Best American Restaurants in Montauk

View all

Best American Restaurants in Montauk

Best Seafood Restaurants in Montauk

View all

Best Seafood Restaurants in Montauk

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(770)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2746)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
Café Boulud
(706)
$$$$
French | Upper East Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Montauk restaurants

  • Restaurant List
  • Best restaurants

Montauk Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Montauk restaurants

Montauk Restaurants

Scarpetta Beach
Scarpetta Beach
(535)
$$$$
Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Can’t say enough how perfect it was. It was our engagement dinner and we chose the perfect spot for it. Food was outstanding and service amazing. We would be back for sure. Thank you so much to all of you. More

OpenTable Diner -
Muse at the end
Muse at the end
(419)
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Anniversary dinner at Muse. Everything was absolutely delicious! The meal started with warm fresh little loaves of bread with port wine cheese spread, olive oil and butter. I got the $35 early dinner special that runs from 530-630pm. Included a salad which hubby ate and loved, and I got the blue cheese salad a la carte for $12. It was insane!!! Could only eat half, brought the other half home. Then hubs got the Gorgonzola steak that came with awesome potatoes $52 and my meal was the chickpea chicken-delicious!!!! We finished off sharing my dessert-a chocolate flourless cake served with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, and fresh berries. The atmosphere was romantic and we will definitely be back! Altogether with a Peroni for him $8 and Prosecco $14 and coffee for me $3, the bill was $133. So worth every penny. The service was outstanding, too. Highly recommend! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
(6)
$$$$
Unspecified | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was tasty, especially smoked fish chowder. Our waiter, Eugene was very friendly and efficient. Prices are too high, in particular, can of beer is $9. Open Table lists this place as inexpensive with two dollars sign. Not really! More

OpenTable Diner -
Showfish
Showfish
(77)
$$$$
Seafood | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

This restaurant was highly recommended to us by a trustworthy lady! We have been coming to Montauk for years and we were very impressed with everything about Showfish - The food was interesting and not too overwhelming - The tables were lovely and private, there's a vibrant bar scene if you are looking for some fun - And the restaurant was far enough away from the bar to be very quite and lovely. The service great . Can't wait to come back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tillie's
Tillie's
(68)
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Good place as always, good food. Service was unfortunately really bad, I heard multiple tables complaining. Maybe they were a bit overwhelmed. Our server disappeared multiple times for a long duration of time, More

OpenTable Diner -
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk
(8)
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

They were closed for the season. They need to update their account & not allow ppl to make reservations in the off season. Ps you’re welcome for the 5 stars. More

OpenTable Diner -
La Fine - Montauk
La Fine - Montauk
(155)
$$$$
Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Wonderful service. Very attentive and friendly. Food and cocktails were delicious. We had the meatball appetizer, eggplant/rigatoni and chicken Marsala. More

OpenTable Diner -
Swallow East
Swallow East
(79)
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Food was good thought the Flank Steak was very expensive for what you got More

OpenTable Diner -

Montauk Diners' Choice Winners

Montauk's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Scarpetta Beach
Scarpetta Beach
(535)
$$$$
Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Can’t say enough how perfect it was. It was our engagement dinner and we chose the perfect spot for it. Food was outstanding and service amazing. We would be back for sure. Thank you so much to all of you. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
(6)
$$$$
Unspecified | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was tasty, especially smoked fish chowder. Our waiter, Eugene was very friendly and efficient. Prices are too high, in particular, can of beer is $9. Open Table lists this place as inexpensive with two dollars sign. Not really! More

OpenTable Diner -
Muse at the end
Muse at the end
(419)
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Anniversary dinner at Muse. Everything was absolutely delicious! The meal started with warm fresh little loaves of bread with port wine cheese spread, olive oil and butter. I got the $35 early dinner special that runs from 530-630pm. Included a salad which hubby ate and loved, and I got the blue cheese salad a la carte for $12. It was insane!!! Could only eat half, brought the other half home. Then hubs got the Gorgonzola steak that came with awesome potatoes $52 and my meal was the chickpea chicken-delicious!!!! We finished off sharing my dessert-a chocolate flourless cake served with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, and fresh berries. The atmosphere was romantic and we will definitely be back! Altogether with a Peroni for him $8 and Prosecco $14 and coffee for me $3, the bill was $133. So worth every penny. The service was outstanding, too. Highly recommend! More

OpenTable Diner -
Showfish
Showfish
(77)
$$$$
Seafood | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

This restaurant was highly recommended to us by a trustworthy lady! We have been coming to Montauk for years and we were very impressed with everything about Showfish - The food was interesting and not too overwhelming - The tables were lovely and private, there's a vibrant bar scene if you are looking for some fun - And the restaurant was far enough away from the bar to be very quite and lovely. The service great . Can't wait to come back. More

OpenTable Diner -
Backyard Restaurant @ Solé East
Backyard Restaurant @ Solé East
(179)
$$$$
Mediterranean | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Food and service were fantastic. Our server recommended local spots that made our weekend in town even better. More

OpenTable Diner -
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk
(8)
$$$$
American | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

They were closed for the season. They need to update their account & not allow ppl to make reservations in the off season. Ps you’re welcome for the 5 stars. More

OpenTable Diner -
Grey Lady - Montauk
Grey Lady - Montauk
(82)
$$$$
Seafood | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Beautiful space but the menu is too limited; lots of fried foods etc. Service was great and while food was good-not what I would expect and doesn’t match the room or service. More

OpenTable Diner -
La Fine - Montauk
La Fine - Montauk
(155)
$$$$
Italian | Montauk, Long Island / Hamptons

Wonderful service. Very attentive and friendly. Food and cocktails were delicious. We had the meatball appetizer, eggplant/rigatoni and chicken Marsala. More

OpenTable Diner -