Two of us ordered filet mignon, and a third ordered porterhouse. All were quite good, though I thought my filet mignon was a little on the salty side. But it was still quite good. The side dishes were good. Total bill with two bottles of malbec was around $400. I actually thought it was a reasonable bill for Midtown Manhattan. I'd go there again.
One of the best ribeyes I have ever had
The best steakhouse in Manhattan. Excellent food and service
Always enjoy lunch with my son at Benjamin’s!
Great place for a meeting or breakfast or dinner.
Second visit in couple of weeks. Go to for steak. Been to every single steak joint in and out of town. The Benjamin is way way up there. Top 5 always.
Excellent service and everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. Steak for 2, wedge salad, and onion rings. their homemade sauce went well with everything. Very high quality restaurant. 5 well earned stars
Be ready for an extra $ 2 charge on top of the cost of a drink if you order a martini (no ice in a drink )on top of a $400 bill for a good steak. Manager has a bad attitude: “everybody does it” so stop complaining. Not my experience, so there is a Better idea, stop going to this place even though the steak was good.
Phenomenal! Service, food and ambience... all excellent as usual.
Usually get their Rib Eye when I go, this time sat at the bar and enjoyed a piping hot dish of pasta bolognese. Very flavorful and a huge portion. Only available at their bar though.
Their cheesecake is a must always, just make sure you leave room for a slice.
Was a recommendation from a friend and we really enjoyed it.
Excellent food with the steak cooked just right . The service was also very good nothing was too much trouble
Once again Benjamin's did not disappoint. From the moment we stepped foot in the door, everyone was more than accommodating, courteous and professional. No issues splitting a steak with my daughter. The food was delicious and the seasoning on the filet was perfect. Thank you for a wonderful dinner to top off a happy fourth of July in the city.
See you all again soon, Ava Spadaro
We found the food to be not comparable with similar steak houses in the area. Service was slow and price was high for the quality of the food
The steak for two was wonderful, and a great value.
It was extraordinary!!!
One of the best ribeyes I have ever enjoyed. Attentive service, but discreet. The penultimate Manhattan steak house experience.
one of the best steak in New York , nice entviroment , nice service . I will definatelly go back
Would recommend Benjamin's food is worth every penny & waiters can't do enough for you
Excellent food, service and ambiance. A true steakhouse.
It was our first time to this restaurant in NY. We had heard good things about it. The restaurant had a very comfortable feel to it especially being a nice steakhouse. The food preparation and quality was excellent with the steaks we had. The lobster bisque was one of my favorites. Crab cakes were very good along with the house special salad. Wine list is very good with good selections in red and whites at comfortable and higher price ranges depending on the type of dinner you are having. Main plus for us was the service. The manager Mario came by our table to see how we were doing a few times. Our server Nick was great. He had good recommendations on the food and preparation as well as being a good guy. The others taking care of the table were very good also with water and keeping things clear in the table. Will definitely go back again when we are back in the area.
Everything it promised, nailed it! Even received complimentary sparkling for to celebrate our honeymoon.
Nice place, quiet, very good service.
Stakes were a bit over cooked.
A little pricey overall, but may go again in the future.
Dining at Benjamin’s was a great experience. The dry aged porterhouse was to die for. Our server Mike & staff were excellent. Thank you Benjamin Steakhouse.
The food was incredible,I had steak for 2 and home fries,broccoli,it was delicious! The service was fast and excellent, our server was Genci. Definitely I’ll be back.
I was here for lunch with my colleagues and we tried porterhouse for 2 ,cream spinach and benjamin home fries witch were amazing
Our waiter Jet was very friendly and professional
Will be back again
I am here always for business lunch!
Great food and excellent service!
Excellent service and great food. It was a great experience for me and my guests
Still in love with this place. I've been coming here for awhile now and it's still one of the best experiences I've received. The food is always stupendous, the services is always outstanding, the atmosphere is always comfortable and I'll always be coming here for years to come. There's no other steakhouse that I would rather be, nothing beats the best and this place is definitely the best.
Amazing service. The food is excellent. Will recommend and return.
Fantastic experience and Our waiter was excellent (Jet)
The food is very good. The Service is excellent. It was very crowded because of the holiday. The price fix menu was excellent with great choices. Then the complimentary cigar and gift certificate to all the Dads was a nice finishing touch.
I went for the Father's day special on a recommendation from a friend, the website said Father's were given a gift card and a cigar. My father received neither.
Always incredible. Go to spot for steak in the city. Even gifted a cigar and a gift card for Father’s Day.
If you haven’t made it here for breakfast you are missing out.
We went there with my 13 yr old son on our last day in New York and it was my son who came across the restaurant by google , we were looking for a good steak in NY and to be sure we were not disappointed.
My wife and son had the lump crab i think it was called ( Large crab cakes ) starter and they said they were superb. I had shrimp starter , four of the biggest prawns i have ever had. For mains my wife and son had the rib eye and they were two of the largest and finest steaks they said they ever had. I had surf and turf , fillet mignon with lobster, shrimp and crab, cooked to perfection and delicious. We only had fries and a bottle of red, nothing else required. Cheese cake and creme caramel to finish again superb.
The restaurant is beautiful large open plan, nice bar with a large fireplace. Waiter staff know the menu so well and are so attentive.
For us this is a treat as it is well above the normal pricing but well worth it. When in New York again we all said we would definitely go back.
John Liz & Tom Dublin Ireland.
Best breakfast in midtown east.
The food was incredible and everyone loved the way the food was prepared and served family style! We had an awesome evening and will definitely go to Benjamins again!
Had the steak for 2 and a ribeye. All delicious. Martinis weren’t bad either