Andrea's 25 of Commack
Rate your experience
Restaurants you may also like
Love the food. Service is great. The owner is wonderful. Always asks if everything was good!!
The food is consistently excellent
Awesome food. Great service. My favorite Italian place of all
Wonderful experience and Andrea's 25. Food and staff were amazing.
Thank you for making my daughters birthday celebration wonderful!
It was wonderful
Food is good but missing some things. The Shrimp Luciano is served on some spinach. It really needs pasta or risotto. We ordered two Caesar salad for three people and for what we were charged thought it was skimpy. It's okay but nothing to rave about.
Great food and Great service. VERY noisy. but I blame that on the table next to us..
Dinner with my daughter. Always a great meal
The food and staff at Andrea’s never disappoints. The manager, Anthony, was friendly and seated us right away and checked in throughout the evening to see if everything was to our liking. The food was outstanding as always, from the avocado salad and risotto balls, to chicken aria, and napoleon for dessert. Wonderful and friendly staff. Can’t wait to go back!
We had a 7:00 reservation & had 3 courses. After paying the bill & finishing up our meal, at 8:45 we were asked to leave because someone was waiting for the table! This was totally unprofessional & uncalled for since we weren’t lingering too long. They offered to buy us a drink at the bar but we had to drive & wanted to be responsible. They ended our evening with friends abruptly. We will never dine there again due this treatment.
Bar area was lively upon arrival. Seated on-time (actually early). Server was attentive, friendly, accurate. Manager checked in to ensure all was well. A very nice evening.
Sal our waiter was amazing, Great experience The Lamb hops are the Best
First time here and will certainly not be my last time! The place was jamming and didn’t expect great service but that was quite the contrary. The service was great! Peter was our server and he was extremely friendly and accommodating. The food was outstanding! Muscles were some of the best I ever had and so was the shrimp over spinach. Good wine list for bottles.....had the 2013 Conn Creek. Can’t wait to go back.
Excellent dinner once again. Jad the Rosemary Lamb chops.
Delicious. Definitely will return.
Great food with healthy portions but a little pricy. More like NYC restaurants. Very noisy but food made up for noise.
Excellent meal! Fantastic service! Highly recommend.
Great food and service on Saturday night 3/16. We loved it and will be back!
Andrea's never disappoints. Great food. Great service.
A little too busy and loud for a date
Really should install noise absorbers but very sweet wait staff
Great food and service always, very consistent. Our go to place.
The restaurant was really nice. Pretty place, great staff, service & delicious food. We sat at the bar until we were seated & the bartender was very nice & made sure our drinks were to our likings. The host was extremely nice & made sure we were well taken care of through out the evening. Food was excellent & was not expensive. I highly recommend this restaurant.
I choose this place to celebrate my birthday with my husband and another couple, was the first time for all of us and we love the place. Great service and the food was delicious. We're having such an awesome time that we didn't realized that the place was about to closed and we're the last table seating. I definitely will go back and I highly recommend this restaurant.
The restaurant was wonderful. Our server was professional and efficient. My entire family enjoyed their meal. My only concern was a few patrons who were obviously over served and were loud and obnoxious....nothing that the restaurant could have done!!! My mom who turned 89 couldn't have been happier!
Second time a charm. Excellent dinner. Loved the rack of lamb. Will definitely be back.
We went there for my husband’s birthday with our three little kiddos. We had and early reservation and my kids are great in dining out so not worried at all bringing them to a fine dining restaurant. The food was excellent, service was attentive and partner/owner working that was so friendly and really made sure each table enjoyed their experience. My son said it was one of his favorite restaurants- he’s 8 years old. Lol. The food was fresh, delicious, appetizers could be a tad larger but I understand it’s not “family-style” portions so I get it. They have kid options on menu too. Wine selection was decent as well! Definitely recommend! We’ll be regulars.
Andrea’s is consistently superb .... food, service, Billy behind the bar... always an incredible meal! Seafood risotto Luciano is the best dish ever!!
Great experience- thank you!
The food was delicious as always. It was the perfect place to celebrate Valentine’s Day
Went there on Valentines Day. Food and service were excellent. Prices were average. Would definitely go back again.
For Being a holiday night food was awesome and service was great. Was a little noisy but that was to be expected
Service was great. My family enjoyed each dish they ordered.
My family came on a Sunday and I was not aware that they did not open up until 4 pm
I tried calling at 1 and no one was there. Again at 2, and then 3. I reached someone at
around 3:30-4:00 and I was able to get the reservation time I wanted.
I was pleasantly surprise when someone from the restaurant called me.
Would definitely recommend
Great food and service. Our waiter Peter was great. Can’t wait to go back.
Food and service was very good. I did think the dining room was a bit loud though
It was all very nice, relaxed and satisfying.
Some of the dishes are pricey but overall very nice.
Unfortunately we were seated at a high top table in the bar. The table was a bit too small and too close to the bar. As it filled up, we had people practically leaning on our table while we were trying to enjoy our meal. The waiter, however, was very nice and paid just the right amount of attention.
Food is always fresh and delicious. Sausage and Broccoli Rabe eggrolls are a must. Shrimp Lilliana is to die for. Cocktails are top shelf. You leave restaurant wanting to come back. Can't say enough good about Andrea's 25.
Great food lobster ravioli amazing!
As always, delicious food and wonderful service. Andreas 25 never disappoints.
Went out to dinner with friends! The waiter was great and the food was absolutely delicious!