1794 The Whiskey Rebellion
Our food is simple and honest, created from ingredients sourced (locally when possible) from sustainable American farmers.
Our bar is based on the "farm to shaker" concept. Using the highest quality ingredients to pair with our small batch and locally distilled spirits & extensive whiskey list.
Our primary concern is the health and safety of our guests and staff. You will see that we are taking all precautions to ensure that you are safe while dining with us. All of our tables are 6 feet apart to allow for social distancing. At the bar we have glass dividers that give you a protective barrier from guests next to you. All of our servers, chefs and bartenders wear masks and gloves. Our employees wash hands and change gloves frequently. We are constantly sanitizing all touch points.
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waiting staff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
american caught wild salmon | 1794 bourbon-cherry butter | cherry plank smoked | sautéed greens | yukon smash
filet medallions | bastille 1789 whiskey butter
filet of beef | demi-glace | cabernet | keswick cheeses | garlic | cavatappi noodles
Zack was outstanding. Attentive and pleasant. Knowledgeable. We will be back. The food was excellent
Great food and Service.
We are happy to hear you enjoyed the great food and had great service! Thank you for leaving such a nice five star review. We hope to see you in again soon. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Our server was awesome! The food we ordered was excellent as well as the drinks. We had an old fashioned and a Bourbon Betty that were done to perfection. The atmosphere is really cool. Only wish was that we were closer to the fireplace especially since we had reservations but still great atmosphere.
Hello Pam! We are very excited to hear you had an amazing experience dining at our establishment. It brings us joy to know you enjoyed the service, food and drinks. For future reference if you are wanting to dine next to the fireplace we recommend just leaving a note that you would like to request the table located directly next to the fire and we will make it happen! We hope to see you again soon! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Get the shepherds pie! Amazing!
Wow! Thank you so much for leaving a five star review and we are so happy to hear you were able to enjoy our shepherds pie. Our kitchen staff does their very best to make sure every dish goes out to perfection and that the flavors are always satisfying. We hope we are able to see you in again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Food and ambiance was great! Hostess sat us in the corner of the dinning room off the main room with fireplace! We asked to be moved as there were no customers in the main dinning with fireplace that had a nice ambiance! They then moved us to that room that gave you a much nicer feel! Waitress didn’t give us any specials and didn’t know the menu. Did her best to accommodate us and the food came out quickly. Drink options were very good and plenty of food for the money!
Huge variety of whiskeys as well as fully stocked bar. Server was Zach- friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. Food is good and moderately priced. Not a cheap evening but we’ll worth it. Heads up entrance is by Comfort Inn- a little hidden unless you are looking
First off thank you for such a great review! We do try very hard in order to keep our whiskey selection the best in the whole county and it is something we are extremely proud of! Also, our kitchen staff does an incredible job assuring that every meal is cooked with passion to make sure no one goes home hungry. To us being inside the hotel allows us to have a hole in the wall type of feel and that makes it a unique experience and we hope you feel so as well and are able to comeback again soon!
Delicious food and prompt, courteous service
We are happy and glad to hear we were able to provide you with a great experience and we are looking forward to the next time you are able to join us in at the Whiskey Rebellion!
Kenzie is so sweet. The food was delicious and her recommendation on the strawberry dessert was perfect. Can’t speak highly enough about Kenzie!! She made our date night so special.
I am so glad to hear you enjoyed your service by Kenzey! Being that she is our newest server she still feels intimidated but as you experienced she is truly a great person to provide amazing service. We hope you find time to come in again soon and do not forget to request her as your server. We are looking forward to when we see you again in at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Our server Autumn was incredibly knowledgeable regarding food and drink at the establishment and was personable as well as entertaining. Would highly recommend both restaurant and server.
We are so happy to hear that you were able to have a very enjoyable experience here at our establishment! It is to no surprise Autumn was able to provided incredible service since she is a great person and an amazing server! We hope you are able to find time again soon to come in and dine at the Whiskey Rebellion and we are looking forward to taking care of you. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Zach waited on us and gave us a great dining experience. He was very attentive, funny, and helpful. The food was delicious and plentiful. We highly recommend!
Thank you so much for such a great review! It makes us happy to hear we were able to provide such an enjoyable evening for you and I will definitely be passing along your comment to Zach which I am sure he will enjoy very much. We hope we are able to see you soon here at the Rebellion and we are looking forward to taking great care of you again. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
The food was very good but we had to wait for our drinks then two were not available waiter was great but drinks took to long to be brought to us.
I do apologize about the inconvenience about how long drinks were taking to arrive at your table. I am happy to hear though that you enjoyed the food very much and hopefully you are willing to comeback in another time to give us another try! If you do I personally will make sure everything goes perfectly for you and that you have a great evening. We are looking forward to seeing you in again soon at the Rebellion. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
It was a chilly night to eat outside, but the heaters kept us nice and warm. The service was friendly and helpful with recommendations - especially from the massive whiskey cocktail menu. I highly recommend the onion rings, fries, and Molly Pitcher pretzels.
