Heirloom Tavern

Consistently delicious

Friendly staff serving excellent food. Always a hit.

Heirloom is a great place for any occasion!

Delicious food, good service!

Truly outstanding food and service! Heirloom is very well managed. Reservations are honored and I never have to wait to be seated. The manager and wait staff go out of their way to assure that your food is prepared to your liking and served in a timely and efficient manner. The menu has a lot of dishes to choose from and the food is tasty and cooked as requested. I highly recommend Heirloom Tavern!

Everything about this restaurant is fabulous, the food, the atmosphere and the service is outstanding!!!

Wonderful food, nice ambiance and great service
Look forward to returning

This was our second visit and it did NOT disappoint! Atmosphere is "pub-like" but the food is outstanding. Many great choices - the chef and the kitchen staff take pride in their creations and it shows. Would highly recommend The Heirloom Tavern!

Great food and ambience. Good place for pre-concert if you are going to Tilles center

Very good!

The food was good. I had the vegetarian lasagna and my partner had the chicken cordon bleu which were both delicious. The butternut squash soup was average and the profiteroles were not bad. This was during Restaurant Week so the menu was limited. I'd definitely go back and try things on their full menu. The serving staff were excellent, by the way.

Alway’s great !

Good service

Top notch food except for desert. The apple in the apple tart felt like reconstituted paper with little or no taste. Maybe the tart wasn't made in house. Everything else was really good. I had a cocktail (rusty nail) which seemed pricey at $16. Overall a very good restaurant.

Was here two years ago. They have maintained an excellent varied menu with exceptional, friendly wait staff. I’m glad there was such a great turn out but the too close tables and noise levels is what made a 1 star loss. Highly recommended place!

Picked because of Restaurant Week. Wasn't disappointed. Great food and service. Obviously a locals place but made us feel right at home. Never felt rushed. Will visit again.

First time there. Small intimate space. Service was excellent. The food was extremely good. Large menu.

We enjoyed our first trip to the restaurant. Food and service were both good. We were there Sunday 530 so it was not noisy. We will be back

This is one of our favorite restaurants. The duck is the best I've had anywhere. My wife's pasta was fantastic too.

Service not up to their standards

Enjoyed an unexpectedly great lunch. Wonderful salads, great burgers. Ingredients very fresh.

I just love this restaurant. The menu selection & the specials offered are excellent. The food is prepared perfectly with a wonderful presentation. The wine was very enjoyable. Every time I go to this restaurant I am very pleased. I can't wait to go again. Pleasant atmosphere and waiter, too.

Heirloom Tavern never disappoints. Food is always delicious. The choices on the menu will please everyone. HT is our go to place.

Great service - delicious food - great atmosphere

This is one of my very favorite restaurants on Long Island. Such a wide menu of small, medium, large plates!

My husband & I celebrate our wedding anniversary here & it was amazing ! Food, drinks, service ! All wonderful ! They even decorated a dessert plate saying “ Happy Anniversary” for us. Food was amazing also !! I highly recommend visiting!

Our favorite local place for certain!
Alex and his staff make you feel at home always, and good never disappoints. Great for special occasions, or even if you just feel like the Best Burger in town!
Saturday night can be a bit noisy, but if you go early it is well worth it!
Enjoy!

One of our go back tos

AMAZING FOOD QUAINT PLACE. GREAT SERVICE!! It’s a win win!! Highly recommend!

Always a special occasion when we take our grandkids out for dinner. They LOVE Heirloom and we always know they will have a delicious meal. Staff is always friendly, accommodating and professional. Our favorite local restaurant.

Everything was perfect! The food, the service and the drinks were spot on!! The homemade ravioli appetizer is a must!! Will be going back with friends.

Although dim in lighting and tight in space the Food is delicious!

Nice place. Located across from the railroad station..plenty of parking..had rsvp for 2 .seated immediately...
Food was excellent..

Food was fantastic. Presentation-amazing. Great service. Lovely spot. Lovely lunch

Little gem by the train station. No one was there when we walked in, but the food was fresh and the waitress was very kind.

Always a great visit multiple time returning customer

Service was attentive , I had onion burger...delicious branzino fresh

The food was very good

Lobster carbonara is excellent. Tuna burger also extremely good. The scallop special was quite good as well. Had the arugula & Serrano ham salad & the beet salad- both very nice. Food is consistently well prepared & fresh. Can sometimes be noisy although this evening was better than other times. Always like this restaurant.

Not a place for a quick bite. This is a true neighborhood eatery with serious food in what feels like a casual cozy pub setting. If you like to share a good time with friends and family, this is a great place. Music is background, not loud. You can actually talk and hear!

We never ended up ordering main courses. Heirloom Tavern has an extensive Tapas style menu with varied small plates and a “bar menu” which essentially doubles a fun Tapas-style experience. We ordered about a dozen or so plates for four of us with a Caesar salad and endive salad. Enjoyed meatballs, filet mignon sliders, grilled octopus, mussels, gulf prawns, lobster tacos etc. could not have been more fun! Don’t miss this one! A unique place with a serious chef.