Connolly's Pub and Restaurant - 45th
Incredibly fast service. Quality of food was excellent on some dishes and so so on others. For example, the smoked salmon appetizer was superb and the burger was pretty good and the Cobb salad was exceptional. However the calamari was not so good. Drinks were fine, but a bit overpriced for a pub.
Great food and desserts! Just wish we were in town to experience St. Patrick’s Day .. I bet it is s blast here!
The warm pretzels are the best!!
Good food with GF options. My ribs and fries were delivious
The menu was a nice surprise because there were so many food items to pick from. Our server was extremely attentive and made our lunch experience even more enjoyable.
Loved the atmosphere of the restaurant. The food was good and our waitress was so personable!!! They also have a 3rd floor deck where you can eat outside.
Was very upset with our table. The restaurant was crowded and there was only one table available and it was nest the kitchen entrance. We left and went to the competition next door.
Shepherds pie just ok. Would try something else next time.
Great place to stop before or after the theater. The service was great and the fish and chips was excellent. Thanks to Joe for taking care of us.
It was beautiful weather day which made it
perfect for rooftop dining. Service was great and service very good. Only bad thing was elevator was not working to go up so we had to walk the 4 flights. Did work on the way down though.
Great place to go for a good pre-theatre meal: very good food, very reasonable prices for both food and drinks, and very good service!
Friendly staff and we were greeted, seated promptly with our open table reservation. Typical NYC pricing; really delicious and fresh salads! Beautiful wood trim throughout the downstairs. Noisy as you would expect in a pub, but still were able to converse in a normal voice at our table.
Our table was by a window so we could watch the street activity. Food was delicious. Wait staff very pleasant. Would highly recommend as it is close to the theater district
Great food and friendly staff
Lunch on a Saturday for seven ws easily handled by the restaurant. We were seated even though our entire party had not yet arrived. Briona, our waitress was fantastic and very accommodating.
Had a large table right next to us. Way too loud. Food was just ok.
Just decided to stop in for some drinks and appetizers on our way to the Theatre and it was surprisingly good. Will definitely go back.
Touristy. If you want to grab a beer it’s a good place to go with friends. Not meant for serum
We ordered a couple of drinks (beer and cocktail) and the Irish beef stew and shepherd's pie. Everything was great and the food not only came quickly but was piping hot. Love it! The server recommended the chocolate chip lava cake and she was right. It is quite rich but the chocolate lava is to die for. Service was excellent, in fact I felt they checked on us too many times. We were in and out within 50 min. If that's what you're after, before a theater performance maybe, give them a try.
Recommended by a friend but was pretty underwhelming, no real Irish charm, had run out of several of the craft beers early in the evening midweek. I'm sure there are better Irish bars in NYC.
Great place to eat. Reasonable prices.
Didn't feel packed in like sardines which is often the case at NYC pubs.
Quiet restaurant early in the day. Good service and food.
This is one of our must go to restaurants when we go to NYC. We always have a great meal. The service is wonderful.
Great rooftop venue for our family gathering after a College Graduation Ceremony held at Madison Square Garden
Outdoor roof deck was perfect for lunch on a beautiful day before a matinee! Great salads!
Great value and prices were extremely reasonable for the city. Greeted by such a friendly hostess. Burgers were great and place was only 1 block from our show. Service was excellent! Very attentive! Bathroom was very clean too! Would definitely return!
Such a good place to go in the theater district for good value, decent food, fun atmosphere.
Buon cibo ma con disservizio. Probabilmente il cameriere si è dimenticato di passare l’ordine alla cucina ed è passata circa un’ora prima di essere serviti. Ovviamente il “tip” è stato, di conseguenza, molto ridotto.
Excellent Irish Pub on 45th. Food was steaming hot and delicious. We tried the Hot Pretzel app, Harp Ale Fish n Chips, Reuben, and Burgers - exceptional n we'll be goin back...
Perfect lunch meeting place! Low key, great food and service.
Upstairs seating was pleasant and quiet, service was good. Main level was deafening even for the few minutes we were waiting to check in with the host.
Reservation was honored, preferred table offered, food great, requests honored - in a word "perfect!"
first time! loved it loved our breakfast!
going back!!great staff great food!
Good value and good food for NYC. Very noisy on a Friday afternoon-but service was very good and food tasty. It's a pub; so you should know what to expect.
What better than an Irish Pub when your cousins from Ireland visit New York. We had a grand time, a nice meal, much fun and laughter, not rushed at all the pints were flowing to those who wanted. Highly recommended.
Direkt neben dem Hotel. Ganz o. k., um auf die Schnelle mal etwas zu essen. Netter Service und typische Pub atmosphäre.
Good spot for kid-friendly food if you're going to Be More Chill (a few feet away). Pleasant service, reasonable prices, average quality.
We always enjoy this location of Connolly’s. The food is very good and the atmosphere is an Irish pub with dark woods, brass and comfortable seating. We frequent Connolly’s and on this day our service was not very good. We only received part of our meal and when we inquired we were told they would check, and then had to remind the service staff a second time that we only received part of our order. My food got cold waiting for the rest of the order. We also were not approached about refills for drinks or as a normal check on the table. The restaurant was not busy when we were seated or placed our order. More customers were seated as we were there and they received attention. It was as if we were forgotten about. If the service was more attentive we probably would have spent more and had more drinks and dessert. As it was we felt forgotten about and left and went elsewhere to continue our evening.
Food was delicious and portions too big.l One dish is enough to feed two.