We try our hardest to keep our patio nice and cozy no matter what the weather is like so we are happy to hear you were able to enjoy yourself while eating out in the fresh air! We hope to see you soon here at the Rebellion and we are looking forward to taking great care of you again! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
We had a wonderful evening, wonderful meals, the atmosphere was warm and inviting and we look forward to visiting again soon! :)
Hello Diana! We are very glad to hear that you and your group were able to enjoy a wonderful evening here at our establishment! Thank you for leaving such a kind review and we are also looking forward to the next time you are able to stop in at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Excellent food with a variety of menu choices. My sister has celiac and enjoyed a gf meal and cheesecake! Service was awesome!
We try our hardest to make sure no matter what the concern is that everyone leaves full and satisfied so we are happy to hear that you and your sister were able to indulge in our menu items! We hope that we did a well enough job that we will be seeing you again soon in at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Great food, service and ambiance. Definitely recommend!
Wow thank you so much for such a great review! We are happy that we were able to give you a five star experience and we are looking forward to taking care of you again soon the next time you are in at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Steaks and drinks were excellent. Service was friendly but unusually slow. Request to not sit at the table in front of the door.
I do apologize about the inconvenience of the table location you were sat at. For future reference I would always recommend specifically asking for a certain table such as the booths or even to stay warm request the table by the fireplace. We hope you are willing to come in and give us another chance to make up on the lack of ambience you did not receive on your previous visit. I will personally make sure your next visit is perfection! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
This place is AWESOME!!!! Anthony is a top notch manager who really cares about the customers and his staff. All the staff are second to none. We especially recommend Mary. She is very attentive, professional, and polite. PLEASE GO AT LEAST ONCE
Wow, such an 'AWESOME' review! We are beyond thankful for such a glorifying review and are happy that as a team we can provide such a great experience for you! I personally am also very thankful for the kind words which makes me proud of my team and the job that I have. We are very much looking forward to seeing you again soon!:) -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Good and drink were great, pricey but worth it! I love the history of it all too!
Thank you so much for your five star review! We try very hard to make the expense worth every penny and we are glad you were able to indulge in our crafted menu items! We hope we are able to see you again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
The service was great. Zach did a very good job. Cocktails were very good and food was fantastic.
Deviled eggs and pretzel were great apps.
Everyone's dinner entree was cooked perfectly and tasted great.
Definitely will be back.
I am very happy to hear that we were able to provide such a great night for your evening out! We are happy to hear that you enjoyed both the food and cocktails that you are already planning your next visit to dine at our establishment! We are looking forward to taking care of you again soon. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
I surprised my wife w/ dinner here for our 16th wedding anniversary. We had a wonderful time the drinks were good, the food was great and the service was outstanding. Thanks for making our anniversary nice Logan
Thank you so much for choosing us to celebrate such a significant evening! We are super glad to hear we were able to give you an incredible experience and that Logan gave you great service. We hope we are able to provide you such a quality service again soon! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Traveling from Cleveland to New Jersey perfect stop for dinner in a very cute town. Everything was wonderful mushroom/prime rib appetizer, crab cakes, rib eye, and cocktails!!
Well thank you for making us your spot to rest and fuel up before the rest of your trip! We are happy to hear that we were able to give you a great experience and that you were able to indulge in our delicious food and cocktails. We hope you get the chance again soon to stop on in at the Rebellion and we are looking forward to the next time you are in town! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Great food and drinks. recommend the prime rib special.
I am happy to hear that you enjoyed your experience at our establishment! Our prime rib weekend special is definitely something we are proud of! Make sure the next time you are in town to stop in at the Rebellion!
I loved this restaurant, the other great thing about 1794 is that, it is very close to me in Carlisle.
So glad we did a good enough job that you love us! We try hard to stick to the history of Carlisle since we are located right downtown in the historical district! We are looking forward to the next time you are able to come in and dine at the Whiskey Rebellion. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Very good food. We go for our anniversary every year.
It makes us very happy that we are your go to restaurant to celebrate your anniversary every year! We hope that we always give great service and cook delicious food for you to continue coming in to celebrate such an important occasion! We are looking forward to seeing you in again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
The food was delicious and the service was great. We'll definitely go back again!
We are so glad to hear that you were able to indulge in our delicious food and had great service! We are very much looking forward to having you back again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
This was a last minute-ish reservation for Thanksgiving I am unfamiliar with the area and chose it after an open table search. The staff was friendly, the ambience was comfortable and the food was outstanding! The bullet bourbon egg nog and the egg nog crème brûlée were so good my sister & I were still talking about them the next day. Great find in an unexpected place !
Thank you so much for choosing us as the location for your thanksgiving meal! It brings us great joy to hear you had an amazing time and enjoyed yourselves so much. We are also happy to hear you liked our specials for the evening and that you felt comfortable dining in our establishment. We hope to see you again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion and are looking forward to it. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Excellent choice for Thanksgiving. The turkey was moist and tasted great and they also had the regular menu available. It was an excellent price.
Service was perfect.
