Best American Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

View all

Best American Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

Sushi Yasaka
(815)
$$$$
Sushi | Upper West Side
Tavern on the Green
(2716)
$$$$
American | Midtown West
HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(391)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Sheepshead Bay restaurants

  • Restaurant List
  • Best restaurants

Sheepshead Bay Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Sheepshead Bay restaurants

Sheepshead Bay Restaurants

Nargis Cafe
Nargis Cafe
(26)
$$$$
Middle Eastern | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was excellent the decor pleasing and the service good BUT: the main courses should have been served all together instead of one of us eating while the others just watched. This was disturbing. More

OpenTable Diner -
Tsob-Tsobe
Tsob-Tsobe
(11)
$$$$
Mediterranean | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

I really enjoyed the food and the service and I definitely recommend to others More

OpenTable Diner -
Anthony's Place
Anthony's Place
(114)
$$$$
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

See all offers

First time trying Anthony’s. Went on a Friday and they had great happy hour specials. Discounted drinks and appetizers. We had the red sangria which was excellent. We ordered the buffalo calamari, shrimp Oreganata and mussels. Also ordered baked clams from regular menu. Everything was great but the winner was the shrimp! Kelley, our waitress, was great. She was attentive and gave us great recommendations. We were full but ordered the veal chop for dinner and the chopped salad (Bobb salad) to share and the other person had the lasagne. The salad was light and delicious! I tasted the lasagne which I thought was great. The veal chop was a little on the tough side but had great flavor. The chef stopped by the table to see how everything was and gave us a taste of the homemade wine he makes on the house. So good!! Dessert was his homemade Italian cheesecake which was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Next Door
Next Door
(42)
$$$$
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was incredible! The staff were welcoming and friendly. Overall, great dining experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
(16)
$$$$
Sushi | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Outstanding!! More

OpenTable Diner -
Blu Turkish Restaurant
Blu Turkish Restaurant
(51)
$$$$
Turkish | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Great food !! Everything was delicious.... More

OpenTable Diner -
Il Fornetto
Il Fornetto
(207)
$$$$
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

I wanted a very scenic place with great food and excellent service as my long time friend was coming in to visit from Connecticut. She also wanted a fresh seafood option. Il Fornetto totally fits the bill! We had the fish of the day and a salad. Shared both and portion size was adequate. The fish came garnished with two large wedges of roasted potatoes which were excellent. The arugula salad was fresh and full of pistachios, goat cheese and perfectly dressed. I would definitely come back with company again! More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
(86)
$$$$
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Nice and clean and very tasty More

OpenTable Diner -
Passage Restaurant NYC
Passage Restaurant NYC
Reviews coming soon
European | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Modern Euvropean Restaurant located on Emmons ave. in Brooklyn with Beautiful veiw on Water, we provide A La Carte and Banquet menu with Shows on Weekends, also serving private parties and catering. Check our website www.passagenyc.com or give us a call for more information 1 (718) 368 3434More

Affecte Cafe & Lounge
Affecte Cafe & Lounge
Reviews coming soon
Mediterranean | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

INNOVATING FOR A GLOBAL PALATE SINCE 1987.

Born into our big multicultural family, AFFECTÉ is an eclectic café lounge with a passion for unique experiences. We have fused the best of contemporary Middle Eastern and European cultures with New York City attitude to create an eyeopening experience. Guests can indulge in dishes ranging from traditional Sultan’s kebab plate and filet mignon to hand chopped and hand pressed burgers. We proudly make each and every dish on the menu from scratch to match our standards of perfection. The hookah program showcases an extended flavor profile to satisfy any cravings. Whether part of a big party or a dinner for two, we are excited to be part of it and make your experience unforgettable.More

Sheepshead Bay Diners' Choice Winners

Sheepshead Bay's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Nargis Cafe
Nargis Cafe
(26)
$$$$
Middle Eastern | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was excellent the decor pleasing and the service good BUT: the main courses should have been served all together instead of one of us eating while the others just watched. This was disturbing. More

OpenTable Diner -
Anthony's Place
Anthony's Place
(114)
$$$$
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

See all offers

First time trying Anthony’s. Went on a Friday and they had great happy hour specials. Discounted drinks and appetizers. We had the red sangria which was excellent. We ordered the buffalo calamari, shrimp Oreganata and mussels. Also ordered baked clams from regular menu. Everything was great but the winner was the shrimp! Kelley, our waitress, was great. She was attentive and gave us great recommendations. We were full but ordered the veal chop for dinner and the chopped salad (Bobb salad) to share and the other person had the lasagne. The salad was light and delicious! I tasted the lasagne which I thought was great. The veal chop was a little on the tough side but had great flavor. The chef stopped by the table to see how everything was and gave us a taste of the homemade wine he makes on the house. So good!! Dessert was his homemade Italian cheesecake which was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Next Door
Next Door
(42)
$$$$
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

The food was incredible! The staff were welcoming and friendly. Overall, great dining experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Blu Turkish Restaurant
Blu Turkish Restaurant
(51)
$$$$
Turkish | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Great food !! Everything was delicious.... More

OpenTable Diner -
Il Fornetto
Il Fornetto
(207)
$$$$
Italian | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

I wanted a very scenic place with great food and excellent service as my long time friend was coming in to visit from Connecticut. She also wanted a fresh seafood option. Il Fornetto totally fits the bill! We had the fish of the day and a salad. Shared both and portion size was adequate. The fish came garnished with two large wedges of roasted potatoes which were excellent. The arugula salad was fresh and full of pistachios, goat cheese and perfectly dressed. I would definitely come back with company again! More

OpenTable Diner -
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
Sushi by Bou - Sheepshead Bay
(16)
$$$$
Sushi | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Outstanding!! More

OpenTable Diner -
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
TGI FRIDAYS - Brooklyn (NY)
(86)
$$$$
American | Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Nice and clean and very tasty More

OpenTable Diner -