52 restaurantsPage 1 of 2


Backyard Restaurant @ Solé East
1. Backyard Restaurant @ Solé East
4.1
179 reviews
$$$$
Mediterranean | MontaukFood and service were fantastic. Our server recommended local spots that made our weekend in town even better.
Scarpetta Beach
2. Scarpetta Beach
4.5
544 reviews
$$$$
Italian | MontaukBooked 3 times todayHaving spent a couple of nights at Guerney's Inn & Spa in the dead of winter, it was convenient to have Scarpetta Beach on the premises. The gentleman I was with found the lighting to be so low that it made it difficult for him to read the menu. On our first evening I ordered the spaghetti which...
La Fine - Montauk
3. La Fine - Montauk
4.0
156 reviews
$$$$
Italian | MontaukExcellent food and service! Dmitri was a perfect server!
Muse at the end
4. Muse at the end
4.4
424 reviews
$$$$
American | MontaukBooked 2 times todayFood was wonderful and unique, but I was freezing! We sat not far from the door and every time the door opened I needed to wear my coat and it wasn’t even a freezing night. That needs to be addressed.
The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
5. The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
4.5
6 reviews
$$$$
Unspecified | MontaukEverything was tasty, especially smoked fish chowder. Our waiter, Eugene was very friendly and efficient. Prices are too high, in particular, can of beer is $9. Open Table lists this place as inexpensive with two dollars sign. Not really!
Dopo La Spiaggia - East Hampton
6. Dopo La Spiaggia - East Hampton
4.5
363 reviews
$$$$
Italian | East HamptonEverything was delicious,... as usual!. From their delicately light, but super flavorful poached sea bass with tomatoes, spinach & white wine to their heartier rigatoni w/homemade sausage, peas and vodka sauce- there’s a dish to please any palate! The service is great from top to bottom and the...
1770 House
7. 1770 House
4.8
1019 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | East HamptonBooked 18 times todayMid-winter overnight stay was spectacular! Inn and restaurant were outstanding and the staff couldn't have been more charming.
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
8. Lulu Kitchen & Bar
4.6
328 reviews
$$$$
Bistro | Sag HarborBooked 5 times todayHad another great dinner at our favorite East End restaurant. This is the most comfortable place in town to have a cozy dinner with the family and enjoy great food and friendly service in a warm atmosphere. The oysters were the freshest I've had in a long time and the poached codfish with the...
The Palm East Hampton
9. The Palm East Hampton
4.5
562 reviews
$$$$
Steakhouse | East HamptonBooked 10 times todayAlways a guaranteed great meal
Tillie's
10. Tillie's
4.5
70 reviews
$$$$
American | MontaukTillie’s was excellent. I was in Montauk for a mother & daughter day . Tillie’s was our lunch stop. I had the chicken sandwich but I opted for the chicken to be grilled, the chef did an awesome job. Service was excellent. The restaurant was empty but that is expected in Montauk off season.
Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House
11. Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House
4.4
666 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | BridgehamptonThe food ambience and service are consistently excellent.
Serafina East Hampton
12. Serafina East Hampton
4.3
303 reviews
$$$$
Italian | East HamptonThe service, food, and ambiance of Serafina East Hampton was perfect. We are Serafina fans and whether in Puerto Rico or NYC, when you dine at a Serafina Restaurant you feel like you are in Italy. Highly recommended.
Highway Restaurant and Bar
13. Highway Restaurant and Bar
4.7
485 reviews
$$$$
American | East HamptonBooked 20 times todayWe were surprised how busy it was on an off-season night, but had great service, a delightful meal, and a good bottle of red. We recommend that others try this very plain-looking outside, with a warm and hearty inside.
Page at 63 Main
14. Page at 63 Main
4.8
846 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Sag HarborBooked 12 times todayThere are not too many places in the Hamptons where you can enjoy a delicious meal at a reasonable price while dining in pleasant surroundings with an attentive staff and be able to converse with your table mates without having to shout. Page at 63 Main is certainly at the top of this list.
