This includes info about cleaning, sanitising, social distancing, and usage of personal protective equipment. Learn More.
Thank you for considering to join us.
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
Tomato, lettuce, yogurt sauce
chorizo, fennel, pernod
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Pistachio ice cream, chocolate sauce
Always an amazing meal at Heirloom. The service was great. I highly recommend the beet salad, the calamari and the steak au poivre.
Heirloom was an excellent choice for my birthday celebration.
Very warm greeting. Short wait for our table. Good wine selection . The special mahi mahi was delicious and nicely presented. Good sized portion.
Not cheap but not overpriced.
The service is perfect because attentive but not overbearing. The cocktails are made exactly as ordered and the wine selection is excellent. Each dish is prepared and presented ideally. The portions are good and the favors exceptional. Don’t expect to get a table for six or more but fabulous for a date or two couples. We have been there a few times and always a pleasure.
I love the relaxed vibe in this place. And the way they make you feel like a friend. The dishes are expertly cooked and come out piping hot. The chicken is spectacular. Price is right! My wife always gets the salmon. Love that many dishes that come out crispy and hot - like the chicken and salmon You get to pick your 2 sides w your entrée and they’re included!
Just a lovely evening. Everyone, from the host to the bartender to the wait and clean up staffs were gracious, attentive and pleasant. Food is always outstanding!
Everybody is so nice and the food is excellent!
It was a quiet Saturday afternoon having lunch with a friend. The food was very good but the portions were small. I had the blackened chicken sandwich that was served on a roll similar in size to a hamburger bun and the side salad (instead of fries) was tiny. The service was good and the food was tasty. Just wish the sandwich was a bit bigger espec for the price of $16.
Delicious meal and outstanding service!
We went for brunch, but I have been there many times for dinner. It was very quiet which was wonderful because at night it is very crowded and can get a bit noisy. The food is FABULOUS!
Love the food and the size and ambiance of Heirloom. Think it needs a second waiter on weekend daytimes...it was a lot for one person to handle though he did an excellent job.
First time for your mussels and certainly not the last!
Everything was perfect when we tried this venue for a Saturday lunch. The one waiter was so efficient that he was able to serve eight tables at once, yet he wasn't at all frazzled. We will return for dinner soon.
Just love this restaurant. Food is always excellent. Staff is friendly and accommodating. A bit noisy but it is a small cozy place. Not so noisy that you can't hear your conversation. Highly recommended!
This was an excellent dining experience. My wife and I had the duck spring rolls as our appetizer. We've been here before and were looking forward to that menu item. We then both had the crabmeat stuffed rainbow trout, which was done to crispy perfection. It was relatively quiet as it was Super Bowl sunday, but other times we have been there it has been noisier. We were extremely pleased with the entire experience.
Salad was tasteless except for the cheese on it.
Steak was tough and not flavorful
Unfortunately we were placed next to a large table with extremely loud dinners.
One of our favorite restaurants. The mussels were the best I think I’ve ever had! Not an empty seat in the house!
Delicious food, great service and amazing sangria! We are already looking forward to our next meal at Heirloom Tavern!
Service was attentive, varied menu.
Great meal, just a bit loud.
Perfect evening to take advantage of Long Island Restaurant Week. Busy and loud but enjoyable nonetheless. Fabulous food and service
Always great service and food....
Another perfect meal!!!
Always a fave of ours, the food at Heirloom Tavern is consistently excellent, with warm, friendly service and high quality ingredients. It never disappoints.
Excellent service and a wonderful meal. Enjoyed the Dinner.
Fantastic menu for a restaurant week. Heirloom never disappoints
Great meal and great service
Another great dinner at Heirloom Tavern. We had a terrific dinner tonight at Heirloom Tavern. Service was great and the food was excellent. All went well and we’ll be back soon.
It was our first time dining here, meeting friends who had eaten at your restaurant before. We enjoyed our meal and found the prices to be reasonable. Unfortunately, the table at the front of the restaurant was extremely loud, which made hearing one another somewhat difficult.
All in all, we had a nice experience, thank you!
We were four people on a Saturday night -- had a reservation and were seated right away, although the place was bustling (in a good way). The menu is very interesting and the food going by looked and smelled delicious -- it was hard to choose! We shared a few apps and they were yum! For entrees, some of us had fish, some had chicken -- everything was perfectly cooked and super tasty. Service was spot on; cocktails also great. And dessert is not to be missed! We had forgotten about it for a while, but are so glad we went back - and we will return!
Read some Yelp reviews all pretty good so it was a no brainier. Food, service, ambiance, were all great. Heirloom tavern is very cozy. I can't forget to mention the ease of parking. I would definitely recommend.
as always food and service at this nearby restaurant was very good and highly recommended
we love Heirloom Tavern and we visit often. Love the food and drinks and we like that it is so closely located to us.
Went for a lunch and had a good meal. The salmon burger was very good and service was efficient. Beignets for dessert were warm and delicious.
We had a spectacular evening. Food was creative and delicious, service excellent. Looking forward to going again soon.
We go to Heirloom Tavern on a regular basis. The food, atmosphere and service is excellent. It has become one of our favorite go to restaurants.
Terrific service super nice waitress. I understand tight for space. The tables are very close. I'm glad we always get the table in the back right up against the wall. I'm going to request next time. Happy holiday's
Super good dinner - service and food fantastic!! Will be back again!
Yummy meal, always consistent! Service was excellent as well. Drinks always top notch!!
This was the second time we'd dined here prior to a concert at the Tillis Center. The place is very small and you can hear your neighbor's conversations with ease. Plus, the tables for two are not in the greatest locations.
There was only one person waiting on all the customers for the first 30 minutes of our 1.5 hours there. Even with the additional two people who showed, the service was still slow.
The food was just okay. The Clams Oreganta were tasteless as were both seafood entrees. All but the soup and French fries were served tepid, at best, and they got very cold very quickly. And for dessert, I asked the waiter for his recommendation from four different options. He told me another dessert that was not on my list. I ended up ordering it and it was, again, tasteless. Overall, we spent almost $200 for a very mediocre meal. It was definitely better a year ago. Next time, we'll dine elsewhere.
Very impressed. Came into town from NYC to see a concert. Food was fabulous. Ordered the duck spring rolls and clams oreganta to start. Wish we had also tried the scallops because they looked and smelled amazing (and also sold out early!)
I had a pasta with lobster that was delicious and my husband had a steak. Great meal.
Very nice overall. Just don’t take the table by the kitchen/bathroom.
Heirloom Tavern does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Heirloom Tavern also offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 686-6633.
Heirloom Tavern is rated 4.7 stars by 848 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.