Ben and Jack's Steakhouse 44th Street
Ben and jacks was overall one of the best Resturant I have been too. I give this Resturant a 6 star if there was such thing. Service was great and the food was delicious. I would definitely be coming back.
This place was absolutely fabulous. The food was delicious and very well prepared. The service was excellent. I cannot say enough good things about Ben and Jack's. I had the bone-in ribeye. It was delectable. I have reduced the amount of beef in my diet, so I had not eaten a steak in a while. That steak was enough to make me add steak back to my diet on a regular basis.
I loved it!!!!
Traditional Steak House
Ate outside. Ask for Dino Service superior Food outstanding. Petit filet ample as were the sides
I don't normally write reviews so believe me when I say this restaurant is totally worth it. The service was beyond our expectations and the ambiance was very classy yet relaxing. While the food might be an extra dollar sign in it's classification, it is worth every cent. The fillet mignon was perfect and for the petite size, actually a much larger portion than I expected. The bernaise sauce is a great addition and the asparagus a good choice of side dish. I actually wish we had room to try the dessert! Our compliments to the chef and our waiter!
Visiting from London and catch up with friends over dinner at Ben and Jacks . Best steak I have ever had !! Will definitely recommend to anyone who loves a nice juicy steak!!
First time here. Porterhouse steak for 3 was amazing! Loved the steak sauce! (Not that it needed any sauce but I love a good steak sauce! This one rivals Peter Lugar sauce!). The bacon (thick cut) appetizer was also incredible! Only disappointment was the 4 pound Lobster - was rubbery so not sure if it was over cooked or just a bad lobster but certainly not good any any price and as you can imagine was pretty expensive as lobsters go. Would definitely go back and just skip the crustaceans! 🦞
We were a group of six and the restaurant totally lost interest in us toward the end of our meal. Steaks were served without the gravy and it was a challenge to get the proper sides. There seemed to be issues with the kitchen and with the wait service. Not sure how food got served without the right sides or gravy, who's watching out for this type of thing? Seemed to be an overall management issue.
Exellent food, service and ambiance. The portions are generous so make sure you do not order as suggested. A steak for three is adequate for five.
Always a great experience when we come here. The steaks are always amazing. Great service and never disappointing food. We come back ever time we’re in NYC.
Entire meal from appetizer to dessert was fabulous! They paid attention to everything and our waiter was so friendly and accommodating even though we were ordering the prix fixe. Their sirloin steak was delicious and we make a point to go there on a regular basis, even on holidays. Highly recommend.
The food portions were great. We took advantage of the prefix lunch menu. Great choices and a lot of them. Food was fresh and delicious. The person we took to celebrate her departure loved it. It was her first visit.
Lovely steak house with experienced accommodating waiters. Great selection of starters and entrees.
Excellent from start to finish! Excellent atmosphere cocktails food & service! An unexpected chance that crowned a perfect day!
The food was outstanding. The steak was so perfect and the sides were great. Everything was so in place and I usually take some home but this time I ate everything. This is the only restaurant that I will eat steak
Great service, great food!!! Atmosphere was excellent. Our waiter was very professional.
Always amazing; never disappoints. Steaks were cooked perfectly and the sides were delightful. Service might be their secret recipe. Can’t wait to go back!!
Staff are awesome / food is great / wine pours are solid!
Candy by the hostess stand (Angie) as you leave is a must!
The experience you have at Ben & Jack's Steak House is phenomenal
The ambience is very relaxing and the good is fantastic. Petite filet mignon melt in your mouth and the rib eye is second to none. It was nice to celebrate my son's birthday here.
Excellent Cuisine - Friendly Staff including the Manager - One of the best restaurant in Manhattan
Amazingly delicous rib eye!!!!!! Great service. The only reason I gave it four stars, is that I thought the Lobester Bisque could use some work. It wasn't bad but it was on the fishy side and I've had much better.
The steak is amazing as was our side on Onion Rings. We split the ribeye for one as we are not big eaters and it lasted 3 more meals. They got the steak right.
