10 Best Shellfish Restaurants In Middletown

10 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Red Lobster - Middletown restaurant

1. Red Lobster - Middletown

4.3

Awesome(14)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Middletown

Good food (lobster and shrimp) & great service for a decent price. As always, love those biscuits!

A photo of Oceanos Restaurant restaurant

2. Oceanos Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(3968)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Fairlawn

Booked 36 times today

There are plenty of restaurants where you can have a good dinner, but very few that make an evening feel like an occasion. Oceanos is one of those places. My wife and I came for our anniversary, and everything was exceptional. We started with the grilled octopus, which was incredibly tender with just the right amount of char. It set the tone for a fantastic meal. What really impressed us was Mandy. Her professionalism, attention to detail, and effortless hospitality made us feel genuinely taken care of. Nothing felt rushed, and the evening unfolded beautifully. Oceanos understands fine dining. Elegant without being pretentious, polished without feeling stiff. A wonderful place to celebrate something special.

3. Blu Pointe

4.4

Awesome(204)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Newburgh

Booked 40 times today

This was an absolutely amazing restaurant. Our service was excellent and our waiter was incredible. The food and restaurant itself were great. Celebrated my wife's birthday and I would come here several times again

4. Kee Oyster House

4.8

Exceptional(1104)

$$$$

• Shellfish • White Plains

Booked 21 times today

This is one of our favorite seafood restaurants locally. The quality, flavor and service never misses! We were celebrating our wedding anniversary and they were kind enough to surprise us with a special treat!

5. River Pavilion

4.3

Awesome(174)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Kingston

Beautiful location. Excellent service (Jose was terrific , Good food and drinks. And very nice eperience.

A photo of Aquario Restaurant restaurant

6. Aquario Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(425)

$$$$

• Shellfish • West Harrison

Booked 7 times today

We had an amazing dinner for our anniversary. The food from apps to dessert and cappuccino was outstanding. We each had fish, Dover Sole and Chilean Sea Bass, both were cooked to perfection! We will be back!!

A photo of Red Lobster - Wayne restaurant

7. Red Lobster - Wayne

4.2

Awesome(19)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Wayne

Had a great experience and the food was delicious our server D.D was amazing, definitely heading back soon😊

A photo of Meltemi Greek Restaurant restaurant

8. Meltemi Greek Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(75)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Ridgewood, New Jersey

Booked 11 times today

We had lunch on a Sunday at Meltemi. Our waiter was incredibly attentive. We took his recommendations and were not disappointed. Everything was incredibly fresh. We had branzino and halibut, grape leaves and calamari, hummus with wonderful pita bread. We will definitely be back!!

A photo of Red Lobster - Paramus restaurant

9. Red Lobster - Paramus

4.1

Excellent(21)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Paramus

Had the ultimate and there was enough food to share-even my husband had his own dinner. Your happy hour $5 for certain drinks was unexpected but great. Service was terrific also.

10. Bistro 146

4.8

Exceptional(463)

$$$$

• Shellfish • Pleasantville

Booked 3 times today

Bistro 146 is a true neighborhood gem. The menu is very large and so are the portions, usually plenty to take home. I'm very fussy about fish and every dish is prepared perfectly, never dry or overcooked. Sides are fresh and inventive. Instead of fighting the crowds in the center of town, come here for dinner and you'll be returning again and again.

Best Shellfish Restaurants in Middletown

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Red Lobster - Middletown

2. Oceanos Restaurant

3. Blu Pointe

4. Kee Oyster House

5. River Pavilion

6. Aquario Restaurant

7. Red Lobster - Wayne

8. Meltemi Greek Restaurant

9. Red Lobster - Paramus

10. Bistro 146

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable