Great service - delicious food - great atmosphere
This is one of my very favorite restaurants on Long Island. Such a wide menu of small, medium, large plates!
My husband & I celebrate our wedding anniversary here & it was amazing ! Food, drinks, service ! All wonderful ! They even decorated a dessert plate saying “ Happy Anniversary” for us. Food was amazing also !! I highly recommend visiting!
Our favorite local place for certain!
Alex and his staff make you feel at home always, and good never disappoints. Great for special occasions, or even if you just feel like the Best Burger in town!
Saturday night can be a bit noisy, but if you go early it is well worth it!
One of our go back tos
AMAZING FOOD QUAINT PLACE. GREAT SERVICE!! It’s a win win!! Highly recommend!
Always a special occasion when we take our grandkids out for dinner. They LOVE Heirloom and we always know they will have a delicious meal. Staff is always friendly, accommodating and professional. Our favorite local restaurant.
Everything was perfect! The food, the service and the drinks were spot on!! The homemade ravioli appetizer is a must!! Will be going back with friends.
Although dim in lighting and tight in space the Food is delicious!
Nice place. Located across from the railroad station..plenty of parking..had rsvp for 2 .seated immediately...
Food was excellent..
Food was fantastic. Presentation-amazing. Great service. Lovely spot. Lovely lunch
Little gem by the train station. No one was there when we walked in, but the food was fresh and the waitress was very kind.
Always a great visit multiple time returning customer
Service was attentive , I had onion burger...delicious branzino fresh
The food was very good
Lobster carbonara is excellent. Tuna burger also extremely good. The scallop special was quite good as well. Had the arugula & Serrano ham salad & the beet salad- both very nice. Food is consistently well prepared & fresh. Can sometimes be noisy although this evening was better than other times. Always like this restaurant.
Not a place for a quick bite. This is a true neighborhood eatery with serious food in what feels like a casual cozy pub setting. If you like to share a good time with friends and family, this is a great place. Music is background, not loud. You can actually talk and hear!
We never ended up ordering main courses. Heirloom Tavern has an extensive Tapas style menu with varied small plates and a “bar menu” which essentially doubles a fun Tapas-style experience. We ordered about a dozen or so plates for four of us with a Caesar salad and endive salad. Enjoyed meatballs, filet mignon sliders, grilled octopus, mussels, gulf prawns, lobster tacos etc. could not have been more fun! Don’t miss this one! A unique place with a serious chef.
Food was not good but it was crowded. We sat next to the kitchen! Every time someone walked to the kitchen or the bathroom the floor moved!
This is a great place but way too noisy.
Heirloom Tavern is one of my favorite local spots! They have a wide variety of options for all types of eaters. As a vegan, I was especially pleased that there side dishes could be made dairy free and put together on a plate so I could feel like I was having a complete meal as well. It would be a great idea to advertise a ‘veggie plate’ so other people like me know that there’s an option for them right away.
Keep up the great work!
Outstanding. Food. Service. Drinks! Totalky reccomend!
Best food and service! My go to restaurant whenever I get a chance!
One of my favorite local restaurants.
A gem of a restaurant not to be missed! Never been disappointed with anything I have eaten here. It’s my go to restaurant now and I always look forward to eating here!!
We had dinner and cocktails at the bar.
Stephani, the bartender, must have at one time worked under Danny Meyer - the ultimate hospitality restaurateur!
Stephani was terrific! She was very attentive to our needs, even before we asked.
Thank you Heirloom for a delicious dinner and great service.
We shared the Duck appetizer- great and then enjoyed our 2 salads I had the Lobster and my friend had the Crabmeat. Fresh and beautifully presented. We ordered a bottle of Pinot (Levin) I believe it was called, which was unremarkable without any discernible flavor ( which was surprising ) would probably opt for the other Pinot selection or go for a Chardonnay with the salads. Finished the meal with the profiteroles- must have dessert!
Heirloom never disappoints when it comes to food and service. I love a restaurant that is consistently flawless.
Food delicious and a great variety. LOVE LOVE the chocolate cake and with the mint cc ice cream, incredibly!!!!
The service is excellent! We also love the bartender even though we do not usually sit at the bar, she is so outgoing and makes a phenomenal sangria.
Drinks were fabulous- white wine sangria!! Food super and our waitress was friendly, knowledgeable . We weren’t rushed with our food and had a really nice dinner- thank you
We arrived at Heirloom looking to just have a quick meal. We had to use restraint because we had made a deal with each other that we were just going to have hamburgers and believe me that’s hard to do! Great menu, great service and the hamburgers were perfect. It’s fresh good food, good drinks and great ambience.
We were fine until a party of six we’re seated right next to us with a screaming child. They let the child carry on for too long before finally stepping outside with him. The manager offered to move us. But that was too late.
The group at the bar (3 people) was very loud, including the very pregnant bartender. Their conversation wasn’t for our or any other child’s ears. Or mine.
The food and service were great! Which is why I wanted to go for my birthday dinner! I could’ve done without the added noise !!! Next time I’m requesting a table in the back- away from the bar!!
A Neighborhood Gem!
Always Delicious and I'm Never Disappointed!
Always wonderful. Never disappoints.
This welcoming neighborhood restaurant has plentiful parking, excellent food and a varied interesting menu.
All three of us really appreciated the small plates menu that allowed us to sample a variety of the very enticing menu items without busting the budget or our waistlines. Have been here a number of times; it never disappoints.
This is really good restaurant, on Sunday which we went here it was very very quite. The prices for lunch is very high and that probably was part of it. The food was very fresh.
I am a repeat customer. I have been here many times. Never dissapoint
Every time we dine at this gem, it’s delicious
We have eaten here many times, food is always very good
Great local eatery