Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC
Great place. Service is fantastic. Food is delicious. Portions are amazing. Will return, and often when in NYC
Everything was beyond amazing! ❤️
Treating tourists to a taste of NYC before a broadway show.
Food portions are enormous so would not recommend this restaurant unless you have at least three people in your party as even sharing one entrée is more than enough for three!
Friendly place and good food
Très bon restaurant où les parts sont très généreuses. Génial pour partager en famille ou avec les amis.
A deux pas des comédies musicales, très bonne adresse.
Rapport quantité/ qualité/ prix très bon.
A must if your in New York! Authentic Italian family style eatery with very large portions great atmosphere and helpful staff.
Gezellig Italiaans restaurant waar duidelijk niet aan portiemanagement wordt gedaan. Je gaat er zeker niet met honger buiten. De prijs is niet hoog en de service is goed!
Food and service was excellent. Portions are enough to feed 4.
The waiter, service, and the food were excellent. The waiter was attentive and explained the menu well. The menu is rustic, without the common over-explaining done on other high end menus, but clear. I thought it was a bit pricey, but overall I feel I got good value and can’t wait to go back again.
It was our first time at Carmine's & we loved everything about this restaurant. As many people have mentioned the portions are very generous! But most importantly the food was delicious! There were 5 of us and we had Calamari, Carmine's salad, Penne Alla Vodka & Chicken Parm and it could have easily fed 2 more people. Our server Melissa was very friendly & attentive and made our experience even more enjoyable. We will definitely go back the next time we visit NYC!
Great service and amazing food. Will recommend for friends to come.
It was a fabulous dinner with excellent service!
It's always a great meal at Carmine's.
As always lots
Of authentic home style Italian food.
The complimentary bread was bad and it was very busy and loud (to be expected in Times square I guess) but the other food was good and it was a cool location
This place is so overrated and what they serve is an insult to anyone who can cook. My daughter ordered the kids pizza and all they did was slap some mozzarella on the free cold bread that was on the table. I ordered manicotti. There was no sauce and it was extremely salty. My only positive experience was the service.
The food was delicious and the energy in Carmine’s was fantastic. Even though we were an hour late for our reservation, they got us in, in 30 minutes. The food was fantastic, and it was so fresh. We had the calamari, the spudini ala romana, penne vodka and chicken parmesan. It was so fresh and tasty. We can’t wait to go back.
Food was great. Huge portions but pricy. Service was excellent once I finally got a waiter. I was irritated it took me and a couple of other diners so long to get a waiter and a menu once seated. Why not start with the food menu like a normal restaurant? But once I did get a waiter, my waiter was very attentive checking on my table and all the other customers as well. Responding to requests very quickly. At times I didn't even have to ask, as they anticipated my and other diners' needs.
Food was great, but the wine is ridiculously priced.
Thank you.....great location....classic Italian family style
Been there many of times and never disappoints. Good food good service and without saying great for large groups
Great pre-theater lunch. Food was really good - the Portobello Parmigiana is a must! Our waiter Wilson was great too. Will be back.
Broadway with the girls
Great dinner with my wife. Staff is always great and food is amazing!
The salad and main course was everything I expected. The portions are huge and we took half the meal home. Plan on splitting everything.
This was our furst visit to Carmine's. The food was fantastic, best Italian food we have had from a restaurant! Great service! Reservations for 430p and we were seated at 430p! Love Carmine's!
Dinner and service was outstanding. They accommodated us- we had someone in our party in a WC and they were able to find us a comfortable table. Would definitely recommend for individuals who enjoy Italian food.
We felt rushed. Staff clearing off plates as we are eating.
perfect spot for lunch before a Broadway matinee. Huge portions, tasty food and good service. we are repeat customers.
A favorite spot for one and all. Food was great and so was the service. Very close to the theater's makes Carmine's an excellent choice before a show.
Great value for family-stye meals. We were a group of very hungry adults and we ordered a total of 4 dishes and we came away stuffed, with some pasta to take home. Also, we were given our table right away even if our party was not yet complete.
My scampi was better before when I went to
The restaurant. This visit, the sauce was more
Amazing service! Unbelievably good food!
The concept is cute but the food was a miss.
Spaghetti was not cooked and it tasted like something I could get from Olive Garden.
Albeit, I went in there expecting some authentic Italian food- and that is my own issue. Otherwise, service was good.
Only family style dishes so not really a great choice for couple. Awesome choice for group of 4 or more. It’s a little bit of a madhouse, but that is also the ambiance it is striving for. Great pre theatre choice for group.
Absolutely wonderful experience, great food, fun atmosphere, made our trip !
Great food and place to gather with friends and family
Too crowd no room to wait to be seated...just horrible. The food was excellent