This includes info about cleaning, sanitising, social distancing, and usage of personal protective equipment. Learn More.
MoonShine - Modern Supper Club
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Clean menu provided to every guest
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
Fresh pea, mint, goat cheese
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
red cabbage jus, romanesco, baby carrot, shaved beets
Amazing! Food delicious. Tables set very far apart under the tent so super comfortable being out to dinner for first time. Service was exceptional. Such a positive experience.
The Menu it’s delicious
Moonshine followed social distance guidelines and all other guidelines for reopening. This was our first time visiting a restaurant since covid and we are so glad we went with moonshine. We felt comfortable and the food was just as amazing as we remember.
The first night Moonshine was open since the lockdown. It was very comfortable dining al fresco and the service was excellent. The food was also well prepared as always and the whole experience was very pleasant. The servers wore face masks and gloves and the menus were scanned by our phones and we read them on our phones. Excellent meal!
The staff could not have been any friendlier or responsive. Food was delicious and portions were large. We could not finish our dinners and walked away feeling stuffed. Cocktails were delicious. Cannot wait to go back.
It was great to back for dinner at Moonshine. My husband and I did the 3-course Prix Fixe Dinner. As always the service, food, and drinks were great!
Wonderful service , varied and interesting menu, appealing surroundings - can't improve upon perfection .
The service was great and they were so nice. They had the best food in town. I can’t wait to go back soon for more delicious food and drinks.
MoonShine was OK. I would go back, but I find myself not rushing to do so. Good alternative for a night out.
We had dinner. The food was very good. My husband had the prefix menu. I ate off the regular menu. The service was wonderful. We will come back.
Good Music, nice atmosphere
Wine selection was outstanding....some wonderful surprises that were major bargains....food was wonderful...the hanger steak perfectly cooked....the Amish chicken a bit dry but flavorful. Bread pudding dessert out of this world. And prix fixe to boot. Great place ...love it
Waitress was nice but told us food was prepared differently. So spicy almost inedible
We are sorry to learn you were not pleased with your last visit. If you have time to stop by in person or call us we'd love the opportunity to hear more from you and address all your concerns. John
Food and service was excellent - within walking distance of Papermill Playhouse.
Delicious food, pleasant and knowledgeable service. Very attentive to the gluten free person in our party.
2nd floor noise level was minimal, the fact that a table conversation was easy to carry on was important for catching up with old friends.
The spot was dope....nice and quite upstairs.....very couple appropriate...food was good and prices was fair. The truth serum drink is strong AF so be aware...its not much but that's on purpose. But great time and great service. Will revisit.
Sat near the kitchen and loved watching the activity. Meal was slightly rushed for our taste, but food was delicious.
We had an issue with an oyster.... it wasn’t a good oyster and it made my fiancé very ill for the next 24 hours. As soon as he tried it, he did spit it back out but had swallowed some of the water.
Other than that mishap, everything else was spectacular.
Went on Valentine's Day and maybe best not judge on a holiday. Was very pleased with the curry soup.
i look forward to going back. Management clearly cares about their guests and you don't see that so often anymore. Nicely designed restaurant with a lot of potential. Will review again.
Hi Mark, we are sorry to learn you were not pleased with your last visit. If you have time to stop by in person or call us we'd love the opportunity to hear more from you and address all your concerns. Truly, John
Had a date night on Valentine’s Day. Their prix fixe menu offerings were good but the food lacked any quality. Was not worth the $60 pp. Their servers also had no idea what table ordered what and we were almost served food/ drinks that were not ours more than once.
Hi Lanny, we are sorry to learn you were not pleased with your last visit. If you have time to stop by in person or call us we'd love the opportunity to hear more from you and address all your concerns. Truly, John
Bartender Sam is talented and very nice. Our server Alisse (sp?) is attentive and extraordinarily skilled in appropriate etiquette and manners. Our bronzino and risotto dinners were outstanding. Moonshine is where I go when going to Paper Mill. I live in the Manasquan Shore/River area and never miss a Moonshine chance. Thank you!
