New Mill Restaurant
New Mill Veal Meatballs
Fresh ground veal seasoned with garlic, ricotta and Parmigiano cheeses, served with fresh tomato sauce
Ground veal, prosciutto, caramelized onions, sage and parmesan cheese in a veal demi glace over black pepper fettuccine
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
With horseradish cocktail sauce and fresh lemon-Gluten Free
Food was immaculate as well as the service was outstanding. Never have had a bad meal here. Definetly will be returning soon
Excellent food and service! A happening, exciting ambiance, but not too loud to enjoy conversation. I couldn't have chosen a better restaurant to host a friend's surprise birthday dinner. We all left beyond satisfied.
Never disappointed. Excellent service and excellent food as well. Always feel welcomed when we go there
Very good! Parking was tough, as it was very busy but we had a reservation and were seated immediately. Everyone was nice and the food came out quickly and correctly. A little far of a drive for us, but would definitely eat there again or recommend it to a friend!
Overall it is a nice-looking place. I tried a few appetizers that looked delicious on paper, but didn’t taste as good to me in reality. And it was quite pricey for what I had.
The food is amazing the atmosphere is so enjoyable. The meatballs are a great starter and steak is a must
Love this restaurant. The food is fantastic from filet mignon to fish dinners. We have never been disappointed. Great bar too.
We had two issues that caused my rating to be just average. First, we ordered an appetizer, clams casino. When the waitress asked us how it was we indicating it was so, so. It was pretty dried out, usually clams casino comes with a little bit of broth. What was disconcerting is the waitress said nothing, which I took to mean she didn't care. The next issue is this night they were offering a prime Angus sirloin steak, which was a step up from their normal strip steak. While it was cooked the way I wanted it, the quality was not worth the price. This was on par with Ruth Chris price, no where close to the same quality.
My husband and I enjoy coming here nearly on a weekly basis! We usually get the steak special, and if we’re feeling like eating light, we opt for their flavorful chopped salad and or soup of the day! Never disappointed with their food, BUT, I repeat, BUT stay far away from their Waitress by the name of Karen. I believe she works there only because her husband works there as well, most likely as the chef. My husband and I had her one time and that was all it took for us to see she brings this place down tremendously. She was rude to us, wasn’t around, we had to keep asking employees for service. She just wasn’t friendly at all. We left her a mediocre tip (she’s lucky she even got one) for poor service, even though our bill wasn’t high, and on our way out she looked at us and said “Thanks for nothin.” We immediately turned around and made a complaint about her uncivilized persona. My husband and I dine out fairly often, and we’ve never experienced someone so full of hate.
Michele was our waitress - she was attentive but over bearing. Timing of the appetizers and meals seemed a little rushed as we ordered an above average amount of appetizers. Overall we enjoyed the experience. It met our expectations.
Our server Jen quickly realized that my husband and I were seated amongst two large parties. She offered to move our table and the noise level was much better. The presentation of the food and the taste were excellant. I would return again.
The food was delicious with generous portions. Its a very nice place with welcoming and efficient staff.
We celebrated our 51 st anniversary and we are repeat customers. My only complaint was the bread. Dinner rolls were served instead of home-made bread. I suggest you upgrade your bread selection to match the quality of the menu.
Good food, my Ribeye was a bit fatty but I was advised by the waiter (prior to ordering) that it comes that way for flavor. Portion was adequate. Overall a good experience.
We love New Mill, drinks are strong, food is delicious and consistent! Clams Casino and Spiedini on point. Amazing salads, steaks and Italian dishes. Service always good, atmosphere lovely
It was my 1st time there and I was so impressed. The staff was friendly and the food was excellent. I was eating my dinner within 20 mins of sitting on Valentine's Day weekend when the place was packed! I will definitely be returning!
Food and drinks were fantastic! Love the ambiance as well!
great evening enjoyed the dinner its a great placeto dine
We had a really nice meal and the service was great! I’ve never had a bad meal there!
I have reviewed this establishment in the past, overall I am very pleased with the service, food, and atmosphere. We sat in the bar area this past visit, it was still very comfortable. Food is great, would like to see some non fish items in the appetizers; my wife is please with the fish selections. Management is greatest he gentleman at the hostess post is always there and always efficient. Will always recommend, I actually posted this past visit on Facebook to share.
We have not been in awhile, tried a couple of times and because we did not have a reservation we did not get in. We got a reservation this time. Better than I remembered. We had a great time while driving home about experience. We will be making another reservation soon.
We've chosen this restaurant for an annual gathering of 8 friends. We've consistently enjoyed the entire experience and choose to come back for that reason. Excellent food no matter what the choice is. Thanks
What a find. Cozy, great food and fantastic service. I had the cod, the bolognese and stuffed chicken was enjoyed by the rest of our group
Everything was very good. They should get better rolls though.
Overall great night out with family celebrating Christmas late.
It was my very first time here and for sure not my last. I gave 5 star on everything. Food, service, ambiance, even the price was just right. Very clean and beautiful restaurant. I took my wife to dinner for her birthday and she loved it.!!
This was a wonderful meal filled with great service and great people
Fantastic food. You do pay for it but I don’t mind paying when it’s great!
Wonderful food & atmosphere. Got very noisy in back room. Service was great! Our favorite restaurant!
Everything was excellent as this was our second visit. Always enjoy our evening here!
My favorite go to for special occasions. It is so pretty when decorated for the holidays. The food and service is always top notch. The only downside is the noise level. It is an old building and just people talking can be loud, not to mention if there is a party going on.
Yes, but not for a holiday. Limited menu, food not as good as normal.
never a disappointment when we go there for a special occasion.
We made oud reservations online for New Years Eve and this place is phenomenal. The decor for the holiday is gorgeous and they had tye fireplace on which made it so romantic! The food was wonderful and the service was amazing. We have nothing but good things to say and can't wait to return!
Delicious food, generous portions! A wonderful way to spend NY Eve!
Honestly, I was expecting more, especially since the restaurant is always packed and this night was no exception. Pouring rain on a cold, Sunday night and barely a parking spot to be found.
Place is beautifully decorated, esp. so for the holidays. Quant rooms and lots of ambiance. Service was very slow - lots of large tables got prime attention.
Ordered eggplant rolanti for appetizer - sadly it was burnt and over cooked. Salads were wonderful - lots of fresh ingredients and many choices.
Ordered cavatelli with lump crabmeat - very tasty and huge portion. Too much in my opinion. Very pricey menu. Most entrees range from $28 up.
Overall, pleasant, but pricey and food decent.
Our meals at the New Mill are always delicious. We especially love the veal meatballs. One of my favorites. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and put it down as a favorite.
Good food, good atmosphere. It is a great place to get together with friends and enjoy a meal.
New Mill Restaurant offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (860) 620-0300.
New Mill Restaurant is rated 4.7 stars by 1075 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.