Calissa
15. Calissa
4.6
159 reviews
$$$$
Greek | SouthamptonBooked 3 times todayThis was our first visit. We arrived and were wonderfully greeted. The hostess was expecting us and even knew my name without me informing her. The restaurant is chic..super clean lines and wonderfully decorated. The staff was fast and eager to share with us the wonderful menu options for the...
Tutto Il Giorno - Sag Harbor
16. Tutto Il Giorno - Sag Harbor
4.7
106 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Sag HarborBooked 9 times todayExcellent food.
Cove Hollow Tavern
17. Cove Hollow Tavern
4.6
150 reviews
$$$$
American | East HamptonThe kitchen actually had a mix up with our order - and the wait staff and waiter handled it so well that we will definitely go back. The potato crusted sea bass and the burger were excellent! Enjoy!
The Clubhouse
18. The Clubhouse
4.6
19 reviews
$$$$
American | East HamptonBooked 2 times todayThis place is perfect for kids and adults. Everyone left happy!
Almond - Bridgehampton
19. Almond - Bridgehampton
4.6
1010 reviews
$$$$
American | BridgehamptonBooked 6 times todayDidn’t care for the wine list.not having pino Grigio or any Dry French whites but food was good!
75 Main
20. 75 Main
3.9
549 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | SouthamptonGreat food and cocktails! Reasonably priced for the Hamptons.
Baron's Cove
21. Baron's Cove
4.4
418 reviews
$$$$
American | Sag HarborGreat food and drinks during Brunch, cozy room and friendly staff!
The Garden at Water Mill
22. The Garden at Water Mill
3.7
22 reviews
$$$$
American | SouthamptonGreat drinks and food. We sat inside as most of the tables outside are picnic tables and benches. Service was attentive and all six of us enjoyed the experience.
The Bell & Anchor
23. The Bell & Anchor
4.8
508 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | Sag HarborChild's birthday
The Maidstone
24. The Maidstone
4.3
843 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | East HamptonBooked 9 times todayThe food was excellent. Our server was Sara and she was great!
Tutto Il Giorno - Southampton
25. Tutto Il Giorno - Southampton
4.8
236 reviews
$$$$
Italian | HamptonsBooked 10 times todayExcellent service and food. Nice bar as well.
Swallow East
26. Swallow East
4.3
79 reviews
$$$$
American | MontaukFood was good thought the Flank Steak was very expensive for what you got
Dopo la Spiaggia - Sag Harbor
27. Dopo la Spiaggia - Sag Harbor
4.6
57 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Sag HarborAlthough the reservation got goofed up and
M.J. Dowling's
28. M.J. Dowling's
4.7
57 reviews
$$$$
American | Sag HarborToo much food. Took home enough of our meal to have another dinner the next day,
Fresno
29. Fresno
4.5
640 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | East HamptonExcellent food and very friendly staff.
Sant Ambroeus - Southampton
30. Sant Ambroeus - Southampton
4.7
136 reviews
$$$$
Italian | SouthamptonBooked 6 times todayLove this restaurant. We had such a lovely dinner. The food is delicious and the service is so friendly. Can’t wait to go back
Claude's
31. Claude's
3.9
60 reviews
$$$$
American | SouthamptonBooked 2 times todayBirthday Brunch. Great food and pricing. Great value. Staff super duper and friendly.
The Inn Spot on The Bay
32. The Inn Spot on The Bay
3.4
265 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | HamptonsAs always, The Inn Spot never fails. It was the beginning of their international festival which they do in the winter months. They opened with a French menu: delicious,hearty onion soup, followed by beef bourgoninn and then a divine baba au rhum and panda cotta with a hard,burnt sugar...
The Plaza
33. The Plaza
4.9
390 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | SouthamptonBooked 8 times todayWe had not heard of the Plaza Cafe but it was one of the options offered by the Southhampton Cultural Center with their theatre ticket/dinner option. We considered the three restaurants participating, and ended up choosing the Plaza Cafe, we were not disappointed, in fact it far exceeded what we...
Vine Street Cafe
34. Vine Street Cafe
4.7
1015 reviews
$$$$
American | Shelter IslandBooked 4 times todayAs always super solid. Great service and excellent food.
