Best American Restaurants in Mayville

View all

Best American Restaurants in Mayville

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Mayville

View all

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Mayville

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(820)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2720)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(393)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Mayville restaurants

Mayville Restaurants

Webb's Captain's Table
Webb's Captain's Table
(351)
$$$$
Steak | Mayville, Western New York

See all offers

Once we were seated, it took over 10 minutes for waitress to arrive at the table. We were in no hurry, so that was okay. My husband and I loved our drink orders, but our guest wasn't happy with her lemon drop drink. She ordered the 8 oz. prime rib special (medium well) and it arrived pink in the middle. My husband and I split a 12 oz. prime rib and it was to be medium rare. It was not medium rare, and was tough. The texture looked nothing like our guest's prime rib). The baked potatoes with toppings were nice. Chocolate bombe, as recommended by waitress was delicious. Very expensive for the quality of the prime rib. Would try other restaurants in the area next time. More

OpenTable Diner -
Heirloom Restaurant at the Athenaeum Hotel
Heirloom Restaurant at the Athenaeum Hotel
(28)
$$$$
American | Mayville, Western New York

We were celebrating our 32 wedding anniversary We had a reservation and arrived a few minutes early. Because we used open table, we were able to enter the gate without paying and receive a free 3 hour gate pass. We also received free valet service at the hotel / restaurant because we used the Open table app to make our reservation Service was good but food was awesome. I had the seared scallops with roasted carrots and real mashed potatoes. Hubby had filet perfectly cooked with the same sides as I had. He also had cup of lobster bisque soup which he said was very tasty. Wine and bubbly choices are awesome Dessert - Carrot cake and what I call a reconstructed strawberry shortcake were heavenly. Yummy!! We sat inside the dinning room near the windows and could see a very pleasant view of Chautauqua lake. We finished our evening on the porch sitting in rocking chairs, sipping our wine and enjoying the orchestra that was playing at the amphitheater on the grounds. It had a quaint atmosphere that we enjoyed very much. Can’t wait until we come back to the Heirloom Restaurant in August. We are coming to Chautauqua for a concert and will be eating hear again. We heard Saturday’s during the season they have a to die for seafood buffet so we are coming back for that as well More

OpenTable Diner -
The See Zurh House
The See Zurh House
(2)
$$$$
American | Mayville, Western New York

Built in 1888 as the Merritt Boarding House, the original "See-Zurh House" was started in 1960 by Don See and Zurh Faulkner. In 1984 Thom Shagla purchased the "See-Zurh House" and continues the tradition of the "See-Zurh House" being a place where you find good things to eat and good friends to meet! In 2004 Thom remodeled the second floor and opened "SHAGGY'S". "SHAGGY"S is a fantastic place for private parties and is a perfect compliment to The "See-Zurh House". Both are the #1 local Favorite for value and quality foods. More