Food was flavorless and the dessert (carrot cake) was inedible due to bad flavor.
Bathrooms were FILTHY
Staff was pleasant and dealt with our bad food kindly.
Hi, we are sorry to learn you were not pleased with your last visit. If you have time to stop by in person or call us we'd love the opportunity to hear more from you and address all your concerns. - John
MoonShine never disappoints! Such a fun place with amazing food and drinks. Elyse was our server and she’s fantastic! Highly recommend to anyone who’s never been here before!!
Excellent food and service. $25 brunch for appetizer, entree, cocktail or beverage of your choice. $3 for each additional cocktail. Will definitely be back!
Great experience, will definitely return. It got very crowded and noisy when it transitioned from dinner to club though. Maybe dinner should stop at a certain time.
Absolutely thrilled with this establishment. Passed by it for years, and so glad we finally had dinner. We were seated on the 2nd floor, overlooking the balcony. Our server for the evening was very well-versed with the menu, and is the resident mixologist. Her suggestions from wine, to cocktails, to the cheese plater were spot on! Can't wait to go back.
Carlos manages to keep a smile throughout the entire evening dealing with a group of 12 ladies!! Kudos to his positive attitude we had a great time at Moonshine tonight.
The service was just par excellence!
had such a good time, our waitress was really nice, the food was great, will definitely come back again!!!
Been to this place 1000 times and never had a problem before. Makes me feel bad to write a review that’s negative since I would like to give them a pass and just say that bad experience was a One time thing. For the first time ever, the food wasn’t good not just for me but for the three other people in my party. I have to say I can’t believe that it wasn’t at least in part because there was a large party upstairs and it feels like they were given preference with regard to service as well as food and the few people in the first floor dining room suffered because of it.
Maria, We are sorry to learn you were not pleased with your last visit. If you have time to stop by in person or call us we'd love the opportunity to hear more from you and address all your concerns. John.
Service was great - our waiter was very friendly and gave guidance on selections- everything came on time
The Gnocchi and Octopus first courses were very good
The Salmon and Lentils entrée was also very good
The Risotto Entrée was okay - cooked well just not my thing in terms of flavors
The Rum Bread Pudding was amazing - definitely to share although you may not want to!
Would definitely go back
Monshine - Modern Supper Club never disappoints. We had a lovely NYE dinner and thoroughly enjoyed the service and the atmosphere.
We had a lovely evening celebrating New Years Eve and my daughters birthday. The food was great. Service was decent for the holiday. It would have been nice not to have been charged for her birthday dessert or the kids meal since it was a Tuesday and children eat free.
Overall, nice place to have dinner.
Like that they have a parking lot food and wine was very good we had appetisers and I had the Tuna Sashimi bowl very good
We went for brunch with Santa. Food was delicious and timely. The staff were all super friendly. Saying hi to my 2 year old daughter as they walked by. Would definitely go here again!
We went for brunch with Santa and it was very cute! Santa read a story to the kids and then took pictures, he and Mrs clause were very personable and funny. They had an affordable brunch menu and as usual the food was fantastic! I will definitely be back next year for brunch with Santa.
Not my first time there and have had better experiences. This time the food wasn't great.
The three of us remarked on the first bite of our entrees how good they were. One beef,one shellfish and one vegetable risotto.
We were disappointed on our last experience at MoonShine. The room was very dark - we had to use flashlights to read the menu. Specials were read to us without prices. I asked for the whole bronzino to be filleted, but I had trouble eating it with all the bones that remained. Not sure if we’ll go back.
Went in for brunch, terrible food, the place was dirty and service was mediocre. Really embarrassing since we had family visiting from out of town with us. Won’t go back or recommend.
Wonderful dinner and atmosphere for a double family birthday party
MoonShine - Modern Supper Club offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 218-6042.
MoonShine - Modern Supper Club is rated 4.3 stars by 850 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.