It was my birthday and they brought me a piece of cheesecake and whipped cream and 3 waiters sang to me after my huge delicious hamburger and fries. Always go there for lunch and the food is outstanding all the time. Very nice owners and excellent wait staff. Go there.
Another great dining experience. Who needs Peter Lugar?
Great Steak and Veal lunch. I should also mention the fabulous mashed potatoes. Fine and attentive service. Extensive wine list caters to all tastes and wallet. Low key and fabulous.
Newly renovated Ben and Jack's, good service, good quality of food, spacious. Went here for a birthday celebration and we availed of the lunch special prefix for $32.99 and it was good. Will recommend! Thanks.
Scallops were wonderful. Steaks were good, but not great. One of ours was ordered medium, came out on the rare side of medium rare, ask to cook it a bit more and came back well done. No much to them outside the butter they were cooked in.
Stopped in for a Drink and we had the Burger and the Sliders! They were both on point BUT that Burger was Phenomenal!
When we were seated, we were placed between two other tables. The volume of their conversations were loud. My wife complained. Immediately Mario, the general manager, moved us to a better table as well as giving us two glasses of champagne. He went above what he could do to please us. Our waiter was great and we had excellent service with the excellent meal. When we ordered dessert, we were given two glasses of port. Completely unnecessary but appreciated. Definitely will go again at our next weekend in NYC.
We have always enjoyed going for the lunch special which is the best bargain in town. The entire meal is prepared with the care they take at dinner and the portions are generous. The French onion soup, sirloin steak and mashed potatoes are fabulous. Highly recommend the key lime pie for dessert. One of our favorite steakhouses at any time. Also, enjoy the nice spacing between tables. A nice selection of wines by the glass, too. Excellent choice for any meal.
This is the best steak I've eaten in Manhattan. The mashed potatoes and broccoli and mixed salad are excellent too. I highly recommend this place. The owners treat you like a special guest every time I go in there for lunch. Very, very good place on the East side.
Amazing food, amazing restaurant.
Everything about Ben and Jack's is fabulous!! From the minute you are greeted when you walk in the door, until the glass of Port is brought after a scrumptious dinner. A wonderful 'Old New York' steakhouse!
Ben & Jacks exceeded our expectations. Quality of food was as good as any steakhouse in NYC and the service was phenomenal. It was a memorable experience here and I would love to come here again! 10/10.
Ben and Jack's has done it again ! Top notch steaks , 1.50 happy hour oysters and top shelf drinks , a great wine list and the best service in NYC . This is by far my favorite steakhouse . Ask for Dino or Timmy for the best service . Dont leave without having a bucket of Schlog! Shout out to Admir, Hodgy,and Eko also Ronnie for another 10 star evening . We will be returning again and again. No other restaurant comes close to Ben and Jack's truly a restaurant like no other !
Good steakhouse - very good meat.
Old fashioned atmosphere.
Arrived 730 1/3 full, departed 9PM 25% full if this is an insufficient comment, please read on.
Waitstaff pleasant but unprofessional, bread tray, an embarrassment; sesame crusted tuna appetizer generous and of good quality. Drinks, meh. How difficult is it to make a gin & tonic? T-bone steak cooked as ordered but tasted slightly gamey and not partucularly tender. German Potatoes slightly over cooked & very salty. Asparagus fine. Chopped salad with shrimp...chopped salad with shrimp. Key lime pie was not but whatever it was, it was interesting. Coffee surprisingly good.
The staff were incredibly kind and helpful. My boyfriend is a butcher and it was the best steak he’s ever had, let alone my steak! It was amazing!! I would highly recommend!!!
Dino was awesome and made my stay memorable. The sirloin was delicious, as were the Brussel Sprouts and Mac & Cheese. The wedge salad was mediocre, but all was redeemed with the beautiful, extremely large, and decadent ice cream sundae with schlag on top! I will go back for sure.
A waiter poured water into our sparkling water glass, the steak is overcooked for medium well, the espresso is expired and the cheesecake is not fresh. You should not expect from its ranking and no more going.
Good food. A little pricey. A little old school with decor and wait staff. Not many people, so quiet. Large portions.