instead of five is that the Crispy Duck Confit, although still very good, was not as "special" as it was before it became a regular menu item. More

OpenTable Diner -
Red Maple at The ChequitRed Maple at The Chequit
105 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

We love this Restaurant in SI. The carrots were raw with the chicken dish. The broth with the mussels was like water. The waitress was very slow with the orders. Overall the food is usually delicious . More

OpenTable Diner -
Pridwin HotelPridwin Hotel
80 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter Island, Long Island / Hamptons

Exceptional menu, great ambience, music, staff and food! More

OpenTable Diner -