Andrea's 25 of Commack
6 sauted shrimp in our famous Luciano sauce sitting atop a bed of sauted spinach
Sweet Chili Calamari
Classic fried calamari tossed in sweet & spicy chilli sauce
Creamy risotto rolled with mozzarella, pecorino romano & parmigiana reggiano panko breaded then lightly fried served with seasoned ricotta & marinara sauce
Only had a salad and risotto balls app. Salad came soaking wet so dressing pooled in bottom of bowl. They did take it off the bill so that was appreciated. Bartender was very helpful and was very apologetic.
It was girl's night out with my family. We enjoyed a lovely delivious dinner, very relaxed ambiance, and very nice service at Andreas 25.
There has NEVER been a moment when we haven’t been completely thrilled with our experience here. Thank you!!
Wonderful experience. Attentive Service. Great food. Nicely priced. I will be back!!
Dessert menu was slim. Missed the chocolate lava cake. Chicken parm was tough. A little disappointing.
The food was great and so was the service !
Always good food. I like their use of cherry peppers.
Excellent food. We had the salmon, it was cooked perfect and well seasoned. Service was good. Cheesecake is delicious.
Staff was great and the food was extremely fresh and was terrific--I would highly recommend this restaurant
Service is always good. Food was so so. I had escarole and beans on pasta. Spouse had meatball and rigatoni. Friend had chicken meatball. Friend had chicken scarapello(?) All were just ok. They are making due with the Covid crisis and they are doing a good job. Calamari was perfectly cooked and delicious.
Seating in the parking is a difficult situation for all, but the restaurant did as good as it gets
Good food and good service but very expensive drinks
Food was excellent, service was great.
Food was very good will definitely go back again everyone in our party enjoyed their food. We had the meatballs, rack of lamb, risotto was excellent. The octopus special was also excellent. Very loud did have a little problem hearing conversations from the other side of the table some times.
We were a party of 6. Peter our waiter was the best. He was so attentive and very patient. The food and drinks were great. We all picked one of the specials and everyone loved their food. We need to come here more often.
Absolutely loved my experience at Andrea's 25. The service was excellent, and the food was delicious.
Pasta was undercooked, not al dente
Outstanding as always.
Absolutely loved this place. Great good, great service, and a romantic atmosphere. Ordered the Seafood Risotto and I don’t know I want to try anything else because of how good it was. Will be coming back
My first time dining here and was quite pleased. I had the Veal Cinque which was very tender, juicy and fresh. The sauce was delicious...not too saucy, nor oily...just right. It is a small restaurant so my only complaint is the tables were a bit too close to each other.
Food was very good. I recommend the baked clams and calamari appetizers. The seafood risotto was also very good. It was busy on Valentines Day as expected but the service was lacking. The music playing was also extremely loud making it difficult to have a conversation at the table. We had to keep looking for our waiter for service. Overall it is a good restaurant but I would only return on a weekday or off peak hours when it is not so busy.
We went for a birthday celebration. We shared a delicious salad with candied walnuts and goat cheese. A nice size portion to share . I had Bronzino over spinach and my friends ordered two different shrimp dishes . All the dishes were delicious. Service was outstanding.
And of course fried Oreos dessert , you can’t go wrong
The place was packed, amazing service, beautiful place, incredibly delicious food, the staff was amazing, paola the waitress was super friendly, Peter the chef and manager was super nice and makes the best banana bread in history, will definitely be going back again, new favorite place to eat, even the customers are super friend, great atmosphere, highly highly recommend this place.
The food quality was certainly not worth the price. The burrata appetizer came with a slice of tomato that was hard as a rock. The seafood special was short on seafood and the linguini with clams was a mushy mess. To be fair, the veal marsala was notable. The service was rushed apparently to accommodate a second "late" seating. Overall, there are way better Italian restaurants within a 10 minute drive of this place.
Nice wine, fresh vegetables, perfectly cooked and seasoned.
Napoleon was epic,
1st time there! Everything was great!
Service was extremely slow although the restaurant was not crowded
Birthday meal. Was amazing
Great as always
The food and service were great. Enjoyed the special. My only complaint was that the restaurant was very noisy which made it difficult to have a conversation.
Food was excellent, but the restaurant was very noisy
Favorite restaurant! Nicest and most accommodating staff and best food!
Birthday dinner with friends
The specials were delicious.
The food here is excellent, and the service superb. For example, after only one prior experience here, the waiter remembered my husband's drink order, and he refilled my soda just as I was taking the last sip of my first one. Portions are also large, and selections quite varied. My only complaint is that it's very loud, but I can overlook that drawback given the other pluses.
Food is very good but after 7:00pm you cannot hear what the person next to you is saying as it is tremendously loud
food was very good along with the service. I would recommend this restuarant
Always great. Delicious meal.
Always amazing delicious food great service great drinks
The cost of food was ridiculously overpriced for the amount of food . I mean to charge $14.95 for 2 small egg rolls, 14.95 for 4 mini, I mean mini rice balls. What are they even thinking . The food was good but not worth that much money for what they feel was a portion. This is Italian restaurant and italians are known for feeding people plentiful . This was embarrassing to bring anyone looking for italian food We all left hungry and broke!
Andrea's 25 of Commack is rated 4.6 stars by 862 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.