Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC
Everybody enjoyed the food a lot!
Visit to NYC, saw the reviews for this place and wasn’t disappointed. Fantastic place, beautiful with a lively atmosphere. Value for money was exceptional. 4 people well fed for less than $60 in Time Square!
Excellent place, delicious pasta and good service
Portions are HUGE! Definitely much better for groups as it’s family style.
Family style, large portions, bring an appetite and friends.
Great way to feel the city. High energy. Food portions are huge and can easily service 3 people each dish. They service was prompt and attentive and the food was good. Love that they service your wine in small carafes. The bread is delicious. We will return.
Food was good. Very filling.
Price was relative to location.
Good ambiance and music.
We were seated right away for our reservation. The waitress was very friendly and welcoming. The food was amazing and the server whose brought our food to us was awesome. Although a fellow waiter ignored my request for some glasses of water another waitress overheard my conversation at the table and gave me everything we asked for. The food was AMAZING! Definitely coming back for a round two.
La nourriture était excellente. Nous avons prit les fruits de mer et n'avons pu finir notre assiette malgré notre grande appétit tellement il y en avait. Le service est personnalisé et on ne se sent pas pressé. L'ambiance est agréable avec musique de circonstances. Notre réservation à été respecté et une mention pour les deux cocktails prit au bar choisir par la serveuse. Je le recommande vivement. Première fois et sûrement pas la dernière.
Excellent consistent food and service
Great for large groups
Portions are to big for a party of two, perhaps as a family restaurant it suits it purpose.
Plus the fact that the qulity was poor.
My experience 15 years ago was much better in this restaurant.
I will not consider to visit it a next time.
Fantastic Italian food! Monstrous portions that you can feast on for days.
Great great great
Awesome service ! Thank you, Tyler !!!!
Food is always amazing....and plenty for leftovers !!!!!! YUMM!!
always good family style food - enjoy it every time we go
We went for lunch before going to see the show Wicked. The food was fantastic and the portions were way too generous. It's family style and we order one entree and side of broccoli, every thing was delicious!
We are never disappointed whenever we eat at Carmines. Wish we had Carmines in Connecticut.
Our favorite place to eat in the city. Wouldn't go anywhere else.
Everything was good except the waitress was kinda annoyed by my girlfriend asking questions about the food. We was kinda surprised by that. But the guys who bring the food to your table was very nice.
The strict family style dini9ng does not work for smaller parties.
This was my first time visiting and I will definitely be back again! The food was AMAZING, we had the prime rib special and it’s something I look forward to eat again!
Family style service, large portions. you need to go in group of 4 or more. Dinner for two may be a challenge because the amount of food they serve you is huge.
Carmine's is a touristy place, convenient for dinner after the show. Very loud, tables very close together, but the waiteress was great. Super salty veal parm. But overall pretty good. Best for groups of 3 or more. Reservations required
Todo muy bien, salvo que no había lasagna
Great Food! Quick Service! Will definitely be back!
We waited about 30 minutes after our reservation to get seated. The front desk acted as if they may have forgotten to come get us from the bar. No explanation why we had to wait so long. Just said it would be a few more minutes as they sat others.
Everything was perfect...we enjoyed our dinner, it was soooo delicious ... The service was great and we’ve a lot of fun
The waiter was extremely rude and the Maitre D was not helpful or attentive to my concerns. The food was cold and undercooked. The whole experience was horrible and I would never go back.
Great time .. service was great We came a little earlier than what our scheduled reservation was and the accommodated us in 20 Minutes
Excellent attentive service. The food was terrific. The hot anti pasta was more than enough for my wife and I and gave us a great variety. We had eaten in Little Italy at 2 different restaurants the day before and Carmine’s was much better than both. Overall, great dining experience.
Carmines is our favorite place in NYC after seeing a show. Can be a bit crowded and noisy, but the food is outstanding!
great food / great service /made reservation and got table right a way /fair pricing but bill adds up quicker than you think LOL/too may choices!! would definitely go again
Put an order in for spaghetti and meatballs and waited over an hour for the dish to arrive. Meanwhile, parties that were seated and ordered after us received their food long before us. I finally was able to flag down our waiter and ask how much longer. He said he would check and then came out with our food. He never apologized nor would explain how the other tables received their food first. Our food was lukewarm at best. Not going back.
Food mediocre, service good, VERY loud including subway vibrations.
Great place great food and great people will deffs be back
Excellent Italian food, especially the Italian sausage. Huge family style portions meant for sharing. Staff was great. People were enjoying themselves, so the noise level was pretty high. Great experience that I would highly recommend!
From fried calamari, linguni and zuppa di clam, everything = excellent.
The service and food was great! It was a bit loud due to the rowdiness of one table who had kids who were yelling and getting up constantly to walk around the table. Other than this, it was a good experience.