Il Michelangelo Restaurant
We pride ourselves for being considered by our own customers as one the best Italian Restaurants in Morrris County NJ. The Menu selection is influenced by our Sicilian heritage and blending culinary flavors from many regions of Italy. Enjoy a true home cooking style experience that will have you wondering if your Italian Grandma is cooking in the kitchen !!!!!
Come and experience that our Motto "Eat Well-Live Well" "Mangia Bene- Vivi Bene" Holds True
Il Michelangelo Restaurant surely belongs in your Dining Agenda where the food and service are designed to "Make your Day!!!"
Sat on the porch. With COViD around we felt comfortable and safe there. The waiter was very nice and responded to our wishes right away. I always get the shrimp scampi appetizer and I am always happy that I did. I had fish. Terrific. My husband orders a simple pasta and thinks the sauce is terrific. Our guests enjoyed the food and the time there as well.
Everyone felt the meal was a bit overpriced. But during these times we want to support restaurants as we hope people will support our businesses.
Always wonderful. Great food cocktails and ambiance. Thank you again for a wonderful night
Exceptional Service. Always feel welcome, like family. Food is excellent and authentic. Need an experienced bartender.
Nice to sit down for a great dinner indoors with our friends at Michelangelo. Should have happened a long time ago. Too bad NJ is so poorly run.
Every dish was delicious and staff was very accommodating.
We have been here many times and never disappointed.
Wonderful as always!
Porch dining ;)
Bathroom very clean.
Try the organic wine
We just loved it! The service was outstanding- our waiter, Aldo was a doll. Food was delicious from beginning to end. Outdoor seating on the front porch was comfortable and lovely
The very best dinner
Very nice to see my friends again. Let these businesses open!
Il Michelangelo is excellent! Always a great meal w good service. The Cascio family (Owners, chef, host and hostess, waiters) are a great family - very hospitable as hosts and excellent chefs de Italian cuisine
Amazing, delicious food! Highly recommend the stuffed artichoke ! Owner is very friendly and hospitable. Will definitely go back in the near future. Beautiful place inside and out!
great food. friendly and efficient staff. relaxed experience.
Great ambiance and food. Very quaint and homey. Will definitely be back!
Why this was our first time was beyond us!!! We stepped inside and were warmly welcomed and seated to our table. Service on spot and food was just excellent. Stuffed artichoke the best we ever had. Service (forgive me for not getting his name) was great. A new favorite if our.
Food is always extraordinary and the service amazing
The food was of excellent quality and the staff was very professional. The setting was clean neat and what you would expect for a special night out.
Very romantic experience...
Great service very nice people.
Great food and a great staff. Very fairly priced wine!
Food was authentic and amazing! Staff is friendly and courteous. Will definitely return!
Always a treat at Il Micheangelo. Fine dining in a classic atmosphere.
We hd a wonderful dining experience! Food service and our conversation with the owner was great. It was like an evening in Italy!
Popular neighborhood Italian place with great dipping sauce and excellent service. They have hard-to-find Ricotta (Italian) Cheesecake and incredible bread pudding, so save room.
The service and food was exceptional. We go out to dinner weekly. It was one of my all time favorite meals.
The atmosphere and ambiance of Il Michelangelo's is wonderful. The service is outstanding! All of the food is excellent and full of delicious flavor! The sauces they use are incredible. My only complaint is the chocolate used on the Bomba dessert. It is chewy and doesn't crack like it is supposed to. It needs to be tempered more prior to having the gelato placed inside. Overall it is a wonderful experience and I look forward to returning for another fantastic meal.
Will definitely be back! Eddie was very nice. Food was delicious
Excellent dinner. The gnocchi were spectacular! Great spot for a date.
Always outstanding food & service! One of our favorites. We travel from outside Philly to get to this restaurant. It is worth the 2 hour drive.
Very VERY nice appetizers, food was awesome! This was the second and definitely not the last time there. We were a party of 9 and all loved the food. We tried everyone's dish and wanted to go back and try more. Very nice experience, highly recommend it. The chef, Dominic, is really an excellent chef btw.
Food is delicious and the service is outstanding. Most pasta dishes are sever with homemade pasta which is the best!! Nice wine list too.
The wild sea bass and gnocchi gorgonzola were delicious. Dominic is always a warm, entertaining host. He has invested to improve the place quite a bit since the last time we were there - the food was always very good but some of the decor was a bit tired. It now looks great, and is consistently outstanding value. A great place for dinner for two or large parties. Will definitely be there again soon.
I have eaten all over the US, travel for work, my mother from Italy still cooks for us when we are in town--This restaurant is as good as it gets in terms of real Italian food! Love the pasta!
This restaurant is fabulous. We were greeted by the owner upon arrival, and he was very polite. It is a cozy restaurant that has the appearance of a house. Our waiter, Eddie, was extremely polite and helpful, and he makes one mean tiramisu martini :) The food was spectacular. Everything was super fresh and super tasty. The owner visited us during our meal and we had a nice little chat with him. The neighborhood this restaurant is in is also very, very nice. I would recommend this restaurant to anybody. I can't say anything bad about it.
One of my pet peeves, and those at our table agreed, is using giant wine glasses and only filling them less then a quarter full
If you are going to charge $10+ for a 6 oz pour, it would look better, and make it seem like less of a rip off, in a smaller glass IMHO
Overall Wonderful dining experience. Wait staff were excellent. The Decour is fresh, very nice but not too formal. Clams casino was just OK. But our two pasta dishes were excellent. They were very gracious to accommodate a special order.
Food and service was great. Always a good experience when dining here
Michaelangelo's provided a lovely Mediterranean atmosphere which was tastefully decorated. The service was prompt, polite and non-intrusive. The food was excellent and well presented. I highly recommend Michaelangel's Restaurant.
Love restaurant. We eat there every Christmas Eve and never disappointed. We also eat there throughout the year. It’s nice to have the special attention of a restaurant that remembers you as a loyal customer and treat you accordingly.
Il Michelangelo Restaurant offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 316-1111.
Il Michelangelo Restaurant is rated 4.8 stars by 370 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.