The Coast Grill
35. The Coast Grill
4.6
128 reviews
$$$$
American | SouthamptonAlways, the best food and drinks ! Great service !
Bistro Ete
36. Bistro Ete
4.7
266 reviews
$$$$
French | SouthamptonAlways a delightful and welcoming atmosphere. Personal attention given by the staff and proprietor. My guest was a first timer.Loved it and looks forward to returning. As I always do. Pam Levy
Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant
37. Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant
4.7
178 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | BridgehamptonWe had an early NYE dinner with another couple. It was just the kind of celebration we were looking for, a quiet, elegant evening with great food. Everything was perfect!!!
Stone Creek Inn
38. Stone Creek Inn
4.8
1798 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | East QuogueBooked 27 times todayA fantastic meal. Everything we ordered was beyond expectations.
Gemelli's Restaurant
39. Gemelli's Restaurant
4.6
517 reviews
$$$$
Italian | BabylonBooked 6 times todaywent for New Year Eve dinner with friends as we were thrilled they had a regular menu and not a special holiday menu, food tasted as good as always and service is sometimes better but they were packed out
The Melting Pot - Farmingdale
40. The Melting Pot - Farmingdale
4.6
3016 reviews
$$$$
Fondue | FarmingdaleBooked 37 times todayGreat food and so much fun.
North Sea Tavern
41. North Sea Tavern
3.6
17 reviews
$$$$
American | SouthamptonA very simple neighborhood restaurant. The burgers are very good as was the service.
Le Charlot - Southampton
42. Le Charlot - Southampton
4.4
162 reviews
$$$$
French | SouthamptonBooked 2 times todayWe waited over two hours for dinner, we think they forgot about us!
Il Mulino New York - Long Island
43. Il Mulino New York - Long Island
4.4
957 reviews
$$$$
Italian | RoslynBooked 19 times todayIn just a few words. You are treated as royalty and the food is amazing.
The Halyard
44. The Halyard
4.4
461 reviews
$$$$
American | GreenportBooked 4 times todayTop quality meal. Great service and spectacular view
George Martin's Strip Steak
45. George Martin's Strip Steak
4.8
2323 reviews
$$$$
Steakhouse | East IslipBooked 45 times todayGreat enjoyed a wonderful birthday
Cafe Testarossa
46. Cafe Testarossa
4.7
672 reviews
$$$$
Italian | SyossetBooked 16 times todayWe were celebrating a friend’s birthday. Everything was perfect! The food was excellent, the service was excellent the ambiance was excellent.
Dodici Restaurant
47. Dodici Restaurant
4.4
482 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Rockville CentreBooked 7 times todayFood is always good but the service was lacking a bit, as it appeared it was very busy and our food order was not correct, but the staff made up for it and we were happy.
Parlay Gastropub
48. Parlay Gastropub
4.6
494 reviews
$$$$
Gastro Pub | Rockville CentreBooked 8 times todayLove going to Parlay; it’s our go to spot for Sunday Brunch when we don’t have a new place to try. The food there is delicious and the staff is great!
Besito Mexican - West Islip
49. Besito Mexican - West Islip
4.7
927 reviews
$$$$
Mexican | West IslipBooked 38 times todayThe food was amazing. Jennifer’s service was incredible. Made sure I told the manager how good and tentative she was.
The Patio at 54 Main
50. The Patio at 54 Main
4.8
573 reviews
$$$$
American | HamptonsBooked 3 times todayWe love the relaxed feel of this place and we have definitely returned. The salmon was cooked perfectly, the special rib eye and filet mignon steaks were amazing, tender and juicy. The mashed potatoes were creamy and delicious. Service was friendly and attentive. They even brought my son a...
Sandbar
51. Sandbar
4.6
927 reviews
$$$$
American | Cold Spring HarborBooked 22 times todayExpert cocktail concoction by exceptional bartenders.
Il Luogo Ristorante
52. Il Luogo Ristorante
4.7
893 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Rockville CentreBooked 2 times todayEnjoyed my fist visit , great service , and delicious dinner .