Thank you so much for choosing us as your location for your thanksgiving meal! We are very pleased to hear you had a wonderful time and that we were able to provide great service. We hope to see you in again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
The 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion was wonderful. Great selections of Whiskey along with wonderful food. They had a great twist on the chicken potpie which was wonderfully tasty. Their onion rings were fabulous. The steak medallions were cooked perfectly though a little tough. The waitress was wonderful and knowledge about the whiskey and food. We had a wonderful evening!
I am so glad you had a wonderful time at our establishment! We try very hard to keep up with the changing whiskey trends in order to have the best selection in our area! I am also happy to hear that you were able to enjoy the food and was given amazing service by our staff! It is our goal to make sure everyone is happy and full before leaving. We hope to see you in again soon at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Excellent food and drinks. Service was outstanding
Thank you for leaving such a great review! We are super glad we were able to give you an amazing experience and that you enjoyed the food and drinks plus the service was outstanding! We hope we did well enough to get you to comeback again soon. We are looking forward to seeing you in at the Whiskey Rebellion. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Food was good! Portions just right. Definitely taste the farm to table experience. All staff was polite and great.
I am super glad to hear you were able to have an enjoyable experience and was able to taste the local farms in our meals! We try our hardest to make it comfortable for everyone and make sure that nobody goes home hungry. We hope to see you again soon in at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
This was a great unique restaurant and bar. Great selection of bourbons and cocktails
I am super happy to hear you were able to enjoy your experience at our establishment and were able to indulge in our carefully selected whiskey collection! We hope you are able to stop in again soon at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
We were skeptical when we found out it was located in a comfort inn but decided to just try it anyway. I wish we wouldn’t have. The food was over cooked, over seasoned or just no seasoning at all. Very much like a mass produced meal with little attention to quality. Then came drinks…first we were told it’s a full bar but any time we asked for something other than whiskey they didn’t have it. I figured better just try an old fashioned…they have a menu of just old fashions…I opened it and there were four different kinds. I picked one and looked at the price..$25 per drink. Seriously…everyone sells Bourbon or whiskey and almost everyone can make an old fashioned…do NOT pay them $25 that’s crazy. We opted for the bill and decided this was the last we had seen whiskey Rebellion.
Last I leave you with a mental picture. Take a low end hotel that you’ve had to stay in and go find the area that they serve free breakfast in daily…now set a wooden fake wall in front of the juice machine and you have the dining room.
If you go, just know the quality you can expect
The service was wonderful. Autumn took great care of me. Food was piping hot when it arrived at my table and tasted wonderful. My beef medallions were cooked to perfection.
I am super happy to hear that you received great service from Autumn and were able to enjoy the food! We hope to see you in again soon at the Whiskey Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Our waiter was great. Service and food was outstanding
I am super happy to hear that you had great service by one of our servers and that you also thought the quality of food was outstanding! We hope we did a good enough job to have you come again soon and we are looking forward to seeing you at the Rebellion the next time! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
They managed to get us in on a very busy night and even moved us to a better table when it opened up.
Super happy we were able to get you in especially on a heavily reserved evening. I am glad that you were able to enjoy yourselves and that you had a great experience with us. We hope you are able to stop in again soon and we are looking forward to having you back at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
First time at 1794 Whiskey Rebellion. Excellent service. Appetizer of mushrooms with shaved beef were delicious. The bread that came with it was amazing. Very campy and buttery. My husband and I both had steaks. Slightly over cooked, but still very good. I recommend the hassle back potato as a side dish. Pumpkin Creme Brûlée for dessert was awesome.
For your first time at the Whiskey Rebellion I am so happy to hear that it was an amazing experience! Our staff tries very hard both front of house and back of house in order to give an excellent dining experience and we are proud to have had you join in on that! We hope to see you in again soon at the Rebellion. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Food and whisky was fantastic.
Our kitchen does an incredible job on keeping up with cooking everything to the best that they can and for years it has been a challenge to get the collection of whiskey that we have; our collection is what makes us unique and is something we are proud of! With so many whiskies to try we hope to see you back in again soon at the Rebellion! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
Mary was very attentive and took great care of us! Food was delicious and espresso martinis were very good!
I am very glad to hear that Mary was able to give you awesome service and that she took great care of you! It is also a good thing to hear you enjoyed the food and the espresso martinis, even though we are a whiskey house we still try our best to make the best of the best cocktails no matter what kind of alcohol that it is! We hope to see you again soon. -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
The food was delicious. Our table had the stroganoff, bourbon chicken, crab cakes and trout. Everything was cooked to perfection. Zack our server was very attentive and pleasant. We had the hot baked cookie with ice cream for dessert. The building was beautiful too. We will definitely go back anytime we are in the area.
They said they were short staffed and it showed. Very polite staff who were doing their best.
Sadly it is very difficult in todays time to be able to stay fully staffed up. We try our hardest to not allow that to be an excuse and I am glad to hear your experience was pleasant with our very hard working team. I truly hope you are willing to give us another go in order to have an amazing occasion to make up for the last one! Please reach out to me when you do and I will personally make sure your night is unforgettable in a great way! -Anthony Tubbs (Restaurant Manager)
1794 The Whiskey Rebellion is rated 4.7 stars by 694 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.