We are never disappointed when we eat at Heirloom Tavern. The food is consistently delicious and the selections on the menu have something for everyone.
Heirloom Tavern is always a winner!
Service was excellent despite how busy they were. First time here so we sampled small plates only. Waiter gave great suggestions and each plate was better than the last! Their weeknight specials look great so we will definitely be returning again.
Always very good food, service. Always way too noisy but I keep going anyway.
Mussels are great!
We ordered several small plates, which came out in rounds so we could really enjoy each. The food was delicious and the waitstaff attentive.
One of the best for consistently very good cuisine on Long Island
Enjoyed casual dinner at the bar. Great drinks, great food.
Always delicious. We have never had a less than outstanding meal. Thank tou
Always a great experience. Service and food excellent
As always the crew at Heirloom makes you feel right at home, and always serving some of the best food anywhere in Nassau County. The special crab meat salad is the absolute BEST! Hope it stays on menu for awhile.
As always the food was delicious & consistent with previous times we’ve eaten there. Definitely one of our favorite places to dine
Took my mom for brunch on Mother’s Day. First time for mom, she loved it.
We had a wonderful evening the service was perfect our table wass ready when we walked in for our 830 reservationI
The wine selection was perfect and the food was delicious we left saying we have to come here more often!
Good but a little too salty for my taste. Why don’t so many restaurants like this one let me decide how much salt to add to my food? They so when it comes to pepper. It’s not like salt is some exotic spice that’s only in the kitchen. The friggin salt shaker is right on the table! I guess the wanted me to drink more.
Great friendly servers who personalize your dining experience. Exceptionally well thought out menu, with
daily specials and delicious staples. Don't be afraid to make a specific request request or modification to your order, they make every effort to please. Rustic ambience and easy parking add to the appeal.
Love this place!
Excellent food and service.
We received a gift card from our nephew, Andy came to Heirloom Tavern for their Friday special, Paella. We love seafood and was happy with their special. The calamari was the best I’ve tasted. Oh the mussels were very plentiful. We’d definitely came back.
It was afternoon. Personal service, very attentive. Food was great.
We've been going to Heirloom Tavern since it opened and it never disappoints. The food and service are excellent and reservations are honored right on time. The staff is always friendly and efficient. There is a great variety to choose from. The food is fresh, seasonal and well prepared. It is our go-to place. It can be noisy at times, but even on those nights, it is still worth it. Always look forward to our next visit.
Excellent food, excellent service, friendly staff!
Great place but small
Lovely dining experience!
Delicious food & great service
Always have an enjoyable meal and time here. Great local place.
Food and service was perfect. A smaller place so it was crowded and fairly loud on a Saturday night. Highly recommended!!
Food was excellent.
Food and service always top notch. Good value on most menu items. Bar/drinks are very pricey....Manhattan prices.
A friend and I had lunch at Heirloom Tavern today. We were the only two diners at 1:00 but other patrons wandered in as we ate. Both of us were delighted by the attentive service and food. I had the onion soup and endive salad and my friend had the asparagus and Brie sandwich. The portions were more than adequate and we overheard comments from the diners around us who also used words like “delicious, excellent,” and “wonderful.” I will positively return.
What a gem. Beautiful ambiance and wonderful service. The menu is extensive and so delicious. I can not think of a better restaurant on Long Island.
The Tavern is my families favorite spot for birthdays and other special occasions. We love to try different places but we almost always find the food here is better no matter the price. Filet Mignon with bacon risotto....c’mon!
Great food and excellent service! You won’t be disappointed. Burgers are juicy and delicious.
My favorite “go to” place when you want fabulous food, a warm and inviting atmosphere and excellent service! Small restaurant and tables are very close together but the food, service and ambiance outweighs that!
Friendly and attentive wait staff, reliably excellent food.
It was loud but we were still able to have a conversation.. I liked the relaxed atmosphere, and the waiter was very accommodating. I had the Chilean Sea Bass which was outstanding.
I think here you should stick to the basics Burger, French dip FF. I had the octopus. It was grilled and then sautéed in a tomato sauce. It was alittle rubbery and tough probably due to over cooking. Everything else was good especially the crusty bread served as you sit down. I will definitely go back but stick to the basics.
Excellent food, fast service, at tentative, overall a great place to go to!! I would highly recommend!!!
Food was great and great choices. Waiter seemed impatient when deciding on dishes and often walked away as I was thinking. It was also hard to get him back to order coffee. Though he was polite and had a nice time
All four courses of food were outstandingly tasty! Glad to have another option in the area to have a nice dinner out with my wife and friends.
As usual the menu is interesting and varied with dishes well prepared, tasty and attractively presented. The service is attentive and unpretentious. The atmosphere is comfortable. An excellent neighborhood restaurant.