Best American Restaurants in West Milford

As usual everything was perfect especially our server Nicole who is a true professional. See y’all soon

This was my first time to the Saddle River Cafe with my wife who has been here. She had the Turkish eggs, which she thought was excellent. I had the Saddle River Cafe breakfast: 3 eggs over easy, potatoes, sourdough bread and turkey sausage. The eggs were very slightly over cooked. The sausage and bread were great. Service was a little slow. My biggest disappointment was that there was no steak or short ribs. Overall very good.

Had the best dinner. Service was absolutely exceptional, courses were properly timed and we did not feel rushed. The food was phenomenal. Our server Annamarie was so sweet and took such great care of us. We will definitely come back

It was our first time and we loved it! The setting, our waiter, the food... all A+! All four of us ordered different dishes and we all thought ours was delicious. Even the roasted mushrooms were yummy and plentiful And we could actually hear each other fully when we talked!! We will definitely return.

We loved everything about this place ... transformed from a bank into a restaurant, it was the perfect atmosphere for dinner. We were seated by the "vault" which had gold bars stacked in it ... LOL! The waiter, Colby, was friendly and attentive. We shared the 8 hour octopus for an appetizer and my boyfriend had the lamb shank and I had one of the specials for the day, slow cooked pork ribs ... YUMMY! I had 2 lychee martinis, and he had a non-alcoholic beer called CONE HEAD ZERO which he says had a slight citrus taste to it. Overall, a great dining experience ... would recommend and come back again.