23 Best Italian Restaurants In San Juan Islands

23 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Cafe Brio

4.7

Exceptional(847)

$$$$

• Italian • Victoria

Booked 22 times today

Cafe Brio was delightful! Welcoming, delicious food and great wine list. Obviously a local favorite. The lamb special was excellent. What’s not to like! If you can get a table go for it!!!

2. Zambri's

4.7

Exceptional(2741)

$$$$

• Italian • Victoria

Booked 13 times today

Excellent evening! Food was fantastic and service was so great too. Given my old brain, I unfortunately can’t remember our server and helpers’ names but they were all so good…perfect balance of attentive and informative, respectful and kind and fun. Great evening! Thanks all! You guys rock!

3. Rudi

4.6

Exceptional(184)

$$$$

• Italian • Victoria

Booked 29 times today

Service was excellent, prawns were superb. We will be back again.

A photo of FARO - Oak Bay Beach Hotel restaurant

4. FARO - Oak Bay Beach Hotel

4.7

Exceptional(833)

$$$$

• Italian • Victoria

Booked 6 times today

A great spot for a more casual evening out. Excellent service and loved the pizza!

A photo of Frankie's Modern Diner restaurant

5. Frankie's Modern Diner

4.6

Exceptional(670)

$$$$

• Italian • Victoria

Booked 3 times today

Great food, amazing service. Travelling and eat breakfast there both days.

6. Elio Volpe

4.8

Exceptional(919)

$$$$

• Italian • Fairview

Booked 94 times today

Isabella and Amelia provided exceptional service. The food especially the pizza, vongole, and pork chop were made perfectly and the most delicious.

A photo of Osteria Savio Volpe restaurant

Icon

7. Osteria Savio Volpe

4.8

Exceptional(4848)

$$$$

• Italian • Fraserhood

Booked 67 times today

Perfect, as usual. Our server picked the most amazing selection for us as part of the "let us cook for you" option -- prosciutto, a grain salad, pasta, steak & cannoli. Service is always friendly, generous, and perfectly attentive without ever feeling rushed. There's a reason I keep going back!

8. Lot 1 Pasta Bar

4.0

Excellent(487)

$$$$

• Italian • Victoria

Booked 2 times today

Great time, good food and the service is always awesome. Thanks

A photo of Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Langley restaurant

9. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Langley

4.6

Exceptional(62)

$$$$

• Italian • Langley

Booked 134 times today

Service and timing of the food was very good. Our server was very nice and very attentive to our needs. Asked all the right questions. I’m sorry I didn’t get her name but I’m sure they are all good. Even your Host with his arm in a sling. That tells me that they want to work! Our friends are from New Zealand and it’s the only place they want go to when they come to visit.

10. Roe

4.8

Exceptional(350)

$$$$

• Italian • Bellingham

Booked 18 times today

Always a stellar experience to be had at Roe. Food was impeccable, service was lovely, and we had a blast introducing our family to some of the best food around. Cheersing with caviar chicken nuggies is a MUST!

Best Italian Restaurants in San Juan Islands

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

23 restaurants available nearby

1. Cafe Brio

2. Zambri's

3. Rudi

4. FARO - Oak Bay Beach Hotel

5. Frankie's Modern Diner

6. Elio Volpe

7. Osteria Savio Volpe

8. Lot 1 Pasta Bar

9. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Langley

10. Roe

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable