Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

View all

Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Best Seafood Restaurants in Bay Shore

View all

Best Seafood Restaurants in Bay Shore

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(819)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2711)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(392)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Bay Shore restaurants

  • Restaurant List
  • Best restaurants

Bay Shore Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Bay Shore restaurants

Bay Shore Restaurants

The Lakehouse
The Lakehouse
(1271)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

I’ve been wanting to go here for a while, it definitely didn’t disappoint. Everything was great from our initial greeting to our exit. The service and food were both excellent. We were even lucky enough for the waitstaff to bring a surprise appetizer that the chef had given to some diners and it was delicious. More

OpenTable Diner -
Salt and Barrel
Salt and Barrel
(747)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The best lobster roll on Long Island! Warm, buttery, toasty.....yummmmmmm More

OpenTable Diner -
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
(494)
$$$$
Mexican | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Excellent food and drink at Verde! Always great nice place to relax and enjoy. More

OpenTable Diner -
Corks and Taps of New York inc.
Corks and Taps of New York inc.
(38)
$$$$
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The food was delicious! I recommend the watermelon martini and the watermelon salad! Our server was excellent! It got too loud for dinner conversation when the band started playing so if you’re looking for a quiet place, this isn’t the place! More

OpenTable Diner -
Bella Vie
Bella Vie
(147)
$$$$
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We have enjoyed dining at Bella Vie several times in the past few months. The quality of the food is outstanding, and the chef made special accomodations for one of our guests. The service was acceptable, though a bit disjointed since we had three people attending to us throughout the meal. Overall we had a wonderful experience! More

OpenTable Diner -
Captain Bill's
Captain Bill's
(877)
$$$$
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was excellent except for noise level More

OpenTable Diner -
Whalers
Whalers
(177)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Three of us went to Whalers for brunch. We were all very pleased with the menu and it was difficult to narrow down our choice for appetizer and meals. My friends raved about the lobster bisque which had big pieces of lobster. I had the wedge salad which was refreshing on a warm afternoon. I enjoyed the breakfast tacos, especially the guacamole which had a bright citrus flavor. The lobster roll was not overdressed and also contained big chunks of meat. My friend who loves shrimp and grits was happy with her main course. Two of us split a piece of key lime pie which was as tarts as a good key lime pie is supposed to be. Our server was terrific. She let us catch up with each other and didn't push us to order. (We tipped her well.) Before we left, I made a reservation to go back with my niece in a few weeks. Whalers is a place I'll be going back to many times. More

OpenTable Diner -
Peninsula Asian Fusion
Peninsula Asian Fusion
(3)
$$$$
Asian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Food was fresh, good size portions, great drink specials and friendly staff! More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - Bayshore
TGI FRIDAYS - Bayshore
(7)
$$$$
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Had such a great time. Went on a Sunday and took advantage of their new happy hour specials. Boneless wings of all flavors were delicious as we're the sliders. Our server Diamond was the best. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tula Kitchen
Tula Kitchen
(2)
$$$$
Fusion / Eclectic | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Delicious food with a fun ambience! Still has a small restaurant feel even with their expansion and growth. Always a go to spot on the south shore. Love the vegan options! More

OpenTable Diner -
fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro
fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro
(2)
$$$$
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Great view, professional staff and tasty food... we return here a few times during the summer More

OpenTable Diner -
Fratelli Pizzeria & Restaurant
Fratelli Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Number 1 Chinese Kitchen
Number 1 Chinese Kitchen
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Chowder Bar Inc the
Chowder Bar Inc the
Reviews coming soon
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The Chowder Bar Inc. is a restaurant found in Bay Shore, New York. Open since 1946, this restaurant began staying open year around in 1988 with the exception of the month of February. This allows The Chowder Bar Inc. the chance to provide its customers with fresh food, friendly service and renowned soups.

Although the restaurant is known for the delicious seafood selections, the restaurant also offers burgers and chicken selections so everyone can find something the patron will enjoy eating. The Chowder Bar Inc. also offers a selection of salads, wines and beer to tempt everyone. Once you have tried the restaurant’s food, you’ll want to come back again and again.

More

Golden Chicken Peruvian Cuisine
Golden Chicken Peruvian Cuisine
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Golden Chicken is a Peruvian restaruant with a comfortable and casual feel. The dining room itself isn't exceptionally large, which lends itself to an intimate and cozy atmosphere for guests. The walls are decorated with authentic Peruvian decor, which adds to the ambiance as well. Golden Chicken also has a small outdoor patio out front, so diners can enjoy their meal outside when the weather is nice.

Golden Chicken's menu features some of the classic Peruvian dishes. Peruvian cuisine isn't overly common in the United States, so for many guests this is their first introduction to some of the delicious dishes that are unique to the region. There are several fantastic Peruvian entrées available, like the lomo saltado which is Peruvian-style beef or chicken seasoned with grilled onions and tomatoes. Some signature dishes only show up on the weekends, like the tamales, patasca and the chicharon con camote.

More

Las Brasas
Las Brasas
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Salvatore's Pizzeria
Salvatore's Pizzeria
Reviews coming soon
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Local Burger Co
Local Burger Co
Reviews coming soon
Burgers | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Aji 53
Aji 53
Reviews coming soon
Sushi | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Aji 53 serves up fresh sushi and sashimi. Dubbed as a fusion of Japanese cuisine, diners at this special spot will find a wide array of fresh fish prepared daily by the sushi chef. At Aji 53, the sashimi and the California rolls are especially popular, but there is much more to choose from as well.

If you are looking for something a bit different than sushi, you can always order up some ramen at Aji 53. This traditional Japanese dish has quickly become a hit and is quite tasty. Lunch specials include the lunch boxes and sushi sashimi lunch selections.

More

Tj Finleys
Tj Finleys
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Southside Hotel
Southside Hotel
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Southside Hotel is a casual restaurant and bar that serves American and Asian-inspired dishes. It�s most popular for its range of homemade burgers. The restaurant�s interior is clean and outfitted in wood, invoking a rustic charm. Southside Hotel is also popular for providing friendly and efficient service, which it believes is an important part of the dining experience.

Begin the meal with an appetizer like BBQ, Asian teriyaki or buffalo chicken wings, crispy Thai calamari with peanuts, cilantro, lime and sweet chili gaze or macaroni and cheese bites served with a smoked bacon ranch dipping sauce. Entr�e options at Southside Hotel include the house special Melton burger with mozzarella, mushrooms and gravy and chicken Florentine topped with fresh spinach and mozzarella. End the meal with a sweet dessert like apple crisp with vanilla ice cream or wild berry cheesecake.

More

Milk & Sugar Café
Milk & Sugar Café
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Milk & Sugar CafŽ in Bay Shore, NY offers full-service catering and a private dining space for special events and occasions. If you need a caterer for an off-premises event, you can opt for a number of meal selections. Popular choices include the continental breakfast, hot deluxe breakfast, cheese boards, quesadillas, mini-sliders and other handheld foods appropriate for buffets, self-service events and full-service events.

Other delicious options from Milk & Sugar CafŽ include the crab cake platter, blooming pistachio chicken skewers, coconut shrimp platter, cold cuts platter and others. Sushi and sashimi selections are available from Milk & Sugar CafŽ, as well.

More

Mitsui
Mitsui
Reviews coming soon
Japanese | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

A new addition to Bay Shore’s downtown is Mitsui Japanese Restaurant. Owner Eric Yeh has restaurants in his blood and is the third generation of his family to be in the business. With lunch and dinner menus, catering and delivery, Mitsui has everything you’ve come to enjoy and seek out in a Japanese restaurant.

With more than sushi, Mitsui serves a selection of cooked appetizers and entrées. Patrons will experience the freshest seafood sourced from one of the biggest fish markets in the Bronx. So whether you’re in the mood for some of that fresh fish presented in the nigiri deluxe, a platter of delicious sashimi, or you want something hot, like pan-fried gyoza a suki yaki hot pot, you’ve come to the right place.

More

Restaurant Galanga
Restaurant Galanga
Reviews coming soon
Thai | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Welcome to Restaurant Galanga, serving Thai cuisine made with the freshest ingredients and an expansive array of flavors. Enjoy a warm ambiance and relaxed atmosphere with family and make your next date night fun and unique with enticing and delectable entrées at Galanga Thai cuisine.

Begin your meal with the po pia spring rolls made with bamboo shoots and cabbage or the deep fried breaded calamari and steamed fried vegetable dumplings. Savor the pad thai with baby shrimp and egg or the drunken noodles with basil and green pepper. Popular entrées include the spicy basil chicken and mango duck with red onions in sweet and sour sauce. Seafood lovers will enjoy the salmon coated in Thai herbs serviced sizzling hot with ginger-brown bean sauce. Enjoy tasty flavors, fresh ingredients and one-of-a-kind flavor combination at Galanga Thai Cuisine.

More

Tullulah's
Tullulah's
(182)
$$$$
Tapas / Small Plates | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Excellent quality food, was a very fun place with interesting decor. More

OpenTable Diner -
Aji Fifty Three Japanese Cuisine
Aji Fifty Three Japanese Cuisine
Reviews coming soon
Japanese | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

The Cheesecake Factory - Bay Shore
The Cheesecake Factory - Bay Shore
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

For an elegantly casual experience in a restaurant that offers a large menu of fare, visit The Cheesecake Factory in Bay Shore, New York for tastes that will satisfy any craving. The menu offers diverse flavors found all over the world, offering something for everyone to enjoy. For lunch and dinner at The Cheesecake Factory, try the cheese pizza, Cobb salad, grilled salmon, grilled cheeseburger, shepherd's pie, fish tacos and more to be enjoyed.

End your meal with a decadent dessert at The Cheesecake Factory. Aside from the famous cheesecakes, there are also homemade items such as strawberry shortcake, tiramisu, carrot cake and a warm apple crisp for a sweet finish.

More

Hong Hing Chinese Restaurant
Hong Hing Chinese Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Zaffran Restaurant
Zaffran Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Siam Lotus Thai Restaurant
Siam Lotus Thai Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Thai | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Brunos Pizza & Pasta Restaurant
Brunos Pizza & Pasta Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Aria Melanie on the Lake
Aria Melanie on the Lake
(293)
$$$$
Mediterranean | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We went to this restaurant for my husband’s birthday. As soon as we stepped into the door we were cordially received by the host and taken to our lake view table. The staff explained the specials and gave us a wine list offering a special wine at a great price. The food was fresh and very delicious and the service was very attentive to our needs. The restaurant was meticulous and tastesfully decorated inside and out. In addition, we were very pleased with our culinary choices and the very attentive treatment we received. We loved everything about the restaurant and are eagerly awaiting our next visit there. Thank you for an exceptional evening. More

OpenTable Diner -
New Forum Diner Restaurant
New Forum Diner Restaurant
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Joes Pizza
Joes Pizza
Reviews coming soon
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

New Toddler House Limited
New Toddler House Limited
Reviews coming soon
Grill | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Spring Chinese Kitchen
Spring Chinese Kitchen
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Sea Levels
Sea Levels
Reviews coming soon
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

Food King Chinese Kitchen
Food King Chinese Kitchen
Reviews coming soon
Chinese | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Coming Soon!More

The Jon Thomas Inne
The Jon Thomas Inne
Reviews coming soon
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Relax and enjoy fulfilling comfort food at the Jon Thomas Inne. It's situated in a historic building that's been around since 1925 and was called the Old Heidelberg. This restaurant offers lunch and dinner services throughout the week. Guests can chow down on an appetizer of corned beef Reuben egg rolls, potato skins topped with cheddar and bacon or buffalo calamari at the Jon Thomas Inne. An entr�e of pork chops with applesauce, skirt steak with parmesan fries or chicken bratwurst with roasted red peppers and curry sauce make for tasty choices. Burgers, salads and sandwiches can also be found on the menu.

The Jon Thomas Inne features a happy hour and meal specials throughout the week. It has private rooms for hosting parties and other private events.

More

Bay Shore Diners' Choice Winners

Bay Shore's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
The Lakehouse
The Lakehouse
(1271)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

I’ve been wanting to go here for a while, it definitely didn’t disappoint. Everything was great from our initial greeting to our exit. The service and food were both excellent. We were even lucky enough for the waitstaff to bring a surprise appetizer that the chef had given to some diners and it was delicious. More

OpenTable Diner -
Salt and Barrel
Salt and Barrel
(747)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The best lobster roll on Long Island! Warm, buttery, toasty.....yummmmmmm More

OpenTable Diner -
Corks and Taps of New York inc.
Corks and Taps of New York inc.
(38)
$$$$
American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

The food was delicious! I recommend the watermelon martini and the watermelon salad! Our server was excellent! It got too loud for dinner conversation when the band started playing so if you’re looking for a quiet place, this isn’t the place! More

OpenTable Diner -
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
(494)
$$$$
Mexican | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Excellent food and drink at Verde! Always great nice place to relax and enjoy. More

OpenTable Diner -
Bella Vie
Bella Vie
(147)
$$$$
Italian | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

We have enjoyed dining at Bella Vie several times in the past few months. The quality of the food is outstanding, and the chef made special accomodations for one of our guests. The service was acceptable, though a bit disjointed since we had three people attending to us throughout the meal. Overall we had a wonderful experience! More

OpenTable Diner -
Captain Bill's
Captain Bill's
(877)
$$$$
Seafood | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was excellent except for noise level More

OpenTable Diner -
Whalers
Whalers
(177)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Bay Shore, Long Island / Hamptons

Three of us went to Whalers for brunch. We were all very pleased with the menu and it was difficult to narrow down our choice for appetizer and meals. My friends raved about the lobster bisque which had big pieces of lobster. I had the wedge salad which was refreshing on a warm afternoon. I enjoyed the breakfast tacos, especially the guacamole which had a bright citrus flavor. The lobster roll was not overdressed and also contained big chunks of meat. My friend who loves shrimp and grits was happy with her main course. Two of us split a piece of key lime pie which was as tarts as a good key lime pie is supposed to be. Our server was terrific. She let us catch up with each other and didn't push us to order. (We tipped her well.) Before we left, I made a reservation to go back with my niece in a few weeks. Whalers is a place I'll be going back to many times. More

OpenTable Diner -